Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Confusion reigns as Goldie rules herself out of Presiding Officer role

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 May 2007
TORY leader Annabel Goldie has ruled herself out of becoming the next Presiding Officer at Holyrood.
Her decision has left widespread confusion about who might take over from George Reid when MSPs vote on the matter on Wednesday. The new 'speaker' must be in place before a government can be formed.

Goldie had been tipped by many to resign as lea
der of the Conservatives to undertake the role, as the previous favourite, former deputy presiding officer Murray Tosh, failed to secure re-election as a Tory MSP on Thursday.

It is understood that Reid has privately urged Goldie to go for the job, and her firm manner and background as a lawyer would appear to make her a strong candidate.

The make-up of the new parliament would also favour a senior Tory in the role, but a party spokesman said yesterday that it was "100% sure" that Goldie would instead remain as party leader.

Conservative sources said Goldie wanted to build on a successful election campaign. "She doesn't want to pack it in just when she's beginning to enjoy it," said one MSP.

The incredibly tight election result means it may now be difficult to find an alternative candidate to be Presiding Officer, and pressure will be applied to Goldie in an attempt to get her to change her mind.

The Presiding Officer frames the timetable for business in the Scottish Parliament, including choosing who gets to question the First Minister at Question Time. The Presiding Officer also controls behaviour in the debating chamber and has the power to discipline MSPs who step out of line.

It is a highly prestigious post, previously held by senior parliamentarians Reid, originally an SNP MSP, and Sir David Steel, the former Lib Dem leader.

The main problem with filling the role this time around is that whoever takes it on will lose their vote on the floor of the Scottish Parliament. That is a sacrifice none of the major parties who are in contention for a role in government are willing to make.

The other current deputy presiding officer, Labour MSP Trish Godman, is seen as an ideal candidate by many and it is said to be 'Labour's turn' after SNP and Lib Dem holders of the office. However, the Labour party is desperate not to hand a further advantage to the SNP after it clinched a one-seat lead in Thursday's poll.

Liberal Democrat MSP Ross Finnie, who was rural affairs minister in the last government, is also being suggested as a contender. But, once again, the Lib Dems need to keep their numbers up - either to help them form a workable coalition government with the SNP or Labour, or in opposition. There have been alternative suggestions that Green leader Robin Harper could be lined up for the job. He is another senior figure who would be viewed as a genuine independent voice if he took on the chair.

However, such a move would halve his party's vote in Holyrood at a time when the two Green MSPs could have a great deal of influence in a series of important counts.

One suggestion that has been laughed off by Labour chiefs is that the defeated Jack McConnell might be interested in another big job if he cannot retain the title of First Minister. With Labour still hoping to form a government, the Presiding Officer's post will be filled before any resignation by the Scottish Labour leader.



The full article contains 586 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Gnasher,

06/05/2007 02:40:43

Whit aboot Margo? I think she would be fantastic and it would be a brilliant culmination to her parliamentary career.

MARGO #1!!!!

2

Peter Cherbi,

Edinburgh 06/05/2007 03:22:54

#1

Yes - Margo for Presiding Officer please ! She's the only independent left anyway and I'm sure this Parliament is going to need someone not to be swayed, as well as someone true to their word .. , which may well make her the first Presiding Officer to fit that description if she gets it !

3

Wisnaeme,

06/05/2007 03:54:43

I would be in favour of Margo as well but herself is desperately needed on the shop floor.As a nationalist it would probabely go against the grain for myself to recommend a unionist Tory for the position but I can see the the advantages of doing so.Until the next UK general election that is.Annabelle has a no nonsense integrity and for many unionists disatisfied by the election results and feart about "separation" this lady with her views on the matter, even if absent from the shop floor, could be perceived to be non partisan by most in the roll of presiding officer. it would calm "anti-separatist" nerves somewhat. The "unionist" part of her label will be sorted out by others soon enough.
.

4

conundrum,

06/05/2007 03:55:05

I doubt Margo would be interested. Being Presiding Officer limits MSPs' opportunities to make ill-informed and over-the-top criticisms of the government of the day. And where's the fun in that?

5

AlanSmart,

falkirk 06/05/2007 04:42:08

The Vote Scandal is a bigger issue than all of this . Please sign this e-petition and help get it to others
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/ScottishVoteScandal2007/

6

Oliver N Dunwith,

06/05/2007 06:39:42

David McLetchie to be PO; Margo MacDonald as a Deputy PO.

There is no legal requirement for the PO to be politically neutral and lose his or her vote, so any coalition deal may include attempt to change the Parliament's Standing Orders to amend its 'impartiality' provisions and thereby allow someone from the new Government to become PO. That would be a disaster for the Parliament, but .....

7

Rab McClair,

FREE (TO LIE TO) SCOTLAND ...?????? 06/05/2007 09:37:41

Whit aboot Wee Wendy..............(we've been tryin' tae find a joab she kin dae fur years !!)

8

Bill, Dunblane,

06/05/2007 09:58:07

Annabelle Goldie has to be the favourite.

I'm certainly no Tory, (perish the thought!) but she has proved during the election campaign to be much smarter, humerous and fair, than most other politicians. (SNP excepted of course!)

Margo would be fantastic, but her health problems would preclude her from the post. AND she doesn't suffer fools gladly!

Almost anyone from the labour party would be so seething with hatred that they could not perform the role.

9

lisa,

perth 06/05/2007 10:27:41

I nominate Kenny MacKaskill. The man could sneer for Scotland, and his attitude is very representative of a parliament that spends £20b of our money and treats us all with utter contempt.

10

Gaga,

Panama 06/05/2007 14:53:57

#9
Its MacAskill. And the man's a hero after getting rid of Labour journeymen/women plebs in Edin East/M'Burgh after many, many decades. You might also note that it was a Lab/Lid Dem coalition that has wasted billions of our cash these last 8 years, and Labour + friends (e.g. Kirsty Newsnight etc) were responsible for the parliament cost/location error. Do get out a little more!


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.