Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Tory confesses, but mystery of Mandela plaque continues

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
09 December 2007
SEVENTEEN years after the man himself walked free from prison, the Nelson Mandela TV Lounge plaque is also free.
The deputy leader of the Scottish Conservatives has finally made a belated contribution to the truth and reconciliation process by admitting stealing a university memorial to the former ANC leader.

As a right-wing student in Aberdeen during the 1
980s Murdo Fraser said he "appropriated" a plaque honouring Mandela but has now returned the engraved "trophy" to students.

However, his alma mater's union has still to see any sign of it. And Fraser's act of youthful folly has been condemned as "outrageous" and "infantile" by a senior lecturer at the university.
Murdo Fraser, picture circa 1990s, took the memorial from the students' union at Aberdeen University during the 1980s, when he was an undergraduate
Murdo Fraser, picture circa 1990s, took the memorial from the students' union at Aberdeen University during the 1980s, when he was an undergraduate

The list MSP for Mid-Scotland and Fife graduated from Aberdeen with an LLB in 1986 before becoming the chairman of both the Scottish and UK Young Conservatives.

During that time he gained a reputation as a champion of unfashionable right-wing causes and a strong opponent of the leftist views usually associated with student life.

As such, Fraser could not resist stirring up controversy when his fellow undergraduates named a room in the students' union after the South African freedom fighter.

The removal of the plaque sparked outrage on campus but the culprit remained untraced and the metal memorial was never returned. When Mandela was freed in 1990 and then went on to become president in 1994 it became largely forgotten.

Now, after the passing of more than two decades, the former solicitor decided the time was right to come clean.

He said: "At one point in time in the 1980s the Aberdeen University Union housed the rather grandly titled Nelson Mandela TV Lounge.

"One night the plaque to this lounge was appropriated by a person or persons unknown.

"All that I can say is that it came into my possession and remained there for around 20 years."

The Tory decided to return the plaque after being invited to give a talk at a Christmas party organised by current members of the university's Conservative Association.

"During my speech I produced the plaque and felt it would be fitting to present it to the chairman. It was a gesture that was warmly welcomed by the gathered students and this item is now back in Aberdeen where it belongs."

During the 1980s a section of over-zealous young Tory students gained notoriety by wearing "Hang Mandela" T-shirts and badges, but Fraser insisted there was no malice meant in his own actions.

"This was a bit of a student prank aimed at winding up some of the lefties on campus.

"There was certainly no real high-politics involved and it was not meant to be taken seriously."

But Dr Michael Dyer, a long-serving member of the university's politics and international relations department, felt Fraser's "outrageous prank" was misguided and out of touch. He said: "By and large at that time there was a recognition across a wide political spectrum that Mandela's imprisonment was unjust.

"Mrs Thatcher, of course, chose to regard him as a terrorist - possibly reflecting the views of her husband and his cronies, her own eccentricity and cussedness towards fashionable liberal causes.

"Conservative students were few in those days and those that joined such an unfashionable cause deliberately adopted 'nutty' right-wing views largely, one suspects, for the hell of it and to out-Thatcher the Thatcherites. Murdo Fraser's action simply reflected the infantile nature of much right-wing student activity."

The respected academic claimed that the Thatcher era was one of the few to provoke controversy on campus.

He said: "Aberdeen is not noted for political activity amongst its student population with their most notable contribution being to provide bus drivers during the General Strike of 1926."

Aberdeen University Student Association believed the plaque had not yet been returned.

Its president, Angela Fraser (no relation), said: "We have seen no sign of it."

DURING his 27 years behind bars Nelson Mandela became an icon of resistance against the racist South African Apartheid regime that jailed him.

He was particularly venerated in Scotland's seats of learning. In the 1980s, Strathclyde University Union renamed a bar in his honour and he was named as an honorary member of the association. There was controversy in 1987 when Winnie Mandela, his then wife, was named as Glasgow University's rector, amid fears over her probity.

But the university's links to the anti-Apartheid movement were far deeper, and back in 1962, a young Donald Dewar fought unsuccessfully to have the Nobel Prize-winning then leader of the ANC, Albert Lutuli, installed as the rector.

But there was not universal acclaim for Mandela on campuses. In the 1980s, members of the Federation of Conservative Students declared the future South African President to be "a communist terrorist".



The full article contains 801 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Maisie from Morningside,

Morningside 09/12/2007 01:38:22

Remember also "Naked Video"
Andy Gray asks Elaine Smith for directions... "Go down Nelson Mandela Road, turn left into Nelson Mandela Street, cross from Nelson Mandela Square into Nelson Mandela Avenue then go up Nelson Mandela Lane...."
or words to that effect.

2

Gnasher,

09/12/2007 01:49:12

Young tories in those days were completely foul. The men looked like Mr Fraser, and you can only imagine that the women who spent time with them saw some prospect of an easy life in the future. But they really were putrid types. They took perverse pleasure in behaving like beasts - homophobic, racist bullies. Few survived to this day.

3

the_figures_are _fudged,

Galashiels 09/12/2007 02:50:37

"Misguided and out of touch", hmmmmmmmm sounds like Murdo hasn't changed in 20 years then

4

donald,

weegieland 09/12/2007 07:27:32

Thatcher said Mandela should be released unconditionally, whilst Kinnockio wanted him to renounce "violence" first. The British Nationalist student "left" groups campaigned to get Kinnockio In by running a "Towries Aht" campaign.

Remember how they also campaigned for Labour "Troops IN" and "Trory Troops Aht"?

5

Gnasher,

09/12/2007 07:30:10

donald from weegieland is talking rubbish.

6

A Better Way,

09/12/2007 07:45:59

Obviously this act was a signal to us all that Murdo is a sympathiser to the right wing ways of the former South African Racist Government.

The thing about this guy that has always impressed me is his capacity to let bygones be bygones, when most of us would simply hate. He put his country ahead of his personal opinion. Got to admire that in anybody.

We better send for him to come and sort out the Unionist Traitors who continue to discriminate against the SNP Scottish Government who only want the best for its own kind. Scottish People.

7

Inspector Murdoch,

Drylaw. 09/12/2007 08:12:51

I for one would arrest him for theft or reset.
It is a shame that being a life long tw*t is not a criminal offense

8

Boy Wonder,

09/12/2007 08:57:26

Typical Tory. Hanging's too good for them! The best way to treat them is to never let them get into any positions of power.

You must also remember, they are the original party of self-interest and self-aggrandisement. They despise the working the class and can never change! No matter what bandwagon Cameron jumps on this week. New Labour are bad enough ... but don't forget what this lot are capable of ... and Murdo Fraser is a prime example!

9

Mikey,

09/12/2007 09:08:38

Ah the Thatcher/Reagan years when human rights were trampled on all over the globe and the wrong side was constantly backed. Much better today when human rights are trampled on all over the globe and the wrong side is constantly backed.......

Plus ca change....

10

Kobi,

09/12/2007 10:41:10

WTF was a student union doing spending public money debating about such stuff, and spending money on plaques? Student union funds (public money) should have been spent representing and providing services for students.

Well done Fraser.

11

I'm no really here,

09/12/2007 11:33:53

It was on sale at Eastgate last week-end.

12

Bobo,

09/12/2007 12:02:56

What a hideous picture, particularly the vile tie and oh so anti-fashion hairdo.

I wonder if MF was one of those Tory students who in championing unfashionable causes at one time sported "Hang Nelson Mandela" T-shirts. They were neo-fascist, neo-imperialist, supremacist scum when Murdo stole the plaque - they're the same scum today.

13

Nurse,

09/12/2007 16:18:02

He looks like Stanley Baxter circa 1963!!!! Hilarious photo!!!!

14

ChrisW,

Brisbane 09/12/2007 23:23:39

Am I being too cynical in being surprised that, assuming he is accurately reported, the good Dr Dyer's primary criterion for selecting worthy causes appears to be that they are "fashionable"? Appears to put his opinions on the same level as those solicited by "real life" phone-in TV shows such as Big Brother, Pop Idol ..... and all the rest.

15

Willie Macleod,

Wick 10/12/2007 01:58:06

#Bobo Gnasher Well said #15 The great Scottish actor and entertainer Stanley Baxter cant be associated with the young Fraser and his ilk.

16

Mark Johnston,

Edinburgh 10/12/2007 07:43:29

Number 9 - What complete, somewhat ignorant, rubbish to say the Conservatives hate the working classes; Margaret Thatcher was working class (born above a greengrocer's shop) and John Major started off his working life as a builder's labourer. Conservatives want everyone to get on and want to see people rise up the social scale through increased opportunity and choice.

Returning to the point, as a fellow Conservative (current) student, may I just say we have changed quite a lot since then.

17

Boy Wonder,

10/12/2007 10:24:31

Working class people who join the Chories are traitors ... and they don't care because they're out for themselves!

The only good Chory is one that's six feet under.

18

,

16/12/2007 00:40:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.