Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 11th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Zimbabwe's rich in no rush for change



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 23 March 2008
WHITE egrets peck on mown grass verges near the Serenity Nursery as ornamental palms flutter outside high-security walls. In the wooded hills behind the red-brick Heritage School, there are glimpses of the huge roofs of Hollywood-style mansions.
This is Borrowdale Brooke, on the edge of what Harare residents call the "dale-dailies", plush northern suburbs populated by the capital's elite: ministers, army generals, bankers, new Chinese investors and whites who have managed to withstand a decade of economic turmoil.

Robert Mugabe's nephew, Phillip Chiyangwa, lives in a white Spanish-style villa with a helipad. Chiyangwa, a property mogul who counts a Humvee among his fleet of luxury vehicles, has a computerised system to help him select what to wear from a dazzling array of designer suits.

In the run-up to presidential elections next weekend, Chiyangwa has spent thousands of pounds bringing international football matches to Zimbabwe's state TV in a bid to improve the popularity of the 84-year-old president's ruling Zanu-PF party.

It is the rich elite who are desperate to see Mugabe win Saturday's polls, warned Harare's recently consecrated Anglican bishop, Sebastian Bakare, in a pastoral letter last week.

Bakare, who is locked in a bruising battle with ousted pro-Mugabe bishop Nolbert Kunonga, castigated the "few who manipulate the situation to their profit. They hold on fast to what they have."

Change – chinja in Shona, the language of the majority – is the slogan of the main opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) of former trade unionist Morgan Tsvangirai, who is leading in the latest opinion poll with 28.3% support, compared with Mugabe's 20.3%. Independent presidential candidate Simba Makoni, a former member of Mugabe's cabinet, is also promising changed leadership.

But for the political elite, "a changed future is very unwelcome", Bakare said.

With his catastrophic white land grab, launched in 2000, and last year's onslaught against businesses, Mugabe has wrecked a once prosperous economy.

With inflation running at more than 100,580%, shoppers needed Z$15m to buy a loaf of bread this week, half a farm worker's monthly salary. A single toilet roll cost Z$25m .

Many Zimbabweans are living on sadza wejongwe, the staple mealie-meal porridge laced with a salt-water mixture they have to pretend is chicken soup, a state newspaper admitted last month. But Borrowdale Brooke Spar supermarket shows no signs of hardship.

The store's car park is packed with Mercedes and BMWs. Its gleaming aisles would not be out of place in Scotland.

Fancy some Cocoa Pops? A box will set you back Z$275m, way over a domestic worker's monthly pay. Granulated chlorine for the pool? That'll be Z$2.8bn per two-litre container, not far off the Z$3.4bn monthly salary Mugabe awarded teachers last week.

The Zimbabwean president said they should be "very happy" with that.

Borrowdale Brooke Spar is where the sleek and the satisfied shop, tiny mobile phones stuck to their ears. "Yes, things are fine, business is good," laughs one man.

Zimbabweans joke that they have the highest IQ in the world because they queue for hours for scarce commodities. Shoppers queue at this Spar, too, but only because they have to wait for those in front of them to get their laden trolleys past the checkout.

One man's bill on Friday for meat, orange juice, cabbage and bottled water came to Z$24bn – about £400 at the parallel market rate but a staggering £400,000 at the official rate Mugabe uses.

"Someone important," whispers the checkout assistant. The supermarket is owned by the Mashonaland East governor, Ray Kaukonde.

It was spared the ravages of last year's price blitz. Earlier this month Kaukonde, who is also a partner in a lucrative car dealership, appeared at a rally pledging his support – and that of his province – to Mugabe. "You will see that we are still behind you," he said.

In a country where poverty levels hover around 80%, money talks.

Zimbabweans are fascinated by the rich and famous, such as Jocelyn Chiwenga, wife of Constantine Chiwenga, the commander of Zimbabwe's armed forces.

She shops at an exclusive interior design store in Borrowdale and made £0.5m selling sugar snaps and mange-touts from a seized white farm to the west.

Transport magnate Isau Mupfumi, from the eastern border city of Mutare, was a policeman less than 10 years ago. Now he lives like a football star, maintaining a fleet of at least 10 high-powered vehicles, including a fuel-guzzling Humvee.

"I drive it when I want to relax and savour everything," Mupfumi told the state Manica Post newspaper late last year.

"People should not see my buying cars as a show-off. The fact that I buy top-of-the-range is simply that I can afford them."

Mupfumi – who the party absolved of black market fuel deals last year – is standing as a Zanu-PF candidate for the Mutasa-Nyanga seat in the upper house.

Mugabe operates his government "along feudal lines", says local economist John Robertson. The president has granted land and privileges such as fuel concessions, duty-free imports and absurdly low exchange rates to a few hundred top officials "so they remain loyal to the party".

Some, Robertson says, are top military officers who served in the Democratic Republic of Congo in the late 1990s. They were able to benefit from mineral and timber concessions awarded to Zimbabwe and came back with "very considerable amounts of money".

"We know their salaries. They wouldn't have earned that sort of money in five lifetimes. They must have had diamonds to exchange," Robertson says, warning that senior police and military can order those below them to vote for the president.

Constantine Chiwenga has already announced he will salute no president but Mugabe, "who has sacrificed a lot for the country".

In Harare this weekend, fuel queues began lining up outside garages. The next few days could be "volatile", an MDC official warned privately.

Stranglehold on power

1980: Robert Mugabe becomes prime minister after the Zanu party wins independence elections.

1982: Government forces are accused of killing thousands of civilians in a civil war against forces backing Zapu leader Joshua Nkomo, right.

1987: Mugabe and Nkomo unite to form Zanu-PF, ending the violence.

• Mugabe becomes president after changing constitution.

1998: An economic crisis marked by high interest rates and inflation provokes riots.

1999: The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) is formed and union leader Morgan Tsvangirai is appointed leader.

2000:

• Mugabe's ruling Zanu-PF wins a parliamentary election amid charges of fraud and vote-rigging by the opposition.

• Thousands of so-called independence war veterans, backed by the government, seize white-owned farms.

2002: Mugabe wins election pitting him against Tsvangirai, right. Observers condemn poll as flawed and unfair. Commonwealth suspends Zimbabwe.

2003: IMF begins steps to expel Zimbabwe over dues unpaid since 2001. Commonwealth summit agrees to continue suspension, leading Mugabe to pull Zimbabwe out of the organisation.

2004: High Court acquits Tsvangirai of plotting to assassinate Mugabe.

2005: Zanu-PF wins parliamentary election, giving it the majority it needs to change the constitution.

• About 700,000 people lose their homes or livelihoods in the demolition of urban slums.

2007: Tsvangirai badly beaten after he attempts to attend a banned protest rally.

• Mugabe is stripped of his honorary degree from Edinburgh University following a campaign led by students and Scotland on Sunday.

2008: Presidential and parliamentary elections scheduled for March 29 pose the biggest threat yet to Mugabe's rule.

Opposition leaders accuse Mugabe of rigging poll

Nelson Banya
in Harare


ZIMBABWE'S main opposition party last week accused Robert Mugabe of rigging the election by changing the law to let police escort voters to polling booths.

Senior police officers have come out in public to back Mugabe, facing the strongest challenge to his rule on Saturday amid a deepening economic crisis.

The election law was changed last year to bar police from coming within 100 yards of polling stations to ensure they could not influence the vote. The change followed South African-brokered talks between the ruling party and opposition.

But Mugabe used his presidential powers last week to reverse the change so police officers would be able to assist illiterate and disabled voters in polling booths.

"One of the players is now acting like a referee and pretending to be a competitor. Are we really in an election or are we in a contest already decided by one man?" said Morgan Tsvangirai, leader of the larger faction of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).

Mugabe will also be facing ruling party defector Simba Makoni in the presidential vote, being held alongside presidential, parliamentary and municipal elections. He said his opponents were Western puppets and prostitutes.

Tsvangirai said opposition concerns over the electoral process – such as irregularities on the voter register – had not been addressed. He complained of limited access in state media and said some of his party's rallies had been blocked.

The party said the distribution of polling stations was skewed in favour of Mugabe's rural strongholds. It also said it was worried votes might be counted centrally rather than at polling stations – making it easier to cheat.

"I will not be part of an illegal process," Tsvangirai said.

Zimbabwe has banned vote observers from countries critical of Mugabe but an observer mission from countries in the Southern African Development Community (SADC) said it believed the atmosphere was conducive to a fair poll.

"It does not appear likely that anyone in SADC would have the guts to stand up to Mugabe," said Tendai Biti, a senior official in Tsvangirai's faction.

"The SADC observer mission in Zimbabwe can state that the election will be free and fair despite gross and evident electoral abuse."

Makoni said that the electoral playing field was not even, noting limited coverage by state media and that his supporters were being intimidated by members of the ruling party Zanu-PF.

He said: "We remain hopeful, certainly desirous of an outcome reflecting the will of the people but remain anxious and concerned as to the integrity of the process." .

US-based Human Rights Watch has accused the government of using violence to intimidate opponents and using state subsidised food to gain an advantage.

Mugabe warned the opposition against Kenyan-style violence if they lose.

"If Tsvangirai and his group have such plans, they must stand warned," Mugabe told about 20,000 cheering supporters in his rural home district of Zvimba.

"That will never happen here, never, never. We will never allow it."

Mugabe said he would romp to a landslide victory to shame former colonial power Britain, which he accuses of funding the MDC and Makoni.

The veteran leader threatened that his government could in future retaliate against British interests in Zimbabwe, saying sanctions – designed to target Zimbabwe's leaders – were hurting his country.

The full article contains 1826 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 22 March 2008 7:38 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Zimbabwe
 
1

indune1,

Canada 23/03/2008 00:28:37

What a basket case.

The gutless UN should have done something about Mugabe years ago.

2

W Smith,

Middle East 23/03/2008 01:00:50
What did Salmond, the economist, do for Zimbabwe's poor again?

Oh... I remember now... he wrote to the regime on his anti-Trident stance.

I'm sure Zimbabwe's poor are just oozing with gratitude for the SNP then eh?

In their time of suffering at the hands of socialist Mugabe, our Alex the socialist steps in with a Christmas-y type message of hope, peace and prosperity through anti-Tridentism!

IDIOT!

Maybe if Lexus driving, two salaries, Salmond was forced to eat nothing but the type of porridge described in this article for a few months then that might wake him up from his 'Butchers Apron' fantasy land.
3

Marky Bhoy,

Dunfermline 23/03/2008 01:50:59
Mr Smith

Perhaps the most pathetic anti SNP post I have ever seen .

If there is some way of exchanging home addresses you have a Chocolate Easter egg to pick up
4

Very Rev Ian Paisley,

23/03/2008 07:06:30
Given their corruption and desire to enrich themselves, at the expense of the poor, I would not be surprised if Mugabe and Labour are bedfellows.

Hang on a minute:

senior members of the Labour party, including Neil Kinnock helped get Mugabe into power in the first place.
5

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 23/03/2008 07:09:31
A great country brought to its knees; first by stupid Ian Smith supporters, then by greedy Robert Mugabe-ites. South Africa next?
6

Very Rev Ian Paisley,

23/03/2008 07:09:40
W Smith

It was the UK Labour party who helped get Mugabe into power.

Much of the support from African leaders is because Mugabe puts up two fingers at the past colonial rulers. Zimbabwe is the UK's fault past and present.
7

,

23/03/2008 07:35:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Conan,

Chile 23/03/2008 07:37:13
Entirely correct, #6. The 'Zimbabwe' problem, like many problems around the world, is a creation of Britains (mainly England's) global theft and destruction in past centuries ..... which past the British (English) seem most reluctant to accept, acknowledge or pay for.
9

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 23/03/2008 08:29:36
#7 Media.

Haiti didn't exist 900 years ago! That island's peoples then were Caribs, not negro slave descendants. These came after Columbus in 15C/16C/17C/18C. You'll know the definition of a slave which is someone stupid enough to be caught and sold, thus passing on and concentrating the stupid gene. This applies to the underclasses of any race, colour or faith.

Ian Smith ruined Rhodesia by refusing Wilson's offer of no majority rule before 2000 AD. That gap could have been filled with educating Africans properly and fully. Mugabe would never have been heard of. Missed opportunity or what?
10

Richardinho,

23/03/2008 08:49:13
Bet if the Scotsman has a counterpart called 'the Zimbabwean', it's the biggest cheerleader for Mugabe.
11

Media 1,

cape town 23/03/2008 09:07:29
Rules

Thank you for checking up! Now that you have you will BE FORCED to admit that its been 200 years of chaos and absolute degeneration.
You have no idea what Africa is like, none at all!
Zimbabwe was not ruined by Ian Smith! You say that Europeans should have educated blacks properly, but why? Why could blacks not educate themselves? Oh yes thats right, let the white man invent, innovate and carry the rest on his shoulders.
I agree that Europeans could have done things differently, but that is only with the gift of hindsight!
Tell me this. Why during apartheid in South Africa, was the Indian community in SA able to look inward and grow their own economies, teach their children at their own schools and operate within a very well organised system, but black communities were not?
Why was the white community during international sanctions able to look inward and grow technology and economy without imploding?
Why? Go on, educate me.
12

Media 1,

cape town 23/03/2008 09:11:09
Rulesnorules

And what about the following?
The SA minister of health wants to use garlic and beetroot to treat aids. The minister of safety and security wants people who cannot stand the crime to leave. AND WHAT ABOUT THIS?

Can you imagine working for a company that has a little more than 500 employees and has the following statistics: 29 have been accused of spousal abuse; 7 have been arrested for fraud;19 have been accused of writing bad cheques; 117 have directly or indirectly bankrupted at least 2 businesses; 3 have done time for assault; 71 cannot get a credit card due to bad credit; 14 have been arrested on drug-related charges; 8 have been arrested for shoplifting; 21 are currently defendants in lawsuits; 84 have been arrested for drunk driving in the last year 373 in total or approximately 70%. Can you guess which organization this is? Give up yet? its the 535 members of the SOUTH AFRICAN PARLIAMENT

13

Very Rev Ian Paisley,

TIA 23/03/2008 09:47:49
This is Africa.

learned well from the white settlers did they not?

Create a wealthy few and impoverish the rest.

I liked the bit about 'duty free' imports and

"meat, orange juice, cabbage and bottled water came to Z$24bn – about £400 at the parallel market rate but a staggering £400,000 at the official rate Mugabe uses"

Who controls the food I wonder. No tatty famines I hope
14

Electric Hermit,

23/03/2008 10:06:36
#2 W Smith

What an impressive collection of contrived non sequiturs and perfect nonsense! There is a strange, almost poetic beauty in an utterance so completely deranged.
15

oder,

Scotland 23/03/2008 10:46:55
5 Rulesbutnotrulers,Federation, not separation

you said

Ian Smith ruined Rhodesia by refusing Wilson's offer of no majority rule before 2000 AD. That gap could have been filled with educating Africans properly and fully. Mugabe would never have been heard of. Missed opportunity or what?

I think on another thread you also mention a British guarantee, unfortunately a British guarantee is not worth the paper its written on,the latest people to accept a British assurance the Serbs have found to their cost that, faith in a British government/politicians in keeping their word is both politically dangerous and stupid! the Prime minister you mention was a notorious appeaser of anything anti British, the man who lost the "cod wars" even Mugabe didn't believe him! never mined a seasoned politician like Smith.

this argument about educating the Africans,well the British took over the cape in 1801, from then until 1964 the British ruled South Africa why did the British not educate the Africans? they had the entire Empire at their disposal? yet you insinuate that its the white Africans are responsible for The Africans lack of schooling while in fact its the British, the white African ruled SA from 1964 1990s, thirty odd years and the British 165 years!

Smith saved his country for 20 years or so, from it being turned into the hell hole of Zimbabwe that it is today!

No! it was`nt a missed opportunity it was great insight by a man who was born and bred and knew/understood Africa better than any politician of his time!
16

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 23/03/2008 11:10:02
#12 Media 1
Given the obvious charecter of the South African Parliamentarians it is not surpising that accused rapists and fraudster Jacob Zuma looks set to be PM.
It seems that a lot of South Africa's political problems comes from the fact that the majority of black people will support any candidate no matter how awful along as he is the ANC candidate. Scotland used to have a similar problem with donkeys and red rosettes.
17

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 23/03/2008 11:28:43
#15 Oder.

If Smith had ruled wisely then Zimbabwe would not have ben in today's mess. The man was a blind fool. He refused to read the writing on the wall.
18

Freedom for Scotland,

23/03/2008 13:15:04
#7, 11, 12 - Media1

At last your TRUE colours. This the same Media1 constantly sticking his non-dom allegedly quasi-Scottish oar into our affairs. With your love for the late and unlamented Ian Smith no surprises for the root of your unionist views.
Go on admit that you secretly admire Mugabe! Go on now!
19

oder,

Scotland 23/03/2008 14:28:14
17 Rulesbutnotrulers,Federation,

sorry! the facts just dont stack, Mugabe has more degrees than Smith! Under Smith the country boomed under Mugabe it has failed,time to stop blaming the white man for African failure,and continuing African failure, Africans are now equal and we should expect no! demand they operate as equals, clearly to tall an order for Mugabe to operate under.

you said

He refused to read the writing on the wall.

yes! he would not have been the first politician to be guilty of that nor the last,just like Mugabe but people will remember the good times under Smith were Mugabe will be forgotten some legacy for the first evil dictator of Zimbabwe!
you forgot to mention had Smith accepted Wilson's guarantee how would Wilson manage to educated millions of Africans in so short a time giving the fact that the British ruled Southern Africa 165 years and contributed little or nothing in African education they were some how now about to produce a miracle of mass education for the African, the trouble with this is no one believed it black or White Africans,Zanu Mugabe`s party was never going to accept it, that was the reality of it.
20

Citylocal Fife,

Fife irresistible wacko news 23/03/2008 14:56:28
There are some distinct parallels between some of our own politicians and those in Mugabeland. My take is that there is a certain openess in Mugabeland politics, by which I mean that the politicians are not afraid to state openly that they are ripping their own people off to enable them to live a life of luxury.

Some of our lot do some very similar things but pretend that they don't, mainly due to the fact that here we at least have the chance to change the ruling party.




21

Neanderthal75,

Rocky Mountains USA 23/03/2008 15:11:26
Hello All,

I'd like to point out that while France, Great Britain, and Belgium, screwed up Africa quite well, it is AFRICANS THEMSELVES who are at fault and are SOLELY RESPONSIBLE for the plight of the poor in Africa!

This is due to the overwhelming power of the WaBenzi!

The Tribe of Mercedes Benz is rife throughout Africa, and the members of this tribe do NOT care how many bodies over which they must tread, in order to maintain their positions of power and wealth.

West Africa, East Africa, Central Africa, and Southern Africa, the WaBenzi RULE at the expense of the average African.

The West helps the murderous WaBenzi by continuing to ship BILLIONS of dollars/pounds/euros to African nations, WITHOUT any/few strings attached! The majority of such monines end up in Swiss bank accounts.

The money that does get through, merely beggars the average African, teaching them to REMAIN 'refugees' and dependent upon handouts from guilt ridden Westerners.

OxFam is to blame for thousands upon thousands of deaths and putting people in poverty, as is no small number of UN organs, and yes, the do-gooders here in the USA are to blame as well.

We need to STOP the status-quo in funding African nations, STOP teaching Africans to be dependent upon the West, and STOP allowing murderous thugs like Mugabe to remain in power.

Stop the WaBenzi.

Cheers from the Rockies
22

Biker,

Ayr 23/03/2008 16:36:18
More stupidity from The Rockies I fear.
Media 1 I have to ask the question, how are the black people supposed to educate themselves within a hite educational system?
It is true that the Indian and Packistani populations took the xenophobic route and taught themselves, but they were and are regarded as an underclass within the African system.
23

Stefania Alvarez,

23/03/2008 17:03:22
Number 12 ... Media 1

Fascinating statistics you provide about the S.A. Parliament.

WOW !!!
I just read that post again
... does the Health Minister honestly believe that is the way to deal with AIDS??
24

Chris,

Edinburgh 23/03/2008 17:41:51
#22 Biker: To my absolute amazement I actually think that 'Neanderthal75' has a point. Read it again and then tell me that his underlying argument is not true. Please name one African state that is not affected by corruption in some form or another where the people at the top, enjoying a high standard of living, ensure that the people at the bottom stay there.
25

Stefania Alvarez,

23/03/2008 19:52:26
Number 22 ... it is sad for me ... because I admired Nelson Mandela when I was a kid.
However Africa seems to produce a glut of despots.

In Africa they do not 'govern' the people
... they RULE ... normally with very authoritarian iron-fist methods.

Still should be time for Led Zepplin and Sir Paul McCartney et al ... and all the old has-been rock stars
... to announce the next "Live Aid" soon ehh??


Let's all sing now:

... "Feed the World ... let them know my rock-star days are gone and I want to re-juvenate my flagging career"

Yea ... bring on the has-been rockers ... for Africa ... Geldof has been awful quiet recently.
26

,

24/03/2008 03:32:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
27

Tatties ower the side,

Johannesburg 24/03/2008 04:36:52
#25 Stefania... Absolutely correct on the "Rule rather than govern" issue.

Mugabe quoted as saying "Tsvangarai will never rule this country" http://apnews.excite.com/article/20080323/D8VJC19G0.html

Whatever happened to the concept of politicians being elected to SERVE the people?
28

Biker,

Ayr 24/03/2008 14:26:28
25 Rodesia was ruled by Ian Smith and his cronies before and after UDI. Mr Smith died a very rich man, as did many of his henchmen. Its not just a black problem. I understand the argument regarding Black governments but consider this. Who ruled the countries prior to black rule, and did they educate the indiginous people sufficiently to take over when they left?
I'm afraid I dont read posties post. Actually I'm not, as sycophancy just annoys me.
29

oder,

25/03/2008 00:46:56
28 Biker,Ayr 24/03/2008 14:26:28

you said

Who ruled the countries prior to black rule, and did they educate the indiginous people sufficiently to take over when they left?

a people called the "British" who ruled for a 165 years, No! they took more than they ever gave! however one oddity about this was when this countries became independent and were UDI was declared the British settlers and others, post empire! built more schools colleges university and had a higher expenditure on African education than the British ever did! more Africans had access to education in these countries,than in Africans had in African countries. a fact that is completely ignored by the politically correct, the difference between Smith and his cronies and Mugabe and his, Smith ran an economic success were Mugabe is a failure, more African have suffered deprivation starvation genocide and upheaval under this evil tyrant, certainly not a charges that could be levelled at Smith even if you are violently opposed to him.
Yep! your right, the British turned their backs and walked away before making sure that the natives could do the job right!
30

Maurice,

Fife 25/03/2008 12:48:26
All of life is in a balance. Where 1 man gets richer, many others get children. Equilibrium is thus reached.
31

Maurice,

Fife 25/03/2008 12:58:48
2 W Smith,Middle East, What on earth does your drivvel have to do with the article in question?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.