Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Calls to clarify police role after informant recruitment claims

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 April 2009
SCOTTISH justice secretary Kenny MacAskill was facing pressure last night to clarify police conduct after claims by an environmental protestor that officers tried to recruit her as a paid informant.
Matilda Gifford, of environment campaigners Plane Stupid, said police told her that they have a network of informants inside protest organisations, which they tried to persuade her to join.

The 24-year-old community worker from Glasgow said she wa
s approached by officers claiming to be from Strathclyde Police a few weeks after she was arrested in a protest at Aberdeen Airport in March.

Yesterday, Richard Baker, Labour's justice spokesman at Holyrood, said: "I am asking Kenny MacAskill to look into this issue so Parliament can be reassured the steps taken by police in this instance were appropriate. However, I am fully aware of the serious and reckless nature of the protest which took place at Aberdeen Airport."

Scottish Liberal Democrat justice spokesman Robert Brown added: "The justice secretary needs to clarify the extent of these activities and the amount of police effort devoted to them."

Gifford said yesterday she had exposed the police tactics because she wanted the officers to be "accountable". She added: "We openly say who we are and are willing to justify what we do. But we still don't really know who these people were."

Gifford said she had attended meetings at a Glasgow police station, which she recorded, and later in a cafe, where officers offered her financial rewards for information on Plane Stupid. She passed recordings of three conversations with police to a newspaper, which posted them on its website.

Gifford said the officers did not specify how much money would be offered, but that it would be tax free and cash in hand. When Gifford said she would not be interested if they were talking about "20 quid" she was told: "UK plc can afford more than 20 quid."

She said they warned her that her protest activities might damage her employment prospects, and the experience left her feeling intimidated.

She said: "They were playing games, trying to make me believe that other people in the group were already informing.

"The police are using sinister tactics and taxpayers' money. I think it raises serious questions about whether the police are there to protect the state and big business or to protect the civil liberties of people."

Gifford went to meet the officers a third time with her lawyer, but the police did not turn up. She said that about half an hour later one of the officers approached her and said he was 'disappointed'. Gifford said that when Plane Stupid's lawyer contacted Strathclyde Police to find out more about the officers, police denied any knowledge of them. Later they said that police had been in contact with Plane Stupid protesters.

Assistant Chief Constable George Hamilton said the force had "a responsibility to gather intelligence". He continued: "The purpose of this contact has been to ensure that any future protest activity is carried out within the law and in a manner which respects the rights of all concerned."

A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: "This is an operational matter for Strathclyde Police and, obviously, there is a requirement to balance the protection of individual civil liberties with ensuring the safety of the wider public. The justice secretary has discussed the matter with Strathclyde Police's Assistant Chief Constable and is satisfied the force has acted proportionately and legitimately."

A report by airport managers working for BAA, estimated the protest cost the airport £1m with passengers, airlines, handling agents and retailers all hit when flights were brought to a standstill. Around 20 flights - including an air ambulance - faced delays, while 19 flights were cancelled when the protest was staged.

On March 4, six men and three women appeared at Aberdeen Sheriff Court charged with breach of the peace and vandalism in connection with the protest. The nine appeared on petition and were released on bail with the special condition they do not go near airports.





The full article contains 677 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 April 2009 7:29 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Scottish National Party
 
1

Fifi la Bonbon,

26/04/2009 00:10:54
The police regularly pay informants to find out about crimes past, present, and likely to happen in the future. Plane Stupid is clear that their tactics include criminal activities. The difference is that its members tend to be nicely middle and upper class chaps and gels with names like Tilly and Ben, many of whom are past or present students of social anthropology and the like, rather than the kind of people you see on The Bill. That's why their peers in the media are so upset and shocked by this.
2

old copper,

dumfries 26/04/2009 00:49:21
Of course the Police offer payments to individuals to provide them with information regarding crime. I know I did when I was a serving officer and it is a practice which has gone on since police forces came into existence.
How else would the Police obtain information if they did not offer some kind of inducement or reward for information received?
If the rewarding of informants ever ceased, many criminals would go undetected and society would be worse off.
I really don't see what the fuss is about.

3

Aeternum Vale,

Wellingborough 26/04/2009 00:52:33
Plane Stupid is already riddled with interlopers, from one team and another, and it has been for some time - with a mix of political, industrial and security sponsors. Indeed if the all this covert infestation was entirely eradicated Plane Stupid would virtually fail to exist - you would just be left with the plummy do-gooders who fail to know of, let alone understand, the far reaching and multi-faceted political agenda internationally conceded to that drives the unscientific fallacy of so called 'man-made' carbon-emissions derived global warming.
4

,

26/04/2009 00:59:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Fifi la Bonbon,

26/04/2009 01:02:19
I bet Colin R used to be some kind of clerk or cashier in a police HQ who got "asked to leave for the efficiencies of the service!"
6

donald,

glasgow 26/04/2009 01:50:41
The Great British "left" in Scotlandshire have long been agents of the British State.
7

2Right,

On Location 26/04/2009 04:26:08
So if you are happy Mr MacAskill then please tell us exactly how much more public funds are wasted in this fashion.

Pity Brown & Baker & Co do not call for the same enquiries into the many Miscarriages in Scotland.

All this at a time when Whistleblowers are being Sacked
8

2Right,

26/04/2009 04:30:09
She said: "They were playing games, trying to make me believe that other people in the group were already informing.

Nothing seems to have changed in the old police tactics then I see ?
9

pitpony,

musselburgh 26/04/2009 08:59:02
tory party did this during miners strike.nothing new here! stopped by special branch on way home from bilston glen asked where i had come from where i was going they where told to pee off. phones tapped- followed. they thought i was telling pickets info but i was doing emergency shift work.dont use phones get a pigeon
10

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 26/04/2009 09:54:20
I can't believe folk are surprised at this. I am just quite glad that the police are doing something 'police' like instead of dreaming up new ways to cream money off decent hardworking citizens !?

I am usually a bit harsh with the old rozzers as I do believe they have fundamentally lost their direction and on the verge of betraying the people they are supposed to protect .. but on this occasion they are doing exactly what they should do!

Intelligent and informants are key in dealing with any 'suspect' oganisation - well done rozzers - some of you are still good eggs !
11

Fifi la Bonbon,

26/04/2009 09:55:20
Reading some of the more recent comments, am I to take it that the police are to stop paying informants for information about possible crime? Or are there certain kinds of offences that should no longer be investigated?

For example, if it becomes apparent that there is a group of people who are determined to invade airports and disrupt them by going onto runways and so on, should the police try to find out who they are, and what they plan to do and when they plan to do it? Or is disrupting airports "fair game" and "legitimate protest?" Because when Mr Mohammed Asha and Mr Bilal Abdulla, and the late Mr Kafeel Ahmed made their protest at Glasgow Airport in June 2007 it would have been nice if the police had known. Pehaps the cips should exempt posh people - but weren't the Glasgow bombers doctors?

#7 thinks such police tactics are redolent of a police state, and worse, English, despite the fact that #2, a former serving officer, confirms that police have always done this. #8 thinks its a waste of public funds. #9 thinks cops ought never to lie to possible informants, and #10 is convinced he or she has been in special branch files since the days of the miners' strike.

Very confusing. How can you keep "nice" people exempt from the heavy hand of the fascist jackboot English state? Maybe #6 Donald Anderson could be roped in to advise the police (joke).
12

Stan Butler,

26/04/2009 10:04:35

Plane Stupid give demonstrators a bad name.

Here's what Ian Bone has to say about them on his blog.

PLANE FU*CKING STUPID - THE ECO TOFFS -EVEN THE INFILTRATORS COME FROM OXFORD!


PLANE STUPID - The ECO-TOFF organisation that wants to ‘MAKE PLANES HISTORY’ - and bring back the Penny Farthing and whooping cough and link the GROAT to the DUBLOON on the currency exchanges - has been ‘infiltrated’ by a spy from a corporate security company. Toby the spy was from OXBRIDGE - just so he’d fit in with the rest of the toffs! TAMSIN OMOND of PLANE STUPID has a high media profile after climbing onto the House of commons roof and ‘invading a christmas ice skating rink’ because it was sponsored by BA. Her grandfather is SIR THOMAS LEES - a fourth generation baronet who owns huge swathes of land in Dorset and her father a retired city banker. Tamsin was educated at fee paying schools - westminster College dontcha know -before going to Trinity College Cambridge where ’she shared a flat with two other leading members of Plane Stupid. Tamsin says ‘I am the perfect force, because of my background, to unite hardcore green activists with wealthy west londoners’. The evening standard says admiringly ‘ It is indicative of the new breed of eco-warriors that so many are well spoken and well educated’. I HEREBY ANNOUNCE A NEW ORGANISATION - ‘MAKE ECO-TOFFS HISTORY’ - BADLY SPOKEN AND ILL EDUCATED RABBLE WELCOME!

bird.jpgTAMSIN REVEALS PLANE STUPID’S ALTERNATIVE PLANS FOR AIR TRAVEL

I’ve written before about ECO-TOFFS - any anarchists who thinks they are some kind of radical movement should be………….sent to the sculleries!
13

Fifi la Bonbon,

26/04/2009 10:05:58
Well now I didn't know that, Stan.
14

Wisnaeme,

26/04/2009 12:12:53
Labour getting a bit tetchy over reassurances about whatever then? it went on during New Labour's swarry in Scotland with varying degrees of failure, incompetence and embarrassment too.
PC Paddy with a 'regional accent has their part to play in the anti- terr.... erm surveillance and information gathering. With the occasional venture into the manufacturing of events to provide ersatz substance of 'we told you so'. It helps with the fear monger and gives a sort of credibility to the justification of the anti terror legislation by New Labour politicos, don't you know.
Besides, these Polis from the provinces have had quite a lot of experience in surveillance and security due to past events there, do they not?
Seems a waste not to use those folk with their experience and expertise in whatever.

I just though ah'd mention that ah've had my experiences with those folk as well whilst 'doing' the campaigning for this and that in the past.

That nice man who bought me a pint in a Portree hotel and got into conversation, or was that an informal interview in pleasant surroundings. Makes a change, from the usual Mr nice plod and Mr nasty plod in wee rooms equiped with a profusion of bright lights, ah suppose.
Nice to know, you had an interest in guns, Mr Plod.

...and how kind of you to enquire if I had the same interest in a roundabout way, naturally..... Which ah didn't!!

Now why would one of the most successful and peaceful, civil disobedience campaigns have a need to be discredited and be branded as dangerous to the establishment, Mr plod? Why indeed.

...and the polis, CPS, certain politicos and their vested interest pals, and the establishment would have absolutely no motive for discrediting citizens engaged in being against some sort of thing or other that is in disagreement with the afore mentioned institutions.

...Would they? No of coarse they wouldn't and flying pigs are but mere figments of our imaginations too!!

...aren't they?
.
15

Fifi la Bonbon,

26/04/2009 12:22:24
#15 - that was an interesting tour inside your head, and you have certainly boosted your radical credibility with artfully dropped hints that you have had a past involvement with the police, but it doesn't actually say what you think about police paying informants.

I suspect that you are just a poseur.
16

Wisnaeme,

26/04/2009 12:42:59
Post 15.

Ach aye, ah was known to the polis ...and other folk.

But you're probably right. Although reported to the proculator fiscal and myself having the kind invitations to pay a visit to themselves... I was never proven guilty of even dropping a sweetie paper on the floor.

Aye, ah must have been harmless then...

and like yerself, they took me fer a poseur.

Suits my purpose ah suppose, being ra harmless loon that ah am.
.
17

uno.who,

Livingston 26/04/2009 12:48:50
I'm with Fifi and Voldemort on this one.

It's nothing new, and totally expected police behaviour.

They asked the eco-toff Matilda to join, she refused, so what's to investigate?
18

lulach mac gille coemgain,

26/04/2009 21:14:30
Don’t criminals also approach the police in a similar manner? It would be interesting to see which side has the better recruitment campaign.
19

Wisnaeme,

26/04/2009 22:41:57
Post 19.

The side that has the most money to spend on accomodations, hence the side having the most influence, power and connections.

Am I being too cynical here? Not really.

Phone call from a nobody's residence to plod complaining of damage to property. If they're lucky they'll receive a crime incident number and a visit maybe later, sometime, maybe never.

Phone call from a somebody's residence to plod on the same matter may elicit a more prompt reaction.

It's a question of priorities, really. Ask Westmidden politicians who matters most, folk with money and influence or folk with little of either.

...and that is the way of it in today's little Britain and it's whots init for me culture. Sad isn't it.
.
.
20

Teofilio Cubillas,

27/04/2009 08:50:15
"Matilda Gifford - the 24-year-old community worker from Glasgow"

Which says all you need to know about her.....
21

response,

Syd 05/07/2009 10:05:03
You have really stirred the pot this time Fi Fi.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.