Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 24th August 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Do UFOs really exist?



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
29 July 2007
IT'S the weird and wonderful place where the men in grey suits from Whitehall meet the little green men from Mars.

Do you have any photographs of UFOs? Share them with us by emailing them to sospics@scotlandonsunday.com

The Ministry of Defence has for the first time opened its real-life 'X Files', detailing how its experts have examined photographs of UFOs hovering over the UK.

While the images range from the baffling to the risible, there is no doubting the seriousness that officials reserve for the issue of extraterrestrial life.

Correspondence between the MoD and members of the public who report sightings of strange objects reveals that Whitehall mandarins remain "totally open-minded" about the existence of UFOs.

The letters - obtained by Scotland on Sunday through the Freedom of Information Act - confirm that the MoD has a procedure of scrambling fighter planes to confront any unidentified craft or object that enters UK airspace.

However, there are hints that at least some strange objects seen in the sky are of a distinctly terrestrial provenance.

In one letter, officials admit that military helicopters carry out low-flying combat training missions across Britain, and apologise for any alarm they may have caused.

The MoD has confirmed it receives more than 100 reports of UFO sightings every year, many of which come from Scotland.

Last year alone, the Ministry was sent five sets of photographs and videos purporting to show UFO activity.

One was sent by a concerned resident who last March reported seeing silent superfast "triangular craft" and other strange objects in the skies above the south of England.

He enclosed a picture that appears to show a ball of light moving at speed across the sky with an illuminated trail in its wake.

A lengthy official response from the MoD's Directorate of Air Staff is at pains to reassure the individual.

It states: "We remain totally open-minded, but to date we know of no evidence which substantiates the existence of these alleged phenomena.

"The MoD examines any reports of unidentified flying objects it receives, solely to establish whether what was seen might have some defence significance; namely whether there is any evidence that the UK's airspace might have been compromised by hostile or unauthorised air activity."

The letter claims the Ministry could not justify spending public money on being an "aerial identification service", but stresses that every precaution is taken to protect the integrity of UK airspace.

It adds: "I should inform you that low-flying training takes place throughout the UK.

"In the event of conflict, helicopters are vulnerable to ground fire, and one of the vital skills that must be acquired by pilots is flying as closely as possible to the nap of the earth so that the aircraft is shielded and camouflaged by the features of the terrain.

"This type of training is spread as thinly as possible throughout the UK, so as not to concentrate activity over one area. I am sorry if this training has caused disturbance to you."

The MoD also received a succession of images of objects in the sky above Portsmouth harbour last July.

And in one decidedly eccentric letter last May, a concerned citizen warns the MoD that she and her husband are being menaced by invisible craft, the grey alien inhabitants of which have already abducted her in the past to "extract her DNA".

To support her case, she enclosed a photograph of an all-too-visible object (possibly a Frisbee or a satellite dish) "hovering" over a church.

In an impeccably polite response, MoD officials come to the sober conclusion that: "With regard to your particular observations, we are satisfied that there is no corroborating evidence to suggest that the UK's airspace has been breached by unauthorised aircraft."

In another response to an individual who claimed to have provided film evidence of UFO activity over the Clyde in Glasgow last year, an official states frankly: "I have viewed your video and I am content that it contains nothing of defence concern."

The MoD confirmed that in 2006 it received more than 100 reports of UFO sightings, including 12 from Scotland.

The previous year around 150 sightings were reported, with again a dozen coming from north of the Border. These included six reported sightings on the same day (September 14, 2005) in Fife and Perthshire of "bright white lights" in the sky.

The unidentified objects were sighted in Lochgelly, Glenrothes, Crieff, Letham, Blairgowrie and Kinross.

Nick Pope, who headed the MoD's UFO Project between 1991 and 1994, confirmed that reported sightings were taken extremely seriously.

"The MoD wants to know everything flying in the UK's air-defence range and investigate all sightings," he said.

Pope revealed that 95% of UFO reports turned out to either have obvious explanations or to be so vague that any investigation was impossible.

"The remaining 5% of cases were pretty interesting and remained unexplained even after a very thorough explanation. It doesn't prove that these objects were extraterrestrial, but you can't rule any option out."

The former MoD investigator even claimed that officials tried to copy the advanced technology of unidentified vehicles.

"A number of reports were of silent triangular aircraft travelling at considerable speed," he said. "These and some other reports suggested some sort of propulsion system we would be extremely interested in.

"A lot of the serious UFO investigation was aimed at trying to ascertain things such as the aerodynamics of some of the UFOs, the avionics and the propulsion systems.

"We wanted to know if there was anything that we might learn from, regardless of what the source of these UFOs is."

Have you seen UFOs flying above Scotland or do you think the whole idea of little green men is pie in the sky? Tell us what you think and discuss extra-terrestrial matters with other readers.












The full article contains 980 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

I'm no really here,

29/07/2007 00:03:02

Of course I exist.

2

albanoch,

Kyoto Japan 29/07/2007 01:13:28

Seeing is believing and I saw one over Hamilton early the hours of one morning while working an all nighter.
The goverment and the church don't want the truth to come out as it could/might cause panic among the populace{which I doubt very much }and the Mythology that passes for religion and all it's assorted mythological Gods would be scupperd..and as Christianity is the very foundations of society..it's sayonara The Church. How in Gods name could they answer that one..that there are other forms of life far more intelligent that us{they prove their intelligence by keeping a far distance from us} and who can come and go as they please and no Gods or prayers to saints or blessed dead folk are of any avail.There is no God and there are no Gods they've all been invented by man's own imagination..there is one source of all and the UFO people are as much a part of that source as we are...If you want them to go away try throwing holy water at them wae yon drumstick thing the Pope uses..might wurk..ye niver know?

3

Guga II,

Rockall 29/07/2007 01:16:46

All these UFO's come from the Johnny Walker School of Flying, which is why the pictures of them are always blurred.

#1 I'm no really here, isn't really here.

4

I'm no really here,

29/07/2007 01:22:41

Isn't it amazing that for years we have had camcorders, digital cameras, phones with cameras, and no-one has yet come up with a clear convincing picture of a UFO or aliens.

#2 I'm a Christian and have a degree in Astrophysics. If I encountered an alien, I would turn it round and look for the zipper on the back of the costume.

5

The Wizard,

OZ 29/07/2007 01:32:03

My neighbour tells me he is from the planet Xzuyion.
He only came here for a holiday but his battery ran flat and we don't have the means of recharging it.

The truth is out there.

6

albanoch,

kyoto Japan 29/07/2007 03:39:36

Gentle readers if you're wanting pics of UFO"s that are not blurred then just type in UFO on your seatrch engine and take youe pick..there are thousand of excellent photographs...
Not much of a God if he could only come up with us violent, drunken, greedy, self centred egotistical hypocrits...there must be someone else out there..

7

C.U. Jimmy,

Cyberspace 29/07/2007 03:40:38

The vast majority of UFO "sightings" in the UK used to occur just after closing time at the pub. With this Government's Victory Gin approach to 24-hour drinking, it would hardly be surprising to hear of more "sightings" these days.

There really is a "silly season" in the media though.

8

gaffer,

kamloops, b.c. Canada 29/07/2007 03:47:32

really , for the love of god , lets get over this , so what if there is life some where else,, we live here and lets build ourselves a better life for al of us , let them come here and say "Hey come and live with us . life is great , utopia " all you will find is an other U.S.A. under Emporer Bush or his followers as the American empire grows, as did all the proceeding empires

9

Joe,

Livingston 29/07/2007 05:20:20

Apparently a UFO was tracked all the way from the Middle East, headed toward Edinburgh Airport, the RAF
were scrambled only to confirm it was in fact an Emirates jet about to overfly Edinburgh on it's way to Glasgow.

10

Cablag,

out there 29/07/2007 05:29:41

strange goings on over Edinburgh

http://www.phi-latitude.co.uk/

11

Masque,

29/07/2007 05:47:38

Stupid headline.

Anything in the sky is a UFO until you recognise it! It's defining what they are when you don't recognise it that's the problem!

12

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 29/07/2007 06:16:44
13

ex katman 2,

ex sudan 29/07/2007 06:20:01

I knew it was the Scouts 100th jamboree, but not the space cadets surely.

14

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta, California The Golden State 29/07/2007 06:36:41

My friends and I see UFO's almost every day, and some nights.


Respectfully
Galactic Cannibal

15

Gizzabreak,

29/07/2007 07:31:32

I see no spaceships ... only hardships!

16

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Don't blame me, I didn't vote for any of them. 29/07/2007 07:37:45

What have UFOs to do with God or Christianity? Why can't both exist/not exist? Are they necessarily mutually exclusive? Or not? Why?

I really do wish that people talking about God would first define the God they have in mind; that way we'd probably be able to agree that we didn't believe in that sort of God either.

As to UFOs: please apply Occam's Razor.

17

Steenwyck,

29/07/2007 08:03:21

albanach! That is a breathtaking leap of faith.

18

BK,

Cyberspace 29/07/2007 08:13:11

I see UFOs every day birds, insects and planes. There is no doubt that they are flying objects, so if I cannot positively identify them, then they are UFOs!

19

blair,

East Lothian 29/07/2007 08:37:45

Over 40 years ago I saw an Unidentified Flying Object but did not report it because I had no witness and, since my youth, had been trained never to believe anything unless I could confirm it from an independent source. I always apply the questions - Who says so? - On what grounds? - How much reliance can I place on their judgement? I was wakened by the dog giving his warning bark and went to the hall where I saw the object through a window and heard a high-pitched electrical hum. I lokked away and called my wife to come. On looking back it had gone and the humming had stopped. The dog was no longer affected.

20

blair,

East Lothian 29/07/2007 08:45:18

Please excuse my typing. That should have read "I looked away".

21

Phil241106,

Airdrie 29/07/2007 08:51:21

Looks like Albanoch (#1) is just wanting to be known as someone who hates the name of God or anything pertaining to the name or a religion - even if it detracts from the current thread. If he's in Japan....then good. If not, then go there and let us get on with it. Stick to the story.

22

SouthernSkye,

29/07/2007 09:12:55

If UFO exists would they then not be IFO ?

23

Helen,

29/07/2007 09:18:07

What a waste of tax payers money!! Surely when there are people in developing countries who don't have access to healthy food, clean water and a decent education, then we are getting our priorities all wrong.
No-one has ever landed on the moon. It was all a big con by the yanks to boost their egos, and now we waste billions of pounds on worthless space travel. Let's sort the mess out on our own planet before we start looking for other planets to make a mess of.

24

Hambo,

29/07/2007 09:44:02

#27
If suc an object was a Big Identified Non Governmental Object it would be BINGO.

25

Hambo,

29/07/2007 09:45:46

#28
More seriously, there are billions of planets - what are the odds that we are the only one with intelligent life?

26

gfaBlack,

Time and space........ 29/07/2007 10:09:39

We are beind visited not by alians but by our offspring.

Time travel would nessesitate the need to travel through space. If time travel was possable in order for you to go back say 1 day you would need to goto where the earth was 24hrs ago. This would be 1000s of miles away from where it is now.

As the nearest exo solar planets are 10s of light years away the chance of a civilisation developing space travel capable of safely reaching us is very slim and then to just take a look and bugger off without saying hello well I find that harder to beleive than my theory of time travel.

Black.

27

gfaBlack,

Time and space........ 29/07/2007 10:10:28

Sorry the first line should read
'We are being visited....'

28

gfaBlack,

A sicle and a grin...Give me a gin 29/07/2007 10:45:33

Time trave.......cont
There have been UFO sigtings over Chenobbel (Don't know how to spel) and other major events in history
Mount st helens
WW1 and 2
Iraq
Probably the Titanic too but the obsever couldn't swim.
I suggest they are Historians from the future.

You may argue that they would change the course of history.. maybe they have how would we know..

You are being watched.....................................

29

warden99,

gorebridge hmmm mars 29/07/2007 10:47:03

I supose everyone to their own , definetly seen some strange if not weird shit in the skies , where they are space craft or planes i do not know , supose just like religion i need hard proof before i would trully believe.

30

gfaBlack,

Proof they exist is here> 29/07/2007 10:55:07

If im right these chaps from the future will know what I am about to reveal and they will try and st

31

Hat Man,

Dumfries 29/07/2007 10:57:41

#33 Methalions. I think that we have to agree that Dylans genius is proof of extra terrestial life.As he nearly wrote on his last album 'Modern Times'.'I'll be with you, when the wheel touches down'.

32

Heimdall,

Don't look up 29/07/2007 10:59:50

I saw a little green pie in the sky once until it hit me in the eye. I swear it was a little man that threw it but then he was 20 floors up and besides it was a foreign country where small is extra large. the real question is - WHY?

33

Heimdall,

Don't look up 29/07/2007 11:09:51

2. albanoch - God is alive and well and driving the turbo charged mark 3 version which is a limited edition that you can only buy if you have 3 galaxies 7 black holes and a wimpy triple cheesburger to buy it with (proof of provenance required) - once you have purchased this please leave good feedback and remember to stay in your seat and that no bumping is allowed.

34

Choosername,

29/07/2007 11:11:35

Thing In The Sky.

35

Gordon99,

Edinburgh 29/07/2007 11:18:08

And,.....is there any recording on Unidentified Flying Object, before we started flying????????????

G

36

Gizzabreak,

29/07/2007 11:48:09

#29. I think, in regard to extraterrestrial lifeforms, you mean "what are the odds that we are the only one with life?" With the way this planet's going, I question the use of the word "intelligent"!

37

Evan Owen,

Upper Gumtree 29/07/2007 11:50:51

Did someone mention intelligent life? On Earth??

The aliens have landed and they are now in government.

38

Vole,

29/07/2007 11:52:43

Look like seagulls to me.

Why has The Scotsman not added this article to their collection of other UFO stories? This site is not what it used to be. http://heritage.scotsman.com/topics.cfm?tid=453

39

Aloysius Munn,

Space 29/07/2007 11:53:50

...it's all mystical wank

40

Swilly Tisher,

Loch Maree 29/07/2007 11:56:11

Yes, I sincerely believe in the existence of flying saucers. Not so many years ago , one hovered directly over Edinburgh's Bute House and deposited two aliens : Jack and Bridget McConnell. But the earthlings fought back , and - on May the 3rd 2007 AD - they were ousted , and sent spinning into an orbit of no return.

41

Mcsnagpile,

S.E.A 29/07/2007 12:04:27

I thought I had a visitation from outer space but it turned out to be the wife in curlers and face cream.
If there are superior intelligences in outer space, they will keep as far away from the chimps as possible, and just watch us on the telly.
By the way there are many religions that do not conflict with aliens existing including Buddhism so it is not the end. The pope can always use strategy B?

42

Andrew P. Palmer,

Boston, Massachusetts, USA 29/07/2007 12:17:34

Pretty crappy photos.

43

Heimdall,

Don't look up 29/07/2007 12:26:50

43. Methalions - there is an echo in here - listen my comment 38 was only ever going to be understood by humans - thats how we will sift out the aliens from the earthlings

44

MARINER,

WELLS,SOMERSET, ENGLAND 29/07/2007 12:28:52

I definitely believe that UFOs have landed in ENGLAND and dumped their rubbish in the Houses of Parliament and Westminster. One thing is for sure the politicians and top civil servants are not from this planet.

45

Heimdall,

Don't look up 29/07/2007 12:37:54

29. Hambo - intelligent left this planet thousands of years ago after they exhausted the supply of xzyzcht which enabes them to bend space and time and do the stuff they do. We are merely the bacteria equivalent left behind - not very clever since we only exist by killing other life forms and appear very low on the food chain. It is only us that calls us intelligent its a sort of denial thing which does not cut with the alien life that are busy observing us fascinated by our primitive delusions of grandeur.

46

eric,

29/07/2007 12:44:29

Says a lot for the Education system in England!

47

Nurse,

29/07/2007 13:03:22

For more evidence visit this sight its scary and interesting but is quite long try its an x employee of the US defence industry that mysteriously died aftyer making this video.
its on You Tube,

You Tube the UFO lecture by Philip Schneider

48

open minded,

cambs.. 29/07/2007 13:05:41

On duty on a bombing range on the Isle of Man in 1957 when this brightly coloured object appeared in the night sky. Greatly perplexed we called out the duty officer who established it was no star. He in turn called out the Station Commander, not the thing one would normally do at 11.30pm and Groupie made two calls. One to RAF Valley and the other to Luce Bay radar unit, Both reported having sight of the object but could not locate it on radar. Valley scrambled a Hunter which passed overhead in a few minutes. The pilot told us that he had clear vision of the object but it was out of his range. By this time it had been witnessed by RAF personnel in three different areas when it suddenly took off at great speed and disappeared. These sightings were taken seriously by the RAF and were far more common than was generally known.

49

eric,

Lothian 29/07/2007 13:10:33

64 Was it Blackpool illuminations shining across the irish sea:)

50

gyc,

Kuala Lumpur 29/07/2007 13:18:37

UFO is obviously (with no doubt) some high level military experiment/testing of advanced engineering technology aircraft accidentally 'sighted' by the ordinary folks (sightings are predominantly in USA and with Hollywood style dramatic experience to those who got abducted) or other more technologically modern countries. And the people sighting the UFO are usually the weird with less sophisticated mindset belonging to again the ordinary folks. NASA probably are in the quest of building an aircraft that can travel with the speed of light that can go beyond the moon to the next galaxy. Only by creating such technology can we (human) go beyond the moon. In order to perfect such technology, we need to experiment a lot of time. That's why accidental sighting with the like or shape of the aircraft that's not seen before in tis world take place.

51

lyinking,

In the land of the Yin Yan lights 29/07/2007 14:24:36

#7 right on bro
#23 LOL
#29 Who says we are the only one's with inteligent life???......who says we have inteligent life ???

52

AlecJ,

29/07/2007 14:25:18

#40 Gordon
Can I refer you to Isaiah chapter 6? He saw something which he explained in his terms. Can't comment on his state of mind, but the "cherubim" were definitely flying objects. It's not the only example from history, but one wich comes to mind from my Judeo-Christian background. Moslems would specify items recorded in the Q'ran and the Hadaths. Just because it is recorded in religious documents doesn't mean that there wasn't something there which could not be properly explained.

53

lyinking,

In the land of the Yin Yan lights 29/07/2007 14:29:18

#40 Read the Bible or Eric Von Daniken whatever you have on your bed side tale

54

Crewedaddy,

Running away from men with sticks 29/07/2007 14:30:40

#17 - Occam's Razor? So what what would you deduce from applying that maxim then?

#26 Helen, please lead by example and forego all the pointless expenditure from your own life. Like your computer that allows you to read this which is, after all, a complete and utter waste of time. The world needs romance and diversion. If these things prove to be real maybe they have a way of eradicating the things that bother you.

One of those pictures looks like someone got fooled by balloons released at a fete, the same way a cigar shaped one flying absolutely level across the rooftops of Tottenham Court Rd 25 years ago completely wrong-footed me to the point that I phoned the Evening Standard and reported it. I have seen one though; a completely unexplained manoeuvre by a light in the sky that was travelling towards me about 1am one morning about 10 years ago in South East London. I watched it get larger for about 20 seconds at which point it shot off at right angles towards the south west. I was used to watching planes stack for Heathrow in the area, none moved that fast. Military activity over London? Don't think so. About a month later there was a news report of an airliner in the area that had lost power and dived 15000 - 20000 ft before the pilot regained control. Appears I was a few seconds away from watching a plane crash on top of me. As far as Occam's Razor is concerned, this was by far from the simplest explanation but then, when you're dealing with something that is unidentified - what is simple?

55

kpm,

29/07/2007 14:31:01

51 The cat has obviously been faked .

56

Aloysius Munn,

Space 29/07/2007 14:56:39

#50 Methalions:

I was quoting Factory Records supremo Tony Wilson, who, when asked if he believed in UFOs, gave that answer.

Shaun Ryder, conversely, attributes his successful and continued abstention from opiates to extra-terrestrial beings that flew over Salford in 1980.

My attitude is, as always, blame Canada, they were the only nation on earh thatbuilt and flew saucer shaped craft. Check out http://www.avrocar.com/ for more details.

Closer to home, councillor Billy Buchanan is a UFO expert, although I fear the extra terrestrials he communicates with are in fact expatriates of Cal-Hab, yished up on Synthi Bucki and shrooms.

Laters

AM

57

Aloysius Munn,

Space 29/07/2007 15:01:26

****
NB the picture at the top of this page is clearly a Feisar craft from Wipout Pure for the PSP.

A crap choice though - anyone flying over Portsmouth at night would be better served by a Triakis (for defence capabilites) or a Piranha (for raw power)

58

Douglas,

Bathgate 29/07/2007 15:19:50

There are many among us, recent arrivals from a system near the Pole star.:o)

59

J M Milligan,

Scot/ USA 29/07/2007 15:55:39

Okay you lot back on board the ship...we've convinced them we don't exist.

60

Bee Zee: GalaxyGarden.org,

29/07/2007 15:58:03

Greeetings Earthlings!

Bee shure to check on our Human-ET interface, updated frequently at http://CosmoCorps.org (see REAL ETs!)

Also, many pics & documents which will rock your "REALITY" can be found by going to the WAYBACK MACHINE:
http://www.archive.org/web/web.php
Type "MUTANEX" & "METAMAGIC"

Aloha from Mauna Kea Mothership!

PS: Briefly, here's the human dilemma:
Wee are primitive neo-tech knuckle-draggers becoming aware that on our little edge of the galaxy, wee are surrounded by a plethora of highly advance space societies, including scavengers, scientists, agrarians, pirates & spiritualists. What do humans do to chimps? Get the idea?

PPS: What this "news" story doesn't touch is the COSMIC TOP SECRET space colonies on the Moon & Mars...

61

Aloysius Munn,

Space 29/07/2007 16:21:20

The Holyrood debating chamber would make a good spaceship.

Well, when I say 'good spaceship' - what I mean is, Lando Calrissian could probably sell it for scrap.

The Council are now working on Space Trams to tackle congestion over Edinburgh. This bargain project will only cost 500 000 000 space credits.

You'll have had your synthemesc?

62

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 29/07/2007 16:41:17

My neighbours are UFOs from hell - unsociable f-fing orifices.

Had another sighting today but their motors aren't silent.

63

big chief toffee teeth,

my muff diving house in the barras 29/07/2007 16:49:47

there has to be some sort of intelligent life somewhere in this universe, there is none here that i can see... please beam me up scotty.

64

Joseph Capp,

United States 29/07/2007 17:11:42

Dear Mr. Horne
I can see by some of the answers many people don't have the faintest idea of the evidence out there on UFO video. In Mexico 23, 000 were sent into a TV show that asked for evidence. There are clear pictures of UFOs. To get them verified beyond reasonable doubt is expensive. However ,one clear photos negative which was examined by the US military has shown an extraordinary flying object... "tens of meters in diameter and evidently artificial, flew within the sight of two witnesses." .Kodak Monitor or Vigilant type of camera. This came under heavy debunking but to this day have stood up. The character of the couple who witnessed also has stood up to shameless attacks. The Trent's neighbors time and time again vouched for the characters of this couple. They never made a dime. Believe it or not received many hate calls.
One other point. Many pilots have witness UFOs with a type of corona discharge around the object, making it appear hazy. If this is true, some of the time, then taking a clear pictures of a fuzzy object wouldn't change the outcome.
Joseph Capp
UFO Media Matters

65

Smokey0541,

Lakewood, Colorado U.S.A. 29/07/2007 19:01:20

I'm ONLY 64 years old. I wonder if we will ever know the truth in my life time ?

LMAO

66

Single Malt Lad,

29/07/2007 19:41:50

If we knew what they were they wouldn't be UFOs. They would just be FOs which what all you ET freaks should do.

67

Jonggmaster,

Henderson, NV USA 29/07/2007 19:56:05

Time for a reality check.

#67 NASA is not developing a spacecraft that could travel at the speed of light, and which could go "to the next galaxy." NASA's progress in developing advanced rocket engines capable of heavy payloads has been very limited and unimpressive. But beyond the present situation are the following inarguable facts:
o The energy required to accelerate a mass to the speed of light is infinite. NASA has studied means to reach 20% of light speed and determined that extraordinary assumptions would have to be realized, not the least of which would be the high cost. And the result would be a mission to a nearby star that would take many thousands of years for the travellers.
o All applicable physics for beings of our size (5 or 6 feet) is already known. There cannot ever be "break-throughs" by any civilization--ours or one near a distant star--that would permit galactic or intergalactic travel of intelligent lifeforms. Exotic mathematical constructs (wormholes, etc.) will never be realized, even if otherwise possible as natural events or objects, for hyper-propulsive purposes because of the enormous implied concentrated energy requirement.

UFOs are either mis-identifications of man-made flight vehicles, or natural environmental and/or optical phenomena. They cannot be visitations from other worlds or galaxies. This is our world. We must make the best of it.

68

Friar Tuck,

Port Perry, Ontario, Canada 29/07/2007 19:56:08

Every star out there is a sun with planets orbiting it. What are the odds that there are no planets with life on them? Do you really believe that Earth is the only planet that has life? The real problem is that WARP drive has not yet been invented. Over to you Scotty!

69

Smokey0541,

Lakewood, Colorado U.S.A. 29/07/2007 20:39:27

How could anyone be so vain or arrogant as to believe we are GODs only creation ?

70

fearsidhe,

North Georgia, USA 29/07/2007 20:43:55

Och, we see 'em all the time on our nocturnal haggis hunts.

Also, the 5th photo in the column is easily identified as a Cessna 182... in a climbing turn to the left.

Now... if I can only explain the one that looks like Harry Potter....

71

ltstrtr,

usa 29/07/2007 20:58:39

YOU'VE GOT TO BE KIDDING

72

,

29/07/2007 21:28:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 828326, Article id was mapped to record!
73

Single Malt Lad,

29/07/2007 22:27:08

#90 What the f*** has this got to do with this blog.
You must be on the wrong page.

74

TazTigress,

Tasmania 29/07/2007 23:10:18

Well all us Tasmanian's have two heads!!

75

whatsyourname,

mars 29/07/2007 23:18:22

# 85 The govertment has had space craft fo years like wise the people visiting us from other planets, how could yoou think other
and have you heard about the center of the earth, I know of some one whom is programed for things to come and she is taken in the night by a goverment space ship,

76

Cardinal Marinetti,

29/07/2007 23:39:51

THERE IS NO OTHER LIFE IN THE UNIVERSE. THIS IS THE ONLY WORLD, WHERE GOD HAS PUT US FOR HIS PURPOSE.

UFOs ARE THE WORK OF THE DEVIL AND YOU MUST IGNORE THEM! THEY ARE DEMONS AND WILL DESTROY YOU IF YOU ALLOW THEM.

PUT ASIDE YOUR CHILDISH THINGS AND WORSHIP THE ONE, TRUE GOD. THE GOD OF ABRAHAM, ISAAC AND MOSES.

YOU WILL BE SAVED BY ACCEPTING OUR LORD, JESUS CHRIST INTO YOUR HEART!

77

whatsyourname,

mars 29/07/2007 23:51:39

# 94 take a pill

78

mildred,

philadelphia PA USA 30/07/2007 00:06:53

Maybe yes-maybe no. What's the problem? As for #94 above, why the paranoia? Only God is God and you may not presume to think you can speak for God. If there are multi universes, that's not for you to judge why. Your domain is not the domain of the ultimate creator. Read Emanuel Kant "On Noumena" and you'll understand that you can't understand. A fly can't be God and neither can you.

79

The Wizard,

OZ 30/07/2007 01:57:20

#92

Is that why they call you Tasmanian Devils?

80

Croman mac Nessa,

30/07/2007 05:22:03

94, ist. Tha Sinnsearachd 7 Ildiachd (an Rian Sinnsearach, a' Bheul-Aithris na Seanar) na's fèarr agus reusanta. Tha an crìosdachd creideamh na tràill, agus tha an crìosdalachd an cealgaireachd. Truis!

81

ufohunter,

Midlothian 30/07/2007 07:24:50

Yes UFOs are flying above our heads take a look at the midlothian ufos and ufos from around scotland.
http://www.youtube.com/user/SkywatcherScotland
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DvQe6kPQno

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9OCcAWgUaek

82

Humphrey,

Bishopstoke, Hampshire 30/07/2007 08:39:08

The subject of the UFO is extremely complex, involving many peripheral subjects. Because of this, only informed opinions are worth anything. It is interesting to note that the following piece of philosophy was voiced over two thousand years ago:

To consider the Earth as the only
populated world in infinite space is
as absurd as to assert that in an entire
field of millet, only one grain will grow.

Greek philosopher Metrodorus – 4th Century B.C.

83

Harumph,

Harumphland 30/07/2007 08:39:12

Of course UFOs exist. By definition they are unidentified flying objects, which just means that the person seeing it cannot identify it. Whether or not they are of alien origin is really what the question should be....

84

dimitris,

Athens 30/07/2007 09:54:56

Oh yea they exist and the fly around us .My brother has seen three times Ufo and I believe him.
Only narrow minded people cannot see and undestand the issue.

85

wisdom,

Edinburgh 30/07/2007 10:28:51

We don't need to scan the skies for evidence of UFOS....We have benches full of Alien life forms in the Commons and the Lords.

86

Peace,

Florida-USA 30/07/2007 11:53:08

94, Why did god make the millions of galaxies, Astronomy lesson, there are more stars in the sky than sand on this earth......The bible says creator of the heavens and earth...why waste all that space, u think god would do that. This is just my opinion...If UFO's are real, never seen any, "still believe in UFO's and it doesn't sway my belief in god...another one of my opinions.....he created others millions of years before us...We are so young of a civilization or world, we probably start Wars with them also, or try...LOL

87

why can't I use my own name???,

30/07/2007 12:08:34

Post #59

xzyzcht, eh? Sound like 's***' if you say it quickly in an Aberdonian accent. Are you telling us they use s*** to bend space? Wow, so much for an advanced technological society! They should maybe come back here, for there's an abundance of it in government at the mo'!!

88

why can't I use my own name???,

30/07/2007 12:11:01

In fact, didn't Alistair Campbell use xzyzcht for many years with Labour?? :-)

89

Keith Williams,

State of Ohio, USA 30/07/2007 12:52:41

I think in all the vastness of space, as there is no end to it, there must be some intelligent life in it. ( there is certainly not much here) because people refuse to believe in other intelligent life elswhere.

90

Peace,

Florida-USA 30/07/2007 13:48:21

Yeah, some people still thinks the world is flat..

91

Heimdall,

Don't look up 30/07/2007 13:56:24

105. why can't I use my own name??? - the real name escapes me right now however xzyzcht is as good a name for something we do not have any more of - the point is we are the primitive life forms left to scavenge this earth once these high flyers have mined the best stuff for their space and time hopping enterprises and while we try to reason in our arrogance and self-importance the unimortant and irrelevant the real play is going on out of our reach and comprehension.

92

munnaboy3,

denton 30/07/2007 15:13:19

It appears that some of your readers have this lame idea that christianity is just another religion, and that if life outside of our world were discovered then there would be a down fall of all religions, including christianity. However that is not true at all because if your readers had given time to read the bible they would have discovered that God is everywhere in the univers, and that he is the author of life, not death, I have seen three ufos in my life time and it makes me think how awesome God is if in fact what we are seeing is life frome elsewhere. But if they are not life from out there or goverment aircraft then perhaps we should be a little more curios about what it is that we are seeing, if you had read the Bible then you would have discovered a prophecy given by Jesus himself that said that in the last days there would be signs and wonders in the haevens and the earth. Souds like God had all the bases covered before these people who think they are smarter than God ever came into being. So the next time you try to speak for christians know what your talking about before you open your mouth, then you wont sound so much Carl Marx.Maybe we should say that if life out there does exist and they visit us some day then every person who doesnt believe in God would be devistated and their whole sence of self importance would collapse in on itself .

93

Croman mac Nessa,

30/07/2007 15:28:30

110, just because your book says something doesn't make it so. Why don't you try applying the laws of Logic to that book and see how many contradictions you can find? Don't assert that there are none until you have had at least a year of Logic at university level and actually taken the statements of your book, translated them into Predicate Logic (or even just Propositional Logic, for that matter), and applied the Laws of Logic to them. And then if you have failed to find any (or more likely ignored the "difficult" bits of your book in an effort to avoid facing the Truth), let me know and I'll be happy to point them out for you. Mind, I could do it the now, but what would it benefit you for me to spoon-feed you? You need to learn how to reason and then use those skills. And then once you've done that, make sure you start examining texts from other ancient near eastern cultures, so you can learn about the sources of the myths in your book. Then expand your studies to other cultures, learn more and more about humanity's quest for, and experience of, the Divine, and as a result, you will eventually realise that in fact Christianity _*IS*_ just another Religion, and not a very healthy one at that!

94

david barnett,

lexington ky, 30/07/2007 16:49:18

if you guys will read from chapter 13 revelations you will see god speeking of chreatures,why the disscussions and confusion? read it.

95

Heimdall,

Don't look up 30/07/2007 17:07:58

111. Croman mac Nessa - First, Logic arose out of lack of faith or rather the misunderstanding of belief as a measure f human endeavours. Two - Logic itself avoids the truth not the belief systems of the world, Christianity for one at least actually faces the most difficult of concepts and deals with them without fiddling the data as logid does. Third Christianity as recorded in the Bible recognises and records many UFO and alien encounters and phenomena. Fourth no logic system can support the idea that Christianity is 'ust another Religion' and fifth, Christianity is aive and well it is just that some people (perhaps the more forward or more voluble) have failed it or maybe they are not so healthy.