Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 29th June 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Ministers to scrap PE pledge for schools



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 April 2008
A GOVERNMENT promise that schoolchildren get at least two hours of PE a week is to be scrapped, despite growing concern about the health of Scotland's youngsters.
Figures obtained by Scotland on Sunday show some schoolchildren currently receive as little as 45 minutes of organised sport each week and most schools are falling short of the two-hour target.

The Scottish Government will announce next month that
it is ditching the target – a key election pledge – and concentrating on "outcome-based" policies that will make children fitter.

But opposition politicians and health campaigners accused the SNP-led Government of letting Scotland's children down and abandoning the battle against obesity.

One in five Scots 12-year-olds were obese in the 2004-05 school year, posing huge health implications for later life.

The two-hour PE recommendation was originally made by a Scottish Government review group in 2004 endorsed by the then Labour education minister Peter Peacock. At the time it was seen as a vital tool to help fight Scotland's weight crisis.

The SNP's 2007 election manifesto also pledged to give "every pupil two hours of quality PE each week delivered by specialist PE teachers".

But the Scottish Government last night admitted it is set for talks with council chiefs about abandoning targets with immediate effect.

A spokesman added: "It is indeed still a major priority to help create healthy, fit and active children in Scotland. But it has now been agreed that the new curriculum framework should be outcome-based with no input requirements in terms of subject or time allocations.

"Many authorities felt the target was a blunt instrument and was not always helpful in trying to achieve the outcomes sought. Some local authority areas are delivering two hours of PE a week, but this approach does not suit all authorities."

Dr Colin Waine, of the National Obesity Forum, said: "It's funny how targets are deemed unhelpful when it becomes clear that they're not being met.

"If councils can't make the grade because they're under-resourced then they should tell us instead of hiding behind this cop-out language."

He added: "Physically, Scotland is in critical condition. Childhood obesity means there is an enormous number of youngsters whose health will be severely compromised in the future.

"Government has a responsibility to emphasise physical exercise in the curriculum because PE lessons have a positive effect, not just on pupils' weight but on their general fitness levels too."

Labour's education spokeswoman Rhona Brankin said: "Just like their broken promises on school buildings and class sizes, the SNP are letting children down. This decision will do nothing to encourage a love of sport in our young people."

Tory education spokesman Murdo Fraser said schools had a responsibility to encourage fitness in children.

He said: "Schools have to take the lead because unfortunately we all know that there are parents who simply won't. So it's a sad day when they can't even meet the most basic requirements of this strategy and leave Scotland with no hope of tackling this epidemic."

Matthew Elliott, of the Taxpayers' Alliance, claimed school funding was being "wasted" on bureaucrats. He said: "There is plenty of money in the schools system to provide two hours of PE a week, but at the moment much of it is wasted."

All children should receive two hours of PE by June this year. But information released under Freedom of Information laws shows that, on average, primary pupils get around 94 minutes of PE per week while, in secondary schools, the average allocation drops to 91 minutes.

Poorly performing schools included Gylemuir Primary, Edinburgh, with just 45 minutes a week, according to the FOI documents. But other schools exceeded the target, including Lady Alice Primary in Inverclyde, at 155 minutes a week for some pupils.

The average in Fife primaries was 85 minutes a week and in Highland primaries 78 minutes a week. In Edinburgh secondaries the figure was 69 minutes and in Orkney 60 minutes.

Yesterday, councils said they were trying to improve their PE provision. Councillor Marilyne MacLaren, education convener for Edinburgh City Council, said: "We are aware that our target for two hours per week of physical education in schools is still not being met, but we are actively addressing it."

Councillor Isabel Hutton, education spokeswoman for the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, said: "We are moving away from narrow targets and input measures – such as the two hours of PE per week – to focus on what is important: improving the health outcomes for children and tackling inequality."



The full article contains 766 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

The Answer,

Glasgow 12/04/2008 20:48:19
Maybe "the fat one" wants everybody to be a roll model like he!
2

DER FUHRER,

13/04/2008 00:03:45
Another day, another failed promise.
3

subrosa,

13/04/2008 01:04:39
What's wrong with telling children not to eat so much? Obesity is a problem to do with consuming too many calories for your activity level. Two hours of PE a week seems rather a lot considering today's curriculum. We had half an hour in the 50s plus a game of hockey/football on Saturdays. No obesity problem because we didn't get money for food and also we used our two feet to get around.
4

grayze,

13/04/2008 01:39:41
The Government, Local Authorities and the individual shools all have a role but, let's face it, it's those of us who are parents who have the main input. I take my two swimming or running or just taking the dog for a walk whenever I can (most of the time they force me into it anyway). Legislation won't work, common sense might!
5

grayze,

13/04/2008 01:42:00
Sorry, that should be schools and not shools.
6

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 13/04/2008 03:02:15
Whats the Problem,?...'NONE'!

Children hate PE, anyhow unless its made,..'Fun'!

2hours, or a sad 45mins, wont make any difference, when the child goes back home and,..'Eats The Buns'!

'Yes' PE, can possibly help, children get on their way of being fit,, but not if it is done,..'Army Style'

Children would be better to be asked and educated, about Physical 'Well-being', instead of being to be expected, to run from Edinburgh to London!

The whole topic is, ..'Absolute Nonsense'!

The Ministers have got it 'Right' for once!
7

R.I.P. HONEST BALANCED JOURNALISM,

13/04/2008 04:16:18
I would say the fact Labour flogged of all the sports fields convieniently placed right next to the schools made a 2 lesson untenable. By the time you get kids onto a bus, travel, get off bus and change it's time to head back.

At least some labour donors got some nice supermarkets though.
8

R.I.P. HONEST BALANCED JOURNALISM,

13/04/2008 04:18:10
#6 I am becoming a teacher! Loads of pay, 25 hour week and months off on holiday. either that or an MP or MSP
9

Vincent-W,

13/04/2008 06:46:10
It was never a realistic target, with all the other compulsory demands on the PS curriculum.

Where's parental responsibility?
10

fife runner,

13/04/2008 07:34:14
the PE at schools is useless anyway. My son and some of his club rugby players have picked up injuries prior to matches at PE sessions NOT because of the activity itself but having no warm up. They then have 30 mins twice a week if the PE teacher can be bothered. Luckily he does his own fitness both at home and his rugby club but the physical difference between him and his peers is very noticeable.

If we care about our kids we would not let them get ill through lifestyle. I have three and have always cajoled them to exercise which they now do themselves. Trouble is there is more to do for kids in the house today with pcs , tv etc. I spoke with one 10 year old at the school I help with cycling proficiency. He had not been out all weekend. He had been watching telly in hos room. His parents had been planked in front of the tv downstairs. That is child neglect.
11

Guga II,

Rockall 13/04/2008 08:08:27
Rhona Brankin has a brass neck criticising anyone. The New Labour Sleaze and Corruption Party had fifty years where they had total control over running things in Scotland. If they had been doing their job, instead of lining their own pockets, the country would be a virtual paradise.
12

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 13/04/2008 08:44:34
HOW Pathetic AND WEAK are we going to become when we get rid of PHYSICAL education. It should be MANDATORY that all MSP SHOULD GET OUT BEDD AND WORK OUT!!!!!!!!
13

Liberal for life,

Dunblane 13/04/2008 09:00:24
Dr Colin Waine, of the National Obesity Forum, said: "It's funny how targets are deemed unhelpful when it becomes clear that they're not being met.

He added: "Physically, Scotland is in critical condition. Childhood obesity means there is an enormous number of youngsters whose health will be severely compromised in the future.

"Government has a responsibility to emphasise physical exercise in the curriculum because PE lessons have a positive effect, not just on pupils' weight but on their general fitness levels too."

I will remind readers that only Nicol Stephen consistently tried during the debates prior to last may 3rd elections to get this crisis debated on TV and at every turn the pundits were diverted onto more "important issues" like a neverendum on Scottish so-called independence. Our kids health is far more important in a country that already has all the devolved democracy it can handle. We now need actions not words on the things that count in real peoples lives. The chattering classes inhabiting the SNP should be ashamed of this latest development as it highlights what their real priorities are and it obviously isn't the future health of our nation.
14

roughrider,

Glasgow 13/04/2008 10:20:13
Ranting Rhona Brankin , what have your sleaze ridden corrupt friend's been doing for the kids for the past 8 years?
SFA now away with you you stupid liebour clown
15

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 13/04/2008 10:24:51
Another day another non story.
Since when is it the governments responsiblity to parent children?? how many times have people complained about the nanny state??
If parents would stop feeding their kids sh*te then obesity wouldnt be the problem its supposed to be today.
In my day we played football on the streets or in the park as well as many other outside games nowadays you cannae get yer kids off the playstations long enough to see if its still light outside.
16

Tris,

Dundee 13/04/2008 11:00:01

Two hours of PE at school is a waste of time. There's too much to learn, and too little time. Kids are already leaving primary school unable to read and write. Parents should take responsibility for keeping kids fit, going to walks or swimming or playing football or whatever, instead of letting them sit in front of the computer/TV all day and stuffing them full of crisps and fizzy drink.

Now, that said, I'd better get off my butt and go for a run.
17

Highland Mighty,

13/04/2008 11:17:18
LOL. Oh, how the nats run to protect Salmond's reputation as he breaks yet another promise.

Controlled by Souter, controlled by Spanish energy firms and failing to keep key election promises.

SNP: Exploiting the gullibility of Scottish youth since 1934.
18

Highland Mighty,

13/04/2008 11:24:43
18. I forgot one....Salmond is also controlled by Trump!

Our little puppet leader.

Who will he bend over for next?
19

Miss H,

13/04/2008 11:34:57
Yet agaon the Scotsman misses the real stiry.

It's an outcome of the outcome agreement.

Central Government no longer has the ability to impose these kinds of targets on individual education authorities.
20

Miss H,

13/04/2008 11:41:10
14 The problem for you as a Liberal is that you would have to support central government being able to impose a blanket target on all local authorities even though local authorities are arguing against that.

You could debate who is right and who is wrong but on the issue of where the power lies a Liberal should actually agree with the SNP that it should be locally not nationally controlled.

The other issue of course is access to school facilities which with many PFI schools is very limited. It was never SNP policy to say that all PE should be delivered within school hours. After school is just as important as during school.
21

Stepford Nat,

13/04/2008 13:32:03
Most of todays kids were born while Liebore ran Holyrood, so this is yet another example of the SNP inheriting their disaster.

www.snp.org - Porridge Power!

22

Jimmy the Pie,

13/04/2008 14:15:41
Highland Mighty

Keeping a low profile today after last weeks humiliation?
23

Alan B,

13/04/2008 15:48:20
The school day should be lengthened to accommodate 1-1.5 hours of sporting activity per day.
24

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 13/04/2008 17:31:39
Alan B @#23,

Glad you weren't my PE teacher, you sound like a,

'Slave Driver'!
25

Caora Dubh,

Croit sheasgair 13/04/2008 20:01:08
Today's kids! Really! When I was little we all walked ten miles to school barefoot through a peat bog in midwinter through sleat and snow. If we were lucky the teacher would light a candle to keep us warm and allow us to rub our hands together. And every afternoon we had to play Uphelly-aa between the Butt of Leodhas and Renish Point at the southern tip of Na Hearadh, although it was the game of the Zetlanders. And we had to row to Eire to play hurley during the season. But seriously: we were extremely active children, and today's kids ought to have at least half an hour of strenuous physical activity each day; after all, what are those beautiful new centrally heated sports centres for? (We swam regularly in outdoor pools, tidal pools, and the sea.)
26

Caora Dubh,

Croit sheasgair 13/04/2008 20:14:00
P.E. is one of those fascinating issues that has never been sorted. Are government schools obliged to make children take part in physical activities, or should this be outside the remit of schools? In addition, there is a desperate need for some sort of organisation to fill that after-school vacuum. We need a nationwide network of after-school clubs for teenagers that offer a variety of different activities, with professionals giving of their time to provide instruction. What I am thinking of is an organisation that would arrange afternoons of archery, target shooting, sailing, canoeing, basic rock climbing, abseiling, horse riding, golfing, swimming coaching, diving, and the like. The problems are the cost of transport, safety, and professional supervision. But I am sure something could be done.
27

AJM,

13/04/2008 20:44:50
#20 Miss H are you really telling us that manifesto pledge could never be implemented because the SNP against this sort of centralised policy. Didi someone not bother to tell the manifesto authors.

Health of the nation is far more inportant than some meaningless conversation.

After school activity is for the already fit, I do not know what sort of school you went to Miss H but mine never had a school team full of the clinically obese. It is the ones who do not do the exercise that need it the most.
28

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 16/04/2008 21:31:58
All MSP'S SHOULD SET an EXAMPLE and attend at least 2HRS of COMPULSORY PE EVERY WEEK! Failure to do so would mean immediate DISMISSAL!!!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.