Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Minimum smoking age limit to rise to 18

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 10 September 2006
THE minimum age limit for smoking will rise to 18, ministers will announce this week.
An advisory group of health chiefs is set to report back to the Scottish Executive, recommending an increase in the smoking age, currently at 16.

Ministers already have the power in law to raise the age limit, meaning that the move could happen a
s early as next spring.

The crackdown is the latest bid by the Scottish Executive to improve Scotland's health, and follows the introduction of the ban on smoking in public places earlier this year.

International evidence suggests that increases in the smoking age limit have led to sharp reductions in the amount of under-age smoking.

Figures for 2004 show that 14% of 15-year-old boys and 24% of 15-year-old girls smoke regularly.

Surveys also show that hundreds of children aged just 13 are smoking regularly, with 6% admitting that they smoke on a regular basis.

The change in the age limit will mark the first overhaul in 70 years, when the 16-year-old limit was first imposed.

Surveys show that under-16s currently have little difficulty in buying cigarettes from shops, even though they are underage.

Duncan McNeil MSP, who has led the campaign for the reduction in the age limit, said last night: "This has become a massive anomaly.

"The smoking ban legislation has challenged the smoking habits of adults, but we did nothing to challenge the smoking of young people who do not smoke in public places."

He added: "If we can prevent young people from getting addicted then we will be making a big improvement in public health in Scotland. This will be another case of Scotland leading by example on smoking."

The British Medical Association, which recently carried out a report showing 19% of 15-year-olds are smoking regularly, is also in favour of an over-18 policy.

Forest, the group which represents smokers' rights, says it is not opposed to the raising of the age limit, but says concerns remain about how the move would be enforced.

The increase in the age limit comes after Asda decided that it would only allow 18-year-olds and over to purchase cigarettes in all of its stores across Britain.

From last week, young smokers have had to produce a passport, photo driving licence, or another proof of age card before they are served.



The full article contains 445 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Peter,

10/09/2006 09:46:12

"THE minimum age limit for smoking will rise to 18, ministers will announce this week."

Well done The Scotsman, another untrue headline.

In the UK, cigarettes can legally be sold only to people aged 16 and over. However it is not illegal for people under this age to buy (or attempt to buy) cigarettes, which means that only the retailer is breaking the law by selling to under 16s.

Furthermore, there is no law stipulating the age at which one may smoke.

If the SE really want to make a difference, change the current law to make it illegal to smoke if under 16.

2

Ashley Thomson,

10/09/2006 10:36:27

smokers should be treated like all other drug addicts. criminalise their addiction. possibly they can be prescribed patches from GPs on the understanding that they have to give up within 3 months or they lose their homes and children.

3

The Strategist,

10/09/2006 10:52:40

Just another diversion from the fact that the economy is going down the pan and an opportunity to employ more "smoke police" ...

4

Sed quis custodiet ipsos custodes,

Peoples Republic of Scotland 10/09/2006 11:14:58

Its good to know they will be introducing a law that obviously all under eighteens will abide by.

5

Andrew,

Cumbernauld 10/09/2006 12:20:55

What your title REALLY should say is that the legal age TO BUY/SELL smoking products will be raised to 18 - but this won't stop the 'behind the bike-sheds' mentality, will it??

6

mr chips,

10/09/2006 12:39:02

Does mc neil think that all 16 year old smokers will stop smoking, then start again at 18.This is just more control freakery by the muppets at folyrood.

7

Guga,

Rockall 10/09/2006 13:30:57

So, you can still get married at 16 and still pay taxes at 16 (and younger). I don't know if they still have "boy" soldiers, but you can still join the forces at under 18; and end up fighting in a war, illegal or otherwise.

However, you can't drink or vote till you're 18, and now they want to stop you smoking till you're 18. The whole thing seems a bit "screwy" to me.

In any event, with our health service and education system rapidly going down the tubes, I would think that our numpties in Holyrood would be better employed sorting out these problems, instead of fiddling while Rome burns.

8

David from New Mills,

New Mills 10/09/2006 13:36:36

Sadly, most of the correspondents here seem to have missed the point of this particular item. As far as I am aware, it is not an offence per se for minors to consume either nicotine or alcohol. The intention of such restrictions and limitations, whether they be on alcohol, tobacco, fireworks, solvents, knives, lottery tickets, or "adult" entertainment is to make it more difficult for minors to obtain them, until they are deemed sufficiently mature to make their own responsible and informed judgements.
Knives are slightly different, of course, as it is an offence to carry these in public, regardless of age.

9

Guga,

Rockall 10/09/2006 14:05:13

David (#8) seems to have missed the point. I wonder why, for example, 16 year-olds are "deemed sufficiently mature to make their own responsible and informed judgements" to be able to get married? The same point applies for under 18's joining the army and killing people.

10

Eve,

Scotland 10/09/2006 17:42:28

Smoking Kills

Why don't they raise the age to 21 or ban it!!!

Banning the sells full stop would work really well, then people would only be able to smoke underground.

11

Douglas,

Virginia 10/09/2006 18:26:33

Smoking in the mines is stupid what with the risk of firedamp etc., with the added illegality of having a drag in the workplace. No I think this underground thing is a non starter.

12

Eve,

Scotland 10/09/2006 20:31:36

11. John Player: Under ground doesney just mean under the ground of sort sometimes the term is used to decribe the black market or people doing it on the sly, hoping not to get caught.

13

David from New Mills,

New Mills 10/09/2006 20:45:29

#9 Guga.
Guga has a certain point about the minimum age for marriage, which I think is 18 in England, but 16 in Scotland for probably historic reasons.
Even those of such immature ages are probably too young to decide to make a lifelong commitment, though many older people also make a wrong choice and their unions end in divorce. Perhaps there is a valid case for raising the minimum age?
Not sure about the situation in the armed forces, though I understood 18 was the minimum age for active service, even though this was not rigorously observed during the Great War.

14

mr chips,

10/09/2006 21:12:27

12. Eve Non-Smoker, Scotland /Mrs andy kerr has her say under the name, eve.

15

Douglas,

Bathgate 10/09/2006 21:22:19

That'll be Eve as in naive. Don't be so po faced. It was a joke (kind of). J.P.

16

Iain Inverness,

Inverness 10/09/2006 22:09:08

I agree with John #11, this underground proposal Eve has is an ill advised, unsafe idea. Much better to be above ground .

Is the black market anywhere near the famous Edinburgh Haymarket or Grass Market? This sounds more feasible but I doubt it would be able to accommodate all of Scotland's Smokers. Certainly not at once anyway.

I'm not aware of the location of "the sly" Is this a local term for some other location you had in mind? Maybe it is a bad place anyway as you mention that people may get caught while they are there.

Have you any suggestions where to accommodate intolerant, unbalanced hate fuelled Hamish's like #2?

17

Eve,

Scotland 10/09/2006 22:11:35

#14. Smoker: Are you trying to make me feel Sick Andy Kerr (Yuck, Yuck, Yuck), I'd rather passive smoke than be that close to that useless MSP, Oh I know he useless use to stay in his constutiony I couldn't wait to get out of there it's a hopless town.

#15. douglas: That did come pass through my mind, but as I was a bit in the boried side earlyer I thought, I would reply.

18

Eve,

Scotland 10/09/2006 22:14:09

#15. douglas: Sorry that should be: That thought did pass through my mind but as I was a bit in the boried side earlyer I thought, I would reply.

19

Synchronicity,

10/09/2006 22:38:30

Eve, are you still 'bored and worried' ? !!!!!!

20

mr chips,

10/09/2006 22:49:57

17. Eve Non-Smoker, Scotland / So you are prepared to stand in the pissin rain out side the warm comfortable pub and participate in passive smoking,rather that meet blubber jaws.Well good on yer hen, a vote for the smokers ,thanks.

21

jane,

11/09/2006 08:05:11

Surely any move towards reaching a smoke free atmosphere anywhere is welcome.

22

__-Steve-__,

11/09/2006 11:20:06

Jane (21)

It's certainly not welcome to the 11 million smokers and their friends. Why would you want to impose your ideology on everyone else?

23

Chuckles,

London 13/09/2006 22:54:27

Jane(21) TOO right stop being a self righeous cow!!


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Is the government right to try to ban newsagents from having cigarette displays?
Yes, anything to discourage smokers is good
No, shopkeepers could lose their livelihoods
No, smokers will still know the fags are under the counter

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.