Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


T in the Park

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Premiere brings Stone of Destiny home to dying son of 'King John'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 October 2008
THERE will be no red carpet, no crowds and no camera flashlights for this most unusual and poignant movie opening night.
The audience for this exclusive screening of Stone Of Destiny will consist of just five people – including a Hollywood director and dying elder statesman – sitting in a suburban home in Scotland.

But the event is likely to generate more emotion and meaning for Sir Neil MacCormick and his special guests than a year's worth of gala openings.

MacCormick is housebound with inoperable cancer and this could be his only chance to see his late father, John, one of the founders of the Scottish National Party, portrayed on screen by Robert Carlyle.

The 67-year-old and his wife, Flora, will be joined at his home in Morningside, Edinburgh, by Charles Martin Smith, the director, who was given permission by the studio to print a one-off DVD for the screening.

Also in attendance will be Ian Hamilton and his wife, Jeannette. Hamilton was one of four Glasgow students who broke into Westminster Abbey and spirited away the Stone of Destiny. His book on the episode has been turned into the film, which opens across the country on Friday. MacCormick, a former Nationalist member of the European Parliament, will sit down the previous night and watch his father – a legendary orator nicknamed 'King John' – come back to life on TV.

Sitting in the lounge of his home, MacCormick told Scotland on Sunday: "It will be fascinating to see Robert Carlyle's portrayal. The particular roles with which Robert Carlyle has been most strongly associated in the popular mind are different in character yet, when you see him, even in the stills, he has something of the same presence and something of the same alertness of look.

"Of course I loved my father very much. But I will be looking at it in context. I won't be saying: 'Oh, here's a film about my dad and there's the Stone in it as well.' More the other way round – here's the film of this remarkable event, how will my father's part in it appear as portrayed by Robert Carlyle?

"I am interested in the whole story. I was quite tied up in it as a child at the time."

MacCormick was told he had inoperable cancer shortly after retiring from Edinburgh University this year.

"I'm very good mentally, very alert," he said. "One of the things that this particular cancer does is it weakens you. I just find it physically difficult to get to places."

He has a black eye and large plaster on his head after a fall last weekend, but remains sanguine about his condition and is looking forward to the film. "I think I'm going to enjoy it and I know I will be fascinated, whether I enjoy it or not."

Charles Martin Smith flew in from North America at the end of last week, with his DVD copy in his hand luggage. Smith, who is immediately familiar as the little, bespectacled character from such films as American Graffiti and The Untouchables, said: "I was terribly sorry to hear about his health problems."

Smith said the students who "retrieved" the legendary Scottish Coronation Stone from Westminster Abbey on Christmas Day 1950 "idolised" John MacCormick.

"It's really only because of him that this ever happened, so I am just delighted to be able to show it to his son," he said.

Smith explained why he had to get permission from the film company to make a DVD.

He said: "They are very careful about making discs, with all the piracy problems. They don't like to do it. But in this case, absolutely."

It is just as well Smith had the DVD in his hand luggage, as his hold baggage went missing at Heathrow.

MacCormick, who was professor of Public Law at Edinburgh University and received his knighthood for services to academe, said he vividly remembered the day the Stone was taken, though he was only nine.

"My father came through and said we had better listen to the wireless news and the top story was about the Stone of Destiny. Always on Christmas Day we had the big extended family round in our house, aunts, uncles and cousins and … there was great cheering."

Only years later did his mother tell him of her reaction to the news. In the privacy of the kitchen she told her husband: "I know that you are in it up to your neck. You have four children under the age of 12 and you are a lawyer in Glasgow.

"What are you going to do if you end up in jail over this? What's more, I know who got you involved in this. It's that Ian Hamilton." McCormick only learned that his father had been involved from the outset when he read his father's book The Flag In The Wind.

The full article contains 827 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 04 October 2008 10:36 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 05/10/2008 00:49:32
Best of luck.

It's not the real stone, though. The only recorded inventory of it comes from the thief - a certain Edward.
2

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 05/10/2008 00:53:27
Funny. I thought it was bigger than that :0(
3

Bzzzz,

Edinburgh 05/10/2008 02:55:08
Brilliant book! can't wait to see the film.
4

William of Liberton,

EDINBURGH 05/10/2008 03:21:45
The premature death of Neil McCormick will be a great loss to Scotland, as was the decline of his father's career as a lawyer (persecuted, in ever so many subtle ways, by the royalist/unionist establishment of the day). His father's forecast that Scotland would have its own parliament by the end of the last century has come true, and his son, looking just a little over the horizon now, knows that full independence cannot be far away. We owe a lot to the McCormick family, and it is good to see John McCormick commemorated, albeit in a small way, in this film.
5

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 05/10/2008 08:15:53
Can anyone throw light on the story that the Stone is of a type not available any where this side of Jerusalem?

(The theory is that Masonry and Templars have something to do with it).
6

Boy Wonder,

05/10/2008 09:48:10
#5. Look back at Hootsmon Archives ... all th theories are in there!
7

agatha,

05/10/2008 09:51:43
Sorry to hear this about Prof McCormick. I was taught by him in the 70s and he was not only a man of huge intellect but also humour and a great communicator.
I don't agree with his politics but agree with #4 that he will be a great loss to Scotland.I hope the prognosis is wrong and we have him for a long time to come.
8

Team Scotland,

05/10/2008 11:44:41
Several years ago I wrote to Scotland’s MP's and MSP's regarding social policy. Most of the responses were bland, non committal or simply toed the party line. Some, including Jim Murphy, did not reply at all. I only received two considered replies, one from Margo MacDonald and one from Neil McCormack. McCormack is one of Scotland’s most intelligent politicians and to hear he is so ill is sad news.
9

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 05/10/2008 11:47:45
Boy Wonder

We have all gone back to the Scotsman archives and thanks for reminding us that they are accessible to posters so that they can speak with some semblance of authority and sanity.

I look forward to viewing Robert Carlyle's depiction of MacCormick as he is one of Scotland's thespian treasures and in EVERY film or television series I have seen where he appears he is OUTSTANDING.

A real ornament to the film world of Scotland.
10

Herne the Hunter,

All of Scotland 05/10/2008 13:42:36
Please get it right it is the Stone of Scone not the Lia Faill or Jacobs pillow or the Stone of Destiny that the ancient Scottih Kings were crowned upon.
The stone of which the film and hysterical Scotland speaks is a piece of Perthshire sandstone which was taken to London and did well. It was a part of the Abbey of Scone,which was taken to Edinburgh castle by Edward the firsts soldiers,when Edward saw this stone he immediately ordered his men back to Scone which they then destroyed looking for the real Lia Fail or Stone of Destiny,they destroyed the ancient chartulary of Scotland,along with most of its ancient charters and papers and they tortured the monks but they still did not find it.
Edward then returned to London,leaving the Stone of Scone at Edinburgh castle and canceling the making of a bronze throne chair,made to hold the real Stone,and covering up the Scottish coronation descriptions by Walter de Hemingford and Adam de Rishanger who had been present at the John Balliol coronation where the real stone was used.
After his death (Longshanks) the wardrobe master at Edinburgh wrote to Edward the second asking him what he wanted done with the petra magna. Edward the second ordered it to London,hence after the Treaty of Northhampton when Bruce was asked if he wanted it back,he refused the offer,penny dropped yet.
Please lets try and get some truth and light on this situation. It is the Stone of Scone that was in Westminister, it the Stone of Scone that was returned to Edinburgh Castle...Not the Stone of Destiny they ar very different things... we have been fooled for more than 700 years by English actions... Lets choose the truth about the real Stone and perhaps we will be choosing our real destiny.... Quaere Verum
11

chugalong,

East coast 05/10/2008 15:59:49
So Herne the Hunter, do you have proof that the Ancient Scottish Kings were NOT coronated on a Perthshire sandstone cesspit lid?
12

Herne the Hunter,

All of Scotland 05/10/2008 16:37:05
Yes,Chugalong If you are that interested,look at the seals of David the first,Alexander the third and the Kelso charter cartouche they all show the Kings sitting on a round stone. Also check the description of Walter de Hemingford ... Concavus,Quidem ad Modem Rotundae Cathedrae Confectus .Check also the investigation done in the 19th century by eminent geologist Professor Teill.The Lord Lyon king at Arms and the Duke of York called it the Stone of Scone at the handover,it was wee Micky the Prat, that called it the Stone of Destiny. More than enough to prove that the piece of Perthshire that went to London and did well is the Stone of Scone, but not the Stone of Destiny....It was not a cesspit lid that the English Kings were crowned upon, it was the door to the floor chamber where the real stone was kept. Its past time for the truth to come to the fore and for Hysterical Scotland to start telling the truth....Quaere Verum
13

john z,

edinburgh 05/10/2008 17:21:55
Of course although the stone is now returned back to Scotland, by those ever gracious Engerlish types a few years ago, it is actually only ON LOAN from England.

Yip, that's right, the Engerlish decided to Lend the Stone of Destiny ( which belongs to Scotland) back to Scotland. Nice.

Time, it was taken back for the people of Scotland for good. Old Queenie Elizabeth the first should be forced to give it back as it is stolen property that belongs to Scotland.

The guys who stole it from Westminster originally should be knighted...but of course that will never happen under English colonial rule.

And they wonder why people in Scotland want independence...
14

,

05/10/2008 18:13:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

Brian Hill,

05/10/2008 23:02:35
Wendy Wood told me it wasn't the real Stone back in the 60s but my answer to that is real or not, it's the symbolism that matters, that's why the theft was so important, it pierced the idea of English invincibility.

I'm very much looking forward to the film though the fact that Neil MacCormick is ill will take the shine off it for me. An iconic moment in recent Scottish history, delighted it has made it to the big screen.
16

Herne the Hunter,

All of Scotland 06/10/2008 09:30:42
Above highlights the real problem that we have, people are not willing to seek the truth.
The Stone that was taken by Edward the firsts soldiers from Scone was not the Stone of Destiny,the Stone that was taken to London was the same stone,it became known as The Stone of Scone ,the Stone that was repatriated from London in the fifties was the Stone of Scone,the Stone that was returned to Edinburgh Castle and resides there is not the Stone of Destiny ,it is the Stone of Scone.
The Stone of Destiny,Jacobs Pillow, the Lia Faill was NEVER captured by the English.
It was spirited away by the monks before Edwards soldiers ever got to Scone and hidden. The Soldiers found a Stone sitting on the main altar in Scone because it was the door to the chamber where the real stone was kept,they assumed because it was sitting on the Altar that this was the correct Stone,it was a sandstone ashlar not a round polished piece of black basalt.... I am sorry about Neil MacCormick,but he would want the truth to be told. We in Scotland have been subject to too many lies over the centuries in order to control us,and if we cannot start telling or understanding what is the truth,then we can never claim our own Destiny.... Quaere Verum
17

BorderLineScottish,

06/10/2008 23:04:21
So, The Scotsman decided to remove my comment (#14)

and for what reason? There were no swear words, slander, cat-calling etc.!!!

All I did was point out that certain people will do anything to turn a sensible discussion into an anti-English, pro-SNP rant!

You do know who I mean, don't you, john z?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.