Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


100 not out for James McCarthy, the 18-year-old veteran

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 March 2009
THERE ARE about to be 100 reasons why James McCarthy is an 18-year-old product of Scottish football like no other. The Hamilton Accies wunderkind will bring up a century of senior games when he takes to the pitch at Ibrox this afternoon for a Homecoming Scottish Cup quarter-final tie. No player in this country has made it to the three-figure milestone before their 19th birthday; still a full eight months away for McCarthy.
"It's great. I'm delighted to break records but the most important things is getting into the next round," says the teenager, with a winning mix of self-assurance and self-effacement. "I'm going to keep my feet on the ground. The gaffer has given me the chance, so it's all down to him. I can't thank him enough."

Hype and happenstance have undoubtedly accompanied the Castlemilk-born attacker's ability to accumulate appearances rapidly since his first-team debut at 15. But those factors cannot explain away the contribution the player of the fifth round has made to the remarkable upward mobility of his club, currently enjoying their best season in the post-war era. Nor the lofty claims made of him by sensible judges.

His manager, Billy Reid, would normally be regarded as one of those sober arbiters, but he cannot help but gush over his great prodigy. He accepts McCarthy looked like a ball boy who had simply strayed too far when he was sent on as substitute against Queen of the South on September 30, 2006. He accepts, too, he had to tread a fine line when it came to duty of care for a skelf of a boy. Even Reid's father then questioned his playing a 15-year-old who "wasn't ready". Now he applauds his son's foresight.

"It was right in a sense; James wasn't ready in that he wasn't always having the influence people thought he should," the Hamilton manager says. "He was an easy target so people said I should leave him out. But I just saw something that made me want to give him those first 20 games, so he could learn what it was all about. He did, and this why he is the player he is today. Young players can often come in and play a few games then fade out. We've had a few who couldn't handle it. Some can come in for half a dozen games and then you don't hear of them again. But that's not going to happen with James McCarthy. He's the real deal; he's here to stay.

"His consistency levels are fascinating and his ability to be strong enough physically to adapt to playing week in, week out, is remarkable. He is silky but the beauty of him is that he does the rotten part of the game as well. He takes the hits. He gets battered, but picks himself up."

McCarthy's decision to play for the Republic of Ireland will ensure he is battered orally by many among the Rangers legions this afternoon. Some may even adapt the racist Famine Song in his "honour", as they did in games between the sides at New Douglas Park.

Yet the issues can be clouded in this particular McCarthy witch-hunt. The baiting of the youngster throughout Scotland, as with other Republic of Ireland internationalists through grandparentage Aiden McGeady and Jim O'Brien, may be tiresome, at the very least. But it is surely human nature that his footballing detachment from Scotland, the country in which both he and his parents were born and raised, will be the source of resentment. If McCarthy had committed to England, his ears would be bashed as soundly at away grounds. Patriotism does not explain some Rangers fans' antithesis to the player, however. Only an allergy to anything perceived as Irish Catholicism does.

"It doesn't bother me," he says. "You hear it now and again when the ball's out of play. But when you are concentrating on your own game and trying to do your job, you don't hear it. I'll just get on with it and I have the backing of all the boys plus the gaffer and the backroom staff."

McCarthy's temperament on such occasions has been as impressive as his toughness in coping with the physical rigours. Reid confesses he has had concerns over burn-out but tailors his training programme to take account of his still-developing limbs and muscles. No longer, though, does he feel the need to protect the club's leading performer from the media spotlight. "It is a great delight to me how he has matured as a person," the Hamilton manager says. "At 15 he was really shy but now he is great with the press, great around the club, and has really came out of his shell and become a confident young man."

The self-belief of McCarthy, who moved to Hamilton from Livingston Boys Club aged 14 after Celtic passed on him following trials, is sufficient for him casually state he has "coped no bother" with the step up to the Scottish Premier League. His conviction that he has "improved a lot this season" and can continue to do so in his present posting leaves him in no hurry to test his talents in more exacting surroundings. At 16, he turned down the chance of a move to Liverpool because he valued constant senior involvement above all else. In the three years since, his priorities do not seem to have changed. Even when no Hamilton games seems complete without a dozen scouts from English clubs scrutinising him from the stand. Hamilton are understood to have placed a £2m bounty on his head – a sum considered too hefty by an interested Celtic.

"If an offer comes in we'll need to sit down and talk to the club," he says. "But I'm happy where I am at the moment. I don't want to move and sit in the stand or play in the reserves. If the timing was right, I'd go down and look at the place, see what it was like and see what happened from there. I'm not going to get carried away."

James McCarthy might then be just about the only person not getting carried away with James McCarthy.

The full article contains 1056 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

,

08/03/2009 00:15:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 00:45:28
No one likes Scotland losing talented young Scots players to other nations, I would loved to have seen these young players wear the dark blue of the country of their birth.

They have made their choice, lets move on. Its time the press gave it a rest with the constant articles regarding the choices made by these players.

Supporters will continue to give them stick on the park for their decision, and have every right too.

I-mac is probably correct, if they had waited a while to see if they were in the frame for a Scottish cap, and it did not come then the ROI was an option for them.
3

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 00:57:48
9 dv

I never called these players bigots.

I have said Scotland have lost 2 talented youngsters who chose to play for another country. The national team set up suffers when things like this happens.
4

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:08:40
17 dv

Hypothetical question for you.

Final match of a qualifying group, the winner of the match advances to finals

You as a Scotland supporter have just watched the ROI beat Scotland to qualify for the WC with McGeady scoring the winner, knowing he has knocked the country of his birth out of a place in the finals would you boo him?
5

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:23:19
21 dv

I said in post 15 "I never called these players bigots"

Why would I think they were bigots for choosing not to play for Scotland? They made a footballing decision, their choice, so why would they be bigots for doing that.

Do I agree with what pundit said in post # 3, about the 2 players being bigots, of course I don't.
6

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:29:15
29 Invictager

Its a cup tie, so all bets are off!

I was a wee lad bit still remember the Berwick Rangers result.
7

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:35:16
The draw for the semis is tomorrow after the match?
8

,

08/03/2009 01:37:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:40:54
Tim

Speaking of putting a nail in the coffin.

That was a well taken penalty by the Saints striker on Saturday.

I hope Boyd does as well with his today. lol
10

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:44:21
41 pundit

We get the live feed of the match at the supporters club, it usually cuts off immediately after the match. I'll check online when I get home.
11

,

08/03/2009 01:44:27
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:47:17
44

Nite.
13

,

08/03/2009 01:50:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:52:29
45

If Scotland have the 2 Europa Cup places, they should go to the 3rd and 4th place team in the league not cup winners or runners up.

A team can get a few lucky breaks in a cup competition that has them playing 6 matches and they qualify for Europe, yet a team works hard for 38 matches finishes 4th and gets nothing, and the cup runners up do nothing to help our standing (points) in Europe
15

,

08/03/2009 01:55:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

,

08/03/2009 01:57:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 01:58:02
59

Lest we forget Gretna!
18

,

08/03/2009 01:59:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
19

,

08/03/2009 02:00:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

,

08/03/2009 02:03:10
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

,

08/03/2009 02:04:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
22

,

08/03/2009 02:07:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
23

,

08/03/2009 02:09:10
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 02:10:13
75

The wind up, is moving up a gear.
25

,

08/03/2009 02:12:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

,

08/03/2009 02:15:33
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
27

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 02:15:56
Later, the clocks here go ahead an hour tonight. Summers on its way.
28

,

08/03/2009 02:19:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
29

,

08/03/2009 02:20:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
30

,

08/03/2009 08:27:49
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
31

Riot_Survivor,

08/03/2009 11:36:06
Well done young James McCarthy.

Never let them wear you down. Get out there and turn in a performance.

A good performance and a possible shock result.

Just imagine how Jessie Owens must have felt in Berlin when he silenced the racists in '36
32

,

08/03/2009 12:13:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
33

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 12:17:36
Glad to see Pedro Mendes speaking out about the bigots that infect ibrox.
A young lad trying to make his way in the game and he has to face the most savage hostility up and down the country week in week out.

In some sense it serves the purpose of demonstrating to the world the extent to which bigotry is so much a part of Scottish cultural life, and by bigotry we off-course mean anti-catholicism/anti-irish...when these two components come together in the one peron, their hatred goes nuclear.

The rules permit this young man to play for Ireland, and those who seek to vilify him for making that choice are simply bigots...if you trod on one, be sure to wipe your shoes on the grass.
34

,

08/03/2009 12:21:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
35

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 12:34:03
BTW

Horrified to read of the two british soldiers murdered in N.Ireland on Friday night...and 4 badly injured.

I hope that the killers are caught asap.

During the peace process, it was the IRA that controlled these dissident groups , and they kept themselves very quiet under threat of retribution from the IRA.

As soon as the IRA disbanded, they started to become a menace and now it seems they have decided to become active...I just hope that the authorities go about their business with greater precision and fairness than in the early 1970s.

These people are very small in number...no sledge hammer required.
36

The Equaliser,

08/03/2009 13:52:53
99/101

What of the bigots who infect Celtic FC with their "political" songs.

In view of the cold blooded murder of the soldiers last night can we expect and end to the praise of the murder gangs by the Bhoys? Hell no thats just the craic.
37

,

08/03/2009 14:11:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
38

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:14:26
#102

That's what's known in the footie forum trade as a "thread closer", so I suggest we stick to football.

If a poster from either side of the religious divide, or from either side of the footballing divide, wants to come on here and condemn last night's events, then we should all display solidarity with such a sentiment.

However, any poster who uses the atrocity to "point score" really needs to remove himself from this thread.
39

,

08/03/2009 14:32:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:32:29
Whittaker in for Broadfoot today, Mendes alongside Bazza in central midfield, Aaron starting on left and Lafferty preferred to Boyd up front.

Should be interesting.
41

,

08/03/2009 14:34:23
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
42

,

08/03/2009 14:38:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

,

08/03/2009 14:39:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
44

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:39:09
Tim

I would certainly leave if I were Boyd, but you do wonder how much ambition the lad really has, given his turning down of a lucrative move to Birmingham and probable Premiership football, and also his attitude towards playing for his country.

He seems happy to play a walk-on role for the team he loves, but I do feel that Smith would prefer to sell him. Will either Boyd or Smith be at RFC next season? I wonder.
45

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:42:13
Invictager

The one employee who's recession-proof is the little lady who's entrusted with keeping all our trophies shiny and sparkly. Two last season and just maybe another three this time around :)
46

,

08/03/2009 14:43:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
47

,

08/03/2009 14:45:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
48

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:46:02
Tim

What's your view on Wee Gordon's "sexist" comment yesterday? :)
49

,

08/03/2009 14:46:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
50

,

08/03/2009 14:47:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
51

,

08/03/2009 14:48:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
52

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:49:55
Tim

He was asked by a female journalist about what had gone wrong against St Mirren, and he replied that trying to explain it to her would be like her trying to explain childbirth to him!
53

,

08/03/2009 14:50:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
54

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:53:12
Tim

The inference that women can never hope to understand the realities of football any more than men can ever hope to understand the realities of childbirth, I suppose.
55

,

08/03/2009 14:54:29
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
56

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 14:57:13
invictager

I'd see Tim as more of a Waitrose or M&S man myself.



57

,

08/03/2009 14:57:18
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
58

,

08/03/2009 14:58:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
59

,

08/03/2009 14:59:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
60

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 15:00:13
Not at all, Tim

I'm all in favour of "unreconstructed man", of which WGS appears to be a fully paid-up member.

Society is too sensitive these days, IMO.
61

,

08/03/2009 15:04:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
62

,

08/03/2009 15:06:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
63

,

08/03/2009 15:08:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
64

,

08/03/2009 15:09:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
65

,

08/03/2009 15:11:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
66

,

08/03/2009 15:12:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
67

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 15:17:13
invictager

Unfortunately, Whittaker could score a hat-trick and win MOTM, but WS would still recall Broadfoot for the CIS Final.

Another of his "safety-first" blind spots.
68

,

08/03/2009 15:18:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
69

,

08/03/2009 15:20:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
70

,

08/03/2009 15:21:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
71

,

08/03/2009 15:22:27
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
72

,

08/03/2009 15:22:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
73

,

08/03/2009 15:23:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
74

,

08/03/2009 15:24:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
75

,

08/03/2009 15:24:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
76

,

08/03/2009 15:26:29
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
77

,

08/03/2009 15:31:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
78

,

08/03/2009 15:31:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
79

,

08/03/2009 15:33:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
80

,

08/03/2009 15:35:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
81

,

08/03/2009 15:36:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
82

,

08/03/2009 15:38:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
83

,

08/03/2009 15:38:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
84

,

08/03/2009 15:40:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
85

,

08/03/2009 15:41:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
86

,

08/03/2009 15:41:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
87

,

08/03/2009 15:43:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
88

,

08/03/2009 15:43:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
89

,

08/03/2009 15:48:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
90

,

08/03/2009 15:49:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
91

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 15:52:16
Rangers worthy of being in front, IMO, but Hamilton are having a go when they can, for which I commend them.

Can't really see the big issues here. Lafferty probably offside, but a tough call, and I like to see attackers given the benefit where the decision is contentious.

As for the penalty? Certainly spared Aaron's blushes, but it was certainly a technically correct decision. It's a bit like the wall being ten yards back at a free kick, it hardly ever is, and the referee tends to let it slide 99 times out of 100, but just occasionally, it's good for an official to punish the offender, to remind us all that the rule exists.

Looking good for Rangers.
92

Riot_Survivor,

08/03/2009 15:54:56
#181 - the cup game no' on the season ticket then?

93

,

08/03/2009 15:57:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
94

,

08/03/2009 16:01:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
95

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:01:33
Where's the corruption exactly?

Was the first RFC goal not legitimate?

Was the second goal not a very close decision that had to be made instantly by the officials?

Was the third goal not a legitimately awarded penalty?

Was the retake decision not a technically correct one?

Your desperation to see Rangers lose, or to discredit their victory, is all too obvious.
96

,

08/03/2009 16:05:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
97

,

08/03/2009 16:10:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
98

,

08/03/2009 16:13:54
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
99

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 16:15:48
I've watched the game in snatches, but it seems that the threadbears are well on top both in terms of the score and the balance of play...could end up with 6 or 7.

Small compensation though for 'Black Wednesday'.
100

,

08/03/2009 16:17:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
101

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 16:17:30
BTW

Looks like a very poor attendance.
102

,

08/03/2009 16:18:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
103

,

08/03/2009 16:19:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
104

,

08/03/2009 16:19:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
105

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 16:20:42
Here comes boydbenchio...'ah'm no' playin' if the manajur wullnae play me....'xcept if it's the rainjurz , likesae.'
106

,

08/03/2009 16:21:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
107

,

08/03/2009 16:21:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
108

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:22:39
Tim

I'm in the other camp.

The league is the bigger trophy, but we have ten more chances including an OF match at Ibrox to rectify our slip-up.

Get it wrong in the cup and it's over.

If it turns out that Celtic win the league by three points or less, then I may have cause to reconsider.
109

Riot_Survivor,

08/03/2009 16:30:59
I know I shouldn't laugh, but watching an average player show boating in a game whilst his team are hammering the other (down to 10 men with a couple of dubious decision going against them) and actually injuring himself in the process...well....you've gotta admit that its worth a chuckle
110

,

08/03/2009 16:35:03
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
111

Ajax MacKindling,

08/03/2009 16:35:47
Lazy Sunday afternoon watching the footy.

Great goal Whittaker.
Bougerra pushed into the keeper for the equaliser, but no way the officials could have seen that without a replay.
Lafferty tap in looked off, then looked on, then off??
Even the replay isn't conclusive.
Clear penalty, Swailes could have had a red.
Technically correct decision for the retake, but its odd that these are so seldom given.
Great goal by Davis.
Another by Lafferty.
Accies very unlucky with injuries throughout.

10 minutes to go, and just another humdrum game in the diddy cup.
112

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:36:00
invictager

Could be foresight on Walter's part. He may need McCulloch to play centre-back in the CIS. I sincerely hope that Walter goes 4-4-2 next week and takes the game to Celtic, however there's no way that he'll do that unless he has his strongest defence on the park.
113

,

08/03/2009 16:36:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
114

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 16:42:13
Cannot believe the cheatin going on here, what a game but this is what the rearangers need a big win against a diddy team takes the heat aff Minty & Wally for another 6 days, but next Monday they'll be asked to leave again, but you and I know no one at Ibrox will listen to to the hoards.

Keep the cup
4inaRow
115

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:43:20
#217

A suitably bitter post.
116

,

08/03/2009 16:43:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
117

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 16:46:22
218 thank you, but what was bitter
118

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:48:48
What was bitter?

Take your pick...

"cheating"

"keep the cup"

"next Monday they'll be asked to leave"

"no one will listen to the hoards" (should be "hordes" by the way)

etc etc.
119

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:50:25
I'm predicting

St Mirren V Falkirk

Rangers V Aberdeen/Dunfermline
120

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 16:51:45
Take your pick 224

The offside goal or penalty retake
121

,

08/03/2009 16:53:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
122

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:54:06
#227

You don't think that the Hamilton keeper committed an infringement at the original penalty?

What a bizarre assertion.
123

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 16:54:25
Keeping yoursel amused BE writen your cra-p, keep it up big ot
124

,

08/03/2009 16:55:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
125

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 16:59:10
233, no he wasn't
126

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 16:59:27
oh dear

Now Finnharp is getting all bitter towards me.

Why don't you just answer the question. Was the decision to order the penalty to be retaken due to the Hamilton keeper committing an infringement a correct decision or not?

It's a simple "yes" or "no", so you should be able to handle it.
127

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:05:54
St Mirren at Hampden. That could have been an OF semi-final. I suppose that's when you realise the loss of being out of the Cup.

Good all-round performance today. Was particularly glad to see Lafferty score two well taken goals. Hopefully he can kick on from here. I still reckon that we're outsiders for the SPL title, but the Treble dream lives on.

C'mon the 'Gers.
128

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:07:07
No it was not, the linesman was a homer its as simple as that. Was the second goal offside "yes" or "no" so you should handle that, unles you cannot type with your blue specs on
129

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:08:57
finnharp

So the goalkeeper did not infringe at the penalty kick?

Really?

Do you know the rules?
130

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:09:39
Scottish cup is the only thing you got going for yous, then its clear out time, no one coming in should be an interesting season next year, unless SMinty pawn his other
131

,

08/03/2009 17:09:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
132

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:10:32
241 No goalie never moved and I believe I know the rules, maybe you can tell me
133

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:11:08
Even if the second goal was offside, it doesn't constitute cheating, which is what you're claiming. It merely means that the linesman, forced to make a quick decision on a very close call, got it wrong, which is perfectly understandable.

The winning margin was 4 goals anyway, so it didn't really matter.
134

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:14:25
#243, they know that from Manchester on they have been found out even the illuminati has been released for all us none masonic people. We are the people has been found out and with it they have brought down not only Scotland (Scotlands Shame), but the brought down the whole of Great Britain & the US, thats what your years of we are the people has done.
135

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:14:57
#244

Yep, maybe I can.

The goalkeeper has to be on the goal-line at the moment that the ball is kicked.

Was the Hamilton keeper on the line at the moment that the ball was kicked?

The truth, now...
136

,

08/03/2009 17:15:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
137

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:16:47
245: It would never had been a 4 goal margin if yous didn't cheat 10 men you kidden

246: Whos laffing what have you won yet, when was the last time you saw europe
138

,

08/03/2009 17:16:49
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
139

Riot_Survivor,

08/03/2009 17:19:00
The rules actually explicitly state that the keeper can move along the line, but not advance from it.

Correct decision is a re-take, so technically the linesman got it right.

The issue is that this rule is never observed and seems to only have been used for a Rangers penalty miss.

Note...it does not state that a keeper can come a certain amount of yards off the line, but MUST remain ON the line.

In that context...why was this penalty never re-taken?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBrPZAZtabM

140

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:19:59
248: he was clearly on his line
141

,

08/03/2009 17:20:10
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
142

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:21:43
#254

Quit while you're behind.

there's not a single poster from either side who believes that, and neither do you.
143

,

08/03/2009 17:25:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
144

,

08/03/2009 17:26:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
145

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:27:59
256:

When was the last time you travelled to Europe to watch your team without getting yoursels intae trouble Scotland Shame indeed

257:You know youve been exposed, ear of deception you know it we know and now the rest of the World is getting it, all those years of not hiring RCs, its coming back big time, illuminati conspiracy indeed, a good read.
146

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:29:27
#257

Translation?
147

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:33:18
Wouldn't it be refreshing to see a Celtic poster come on and say something like...

"Deserved win for Rangers today, even if the scoreline slightly flattered you. All the goals from open play were well taken, although there was a strong hint of offside about your second, and the decision to award a penalty retake, whilst correct, was a little unusual. Nonetheless, you took care of business in a way that we were unable to yesterday, so well done, and I expect you to go on and lift the Cup now."

It only requires fair mindedness and a good sporting attitude, after all.
148

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:34:03
262 nice one execpt for Manchester, were you totally disgraced the country, never mind its typical of you lot, deflect and blame someone else, you are true blue all right, why don't you show some balls and get Minty out, oh thats right noone likes you and you don't care.
ha haha ha
149

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 17:36:35
A convincing win for the threadbears, but does little to console their fanz for 'Black Wednesday' (as in Ian Black.)

League business is now deep frozen, and the rearrangerz will have to wait a whole fortnight before they can get so much as a sniff at cutting the champions' lead...and guess what, it's the jam fertz who will provide the opposition.

Not an easy three points by any stretch of the imagination, no sir-ee !
A draw is a very distinct possibility, which would hand Celtic a glorious opportunity to stretch their lead further.

But it's the wait, isn't it ? It's having to sit around, hoping, wondering ...whilst the champions sit comfortably at the top.

Holding the lead in the spl as we go into the break is like a warm douvet on a cold winter night...I just snuggle up, book in hand...ahhhhh.



150

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:37:28
Hide behind your keyboard, you only Hide behind your keyboard, Hide behind your keyboard, you only Hide behind your keyboard, thats wasn't me thats your wonderful owner, good to see neither of the rearangers have commented on the illuminati, to obvious
151

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:38:44
It consoles me Patrick

A Cup final coming up. A semi-final to follow. And still in the SPL race with an OF match at Ibrox still to come.

Shaping up to be an exciting end of season for the 'Gers.
152

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:40:11
The league is over why don't you go home
153

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 17:42:14
#268

You sink deeper and deeper into the realms of surrealism and irrelevance. Your bitterness is palpable, and your hatred of all things RFC is as sad as it is obvious.

I'm actually glad that you support Celtic.

154

Finnharp,

08/03/2009 17:45:54
271: Thank you, you just made my day I must go now as Ive work to do, anyway before I go;

1). The keeper moved
2). The second goal was on the line, its been fun thought

Will enjoy the next 12 weeks, see where the league ends up.
155

Riot_Survivor,

08/03/2009 17:49:31
#263 - my point was singularly about the biggest decision of the game and in retort to other posters debating it.

The question asked was whether the re-take of the penalty was the correct decision of the ref, which I am happy to go on record as stating is correct.

I am also happy to state that to see this happen is unusual considering the amount of times it happens.

The example I posted was Alan MacGregor similarly coming off his line for a pen save at Celtic Park with no re-take awarded. This passed without any comment. There's probably hundreds of similar example which are not re-take and pass without comment.

Seems a tad strange that this rule is now being fully implemented and I would hope to see it further implemented in games across Europe....don;t think it will though.

Thats been the gist of my post....never stated anything else about the performance today.Good, bad or indifferent.
156

Shape to Shoot,

08/03/2009 17:49:59
271

Can't see it being a blow for whichever team loses tbqh.
If the champions win, very nice, we'll take it, if not, we just knuckle down for 4 in a row.
157

Hobo Harry,

08/03/2009 18:13:26
264 BEMUSED EXILE

"Deserved win for Rangers today, even if the scoreline slightly flattered you. All the goals from open play were well taken, although there was a strong hint of offside about your second, and the decision to award a penalty retake, whilst correct, was a little unusual. Nonetheless, you took care of business in a way that Celtic were unable to yesterday, so well done, and I expect you to go on and lift the Cup now."

There, a Hibee can do it......
158

BEMUSED EXILE,

08/03/2009 18:33:35
Thanks HH.

Never underestimate the power of "copy and paste".
159

,

08/03/2009 18:54:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
160

,

08/03/2009 19:00:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
161

Jimmy Mallet,

08/03/2009 19:34:22
punytit-yeraweeclulezwanka,anatramparzetaeboot

awa'wiyeyasmellygypo
162

Jimmy Mallet,

08/03/2009 19:37:43
rearrangerzhivnaechancetogitootofdebt,ifweesmellytramparzeslikepunytit,urnaegointaecupgames

punytitanthousandzlikehim,urjistmurrayzersewipes
163

Hobo Harry,

08/03/2009 19:57:50
278 thepundit™, Thanks for that, I've been working a ridiculous amount of hours but we met the deadline and I can go back to some kind of normality....
164

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 20:37:15
287 Jimmy Mallet

You're the biggest ar*e wipe to come on these threads.

Away and play with yourself.......again!
165

Daillyman,

08/03/2009 20:57:46
291

2 well taken goals today that will make the high lite reel.

The one goal that some posters say was offside was a close one, but they get the replays in slow motion on the telly, the linesman and referee dont have that luxury.

The penalty retake was a decision that many refs would not have given, but to the letter of the law the keeper did move forward of the line before the ball was struck.

Why certain tic supporters call RFC cheats for decisions made by match officials is now bordering on the amusing, they seem very child like in their posts.

Overall a decent performance, good ball movement, possession, and a wee bit of flair to add to the excitement of the result.

Still a tough cup final to come next week, as I am sure the tic players will show more passion for a cup final than their supporters who post on these threads.
166

Ajax MacKindling,

08/03/2009 21:12:46
Lots of bemoaning of the officials decisions on here this evening, from fans who "don't care about the cup" anyway.

Clearly Rangers deserved to go through to the next round.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.