Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Lap dancing clubs among job centre advertisers

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 January 2009
WOMEN are being asked to prostitute themselves after applying for vacancies in job centres, the Government has admitted.
Job centres across the UK are routinely advertising for escort agencies, lap dancing clubs, massage parlours and TV sex channels, according to a new report released by the Department for Work and Pensions.

The Government has now revealed that applicants getting such jobs have complained after being asked to perform "sexual services" for clients.

Women's groups last night said the revelations were effective proof that job centres were providing a path into prostitution for out-of-work customers.

All job centres across the UK have been forced to advertise adult entertainment posts since 2003 after the High Court ruled that a previous ban was discriminatory.

But ministers are now considering whether to place new restrictions on the practice to ensure the Government is not inadvertently providing a "pimping" role in the huge prostitution industry.

An investigation by this newspaper of job centres in Scotland last week found several adverts for adult entertainment jobs. There was no suggestion that any of the positions involved prostitution and they fell within the criteria for advertising in job centres.

One centre in Edinburgh was offering job-seekers the opportunity to become a lap dancer at a city-centre location in the capital, guaranteeing an above minimum wage.

Also advertised was a 32-hour-a-week job as a pole dancer in Glasgow on a "self-employed basis".

The adult entertainment industry insists that it adopts strict working safeguards, which ensure that employees are not exploited. Employers also point out that workers in the industry willingly take on such jobs and are not coerced.

But there is now clear evidence that some applicants are being asked to perform "sexual services".

Two cases were uncovered in the past year, the DWP has said. In the first case, the job in question was subsequently withdrawn from the job centre list of vacancies. In the second, the employer was warned about the standards required and was then allowed to continue to advertise.

The DWP has also revealed that, since 2003, job centre staff have stopped four adult entertainment employers advertising in their premises following investigations into alleged improprieties.

A spokeswoman for the pressure group Object said: "This is the tip of the iceberg. The fact is that a lot of these jobs are often a front for prostitution. They should not be placed in job centres, it is as simple as that."

She added: "Since prostitution is essentially not legal in our society, due to the massive harm associated with it, why are we allowing the 'fronts' for them at all, and for these fronts to be so very normalised and so clearly promoting prostitution?"

Katherine Rake of the Fawcett Society, which has also campaigned against lap dancing clubs, said: "It is completely unacceptable that these jobs should be offered in job centres.

"The line between the adult entertainment industry and the sex industry is very blurred. The cases where there have been complaints suggest we are talking about sexual pimping by the state."

The DWP is now launching a new consultation exercise which will examine whether to tighten the rules on how such jobs are advertised in job centres.

In total, job centres advertised 351 vacancies in the adult entertainment industry last year. Among the positions offered were 44 vacancies for lap dancers, 30 vacancies for adult chat line operators, eight vacancies for masseuses and eight vacancies on a topless TV channel. A further 11 'other' jobs included "a semi nude butler, a nude cleaner and a kissogram".

Adult entertainment businesses were allowed to place vacancies in job centres following a legal challenge led by the high-street chain Ann Summers. The group successfully argued that in preventing the adult entertainment industry from advertising, Jobcentre Plus was failing to recognise that many people would want to apply for such jobs.

The rules now stipulate that for jobs that may involve physical contact – such as work as an escort or in a massage parlour – employers must guarantee that no contact is of a sexual nature. Job centre staff then follow up job-seekers who obtain such jobs to check they are not being coerced into providing sexual services.

However, ministers appear to want to take a tougher line following the explosion in the adult entertainment industry. The number of pole dancing and lap dancing clubs in Britain has doubled in the past three years.

UK ministers say they will soon act to tighten up licensing laws for lap dancing clubs.

A spokesman for the DWP said: "We've already tightened up the rules to crack down on unscrupulous employers, and we want to make absolutely sure that anyone who attempts to flout them and take advantage of people looking for work is dealt with.

"In the past year, around 0.015% of vacancies carried by Jobcentre Plus were in the adult entertainment industry. This consultation is all about looking at how we can tighten the rules further."

Apply within

Adult entertainment vacancies advertised by Jobcentre Plus between August 1, 2007, and July 31, 2008:

Party planner (adult products) 68 vacancies

Retail (adult products) 58

Lap dancing club bar staff, managers 54

Dancers, eg lap, pole, table, erotic 44

Adult chat line operators and supervisors 30

Models including lingerie and nude 28

Warehouse 20

Escorts 12

Masseuses 8

Topless TV channel staff 8

Webcam operators 7

Topless/semi-nude bar staff 3

Others including semi-nude butler, nude cleaner, kissogram 11




Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 January 2009 7:58 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Observer,,

Glasgow 04/01/2009 00:26:25
Semi nude butler ?
2

Jimmy Le Pie,

04/01/2009 00:31:15
Good to know there are jobs available to ex New Labour Sleaze MP's snd MSP's when they get booted out at the next election.

I can just picture Red Wendy and Big Jackie cavorting around a pole!!

With Lard Foolkes shoving fivers doon their breeks (House Of Lords expenses!)

Oh happy days to come!!
3

Observer,,

Glasgow 04/01/2009 00:46:59
I hate being prudish but I don't think it's fair to make people work as tarts for their dole. Maybe I am just old fashioned.
4

Observer,,

Glasgow 04/01/2009 00:47:56
2 You need a psychiatrist more than a lap dancer.
5

jabberjocky,

edinburgh 04/01/2009 00:54:47
possibly the most hypocritical article yet written here -
this newspaper has been advertising similar jobs and services for decades now, without a hint of shame.
6

Newton_Invented_Gravity,

04/01/2009 01:50:48
'web cam operator' had to laugh at that one!
7

Roy,

04/01/2009 04:30:58
Warehouse?

Whorehouse maybe?
8

drunken proffet,

Tassy 04/01/2009 05:11:59
Lap dancer seems to be a bit near the bone, but party planner, retail sex products, chat line operators seem to be a bit mundane. I am sure a lot of folk would fit right into those jobs and as long as they are not smutty (to your average pensioner), why not?
9

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 04/01/2009 05:32:51
It may seem a bit funny now, but when they bring in these new rules to force single mothers of benefit they may find they are given a choice between accepting a "Job" they are qualified to perform and having their benefit cut.

That along with the devaluation of the pound is part of Gordon's cunning plan to get the UK to the top of the list for Sex Tourism. Think of all that lovely Arab oil money rolling in.
10

ymatt,

west brom 04/01/2009 07:04:13
its disgusting. theyve had this from france,wondered when they was getting around to it.turning our women into prostitutes, dont be surprised if they say to you you dont get your dole money if you refuse, as ayoung women from france said, its legal in france, now its here in the uk
11

,

04/01/2009 07:48:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

W Smith,

Middle East 04/01/2009 07:59:05
This carry on didn't start with 'New Labour' now did it?

The Edinburgh Labour Party, as I recall, were promoting massage parlours in the city long before Tony Blair became leader of the British Labour Party.

Funny how a newspaper based in Edinburgh would have missed that.
13

Christopher Crossley,

Wuhan City 04/01/2009 08:01:58
Perhaps there ought to be an associated investigative article dealing with why there is this surge in demand for people to work in the adult entertainment industry.

In a nutshell, the demand has undoubtedly soared because a lot of men, whether married or not, require a badly-needed diversion from everything in life that makes them miserable, such as plunging stocks, failing and failed relationships and marriages, and a general malaise that is prevalent in the world at the minute that has plunged the people into a great deal of emotional turmoil.

Perhaps if it was not for all of these things happening to the everyday bod who is put under pressure from both home and work, this surge in demand would not have existed! Somehow, a walk in the park at twilight with one's other half isn't so appealing any more. One emotional outburst from that other half is enough to plunge even the sanest and strongest of men into gloom and despondency in an instant.

Can you wonder why the adult entertainment industry in this country is growing, then?
14

St Andrew 01,

04/01/2009 08:06:33
A job is a job -
And here is the thing, if you can become a lap dancer you can become a waitress, a cleaner, a shop assistant, a check out lady, anything.
So lets drop the facade, the takers will take because the givers keep giving, so STOP giving.
Let them dance on poles, let them wriggle on a mans lap for their money.
OR, scrap the free hand outs and get them washing graffitt from bus stops, get them sweeping streets, get them painting park benches, get them picking up litter, get them washing police cars and fire engines, get them working FOR THE GIVERS - Then you may see a change in the Scottish social psyche
15

Joe Macdelta.,

04/01/2009 08:49:52
If there is a market, then it follows that there will be recruitment, just like any industry, it isn't compulsory to apply.
16

,

04/01/2009 08:49:59
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Iain's,

04/01/2009 09:05:04
You should add begging for charity to the list.

One job offerred is joining those people who ask one to sign up to donate to charity.
18

Pocket Dictionary,

04/01/2009 09:19:45
I'm assuming the owners of massage parlours pay income tax. So why isn't the government charged with profiting from immoral earnings?
19

Scimitar1,

04/01/2009 09:26:38

The end users of these services will be wondering why pay for it when they can have a 'free' prostitute (abeit drunken) in any town or city any night of the week in Scotland.
20

LAM,

Edinburgh 04/01/2009 09:53:17
#17..think you are mixing two issues.. the point is that the Job Centres are in essence doing much of the recruiting for these places and so if something imoral is happening there (which in many cases is likely) then they... as in our Government is taking a hand in pimping.. which doesn't in anyway seem right. But if we are legalising these places and what they do there then we need to take another look at the situation. Do these places serve a function... possibly.. keeping more prostitutes off the actual streets.. do they pay taxes and licence fees again if so someone sanctioned this..hmm lets see would that be government.. So if we turned around and said they couldnt advertise in Job Centres.. we would be saying they are doing something wrong..if they are..(again we know the answer to this)A crack down needs to happen to make them tow the line..we are now stopping Johns from curb crawling..stop them from club crawling...they are still Johns..... As for women taking these roles instead of dole... if the women are physically/ mentally able to take on these positions willingly they can make a lot more money than being on the dole.. again the word in WILLINGLY. As for the collecting of dole as the god given right as many believe here..your right make them earn it..there are many functions that could be performed that would make them either continue or pull up their boot straps and go to work.
21

Douglas,

Bathgate 04/01/2009 10:15:19
I'll never see the headline "Jobs Blow" in the same light again.
22

Eric Muldownie,

London 04/01/2009 10:17:06
If theses venues are legal then they should be properly regulated and if they are properly regulated and no one is being forced to work there then I don't have a problem.
However ,there is a well established connection between lap-dancing clubs and prostitution and a connection between prostitution and drug use and this is a real worry.
23

Eustace,

/ 04/01/2009 10:22:16


There is a distinct difference (or there should be) between private advertising which could be approached with caution and a Government Agency which implies (to a cross section of candidates) that it is recommending a particular sort of work/situation or training and any related activities which may flow therefrom.



24

Pilrig.,

Livingston 04/01/2009 10:55:37
15 - a lot long before that. There was Nora's place in Danube St, then there was the Deep Sea at the top of the Walk.
25

Garry Otton,

Scottishmediamonitor.com 04/01/2009 11:33:27
Eddie Barnes is a former editor of a Catholic newspaper and has a track record of negative reporting of sexual issues. Overflowing with quotes from organisations who make it their business to promote sex-negative messages hardly makes for balanced reporting. What about the men or women who enjoy such jobs? How about quoting them? No one is forcing you to do a job you can't do. Get over it.
26

Stan Butler,

04/01/2009 12:03:35

#28 How very tolerant of you.

Are you a gay?

27

,

04/01/2009 12:17:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
28

nick prince,

warrington 04/01/2009 12:42:10
to those of you that say make them work for it, why should anyone be co-erced into removing chewing gum, preferably by licking, chewing gum of pavements for something beneath the level of a living wage, seems like you folk want to humiliate people? Should they wear brightly coloured rubberised garments? Sounds like you people are frequenters of just those establishments that the alleged dole scum are now being asked to work in? How many hours a week would you people force those less fortunate to work for their miserable pennies? Would you recognise the minimum wage?
29

nick prince,

warrington 04/01/2009 12:45:11
would you also ask them to develop a taste for nuclear waste and get them to deal with the radioctive waste problem, sorry about putting chewing gum in twice above...
30

kpm,

unsworth 04/01/2009 13:02:05
are the jobs restricted to young women ? mind you I suppose a 17 stone hairy string vest wearing male would not have similar appeal.
31

Toast,

04/01/2009 13:18:55
In the current economic climate any job is better than no job,politicians of course would not understand this living in their cotton wool wrapped world with a huge salary and limitless expenses,what the h*ll do they know about reality or poverty.
32

Garry Otton,

scottishmediamonitor.com 04/01/2009 13:49:48
#29 Stan. How intolerant; you str8?
33

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 04/01/2009 14:05:58
Warehouse? Shome mispelling one suspects. However #9 got in there first.

Anyone applying for a job in he "adult entertainment" industry should not be too surprised at being asked to perform extra duties? Or does this have to spelled out for them?!
34

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 04/01/2009 14:08:14
#33 kpm

You are assuming that the sex industry only caters to heterosexuals, some gay men apparently go for the "hairy bear" type.

JobCenter Conversation:

Worker: Jimmy, you have been on job seekers allowance for over a year now. We really must get you into some kind of employment. I says hear that you never finished school and the jobs that you have had so far have been all unskilled manual labour. What sort of position do you think would be good for you?

Jimmy: Well I have always wanted to work in the movie business.

Worker: Well Jimmy, today may be your lucky day. I have a job here with a film company that has an entry level position available. Tell me Jimmy, do you have any physical problems, bad back or bad knees.

Jimmy: No Sir, I am in top physical condition.

Worker: Ok Jimmy. The jobs title is Fluffer with a company called Pink Triangle Films. They want you to come to an interview this afternoon. If you fail to turn up for the interview or refuse to take up the position I am afraid we will have to stop your benefits. Cheery Oh Jimmy.
35

Tris,

04/01/2009 14:12:22
And with all the equal ops, I can see men being made to do it too..... New Labour, new future (not a very bright one, but new none the less).
36

,

04/01/2009 14:43:37
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
37

Mcsnagpile,

04/01/2009 14:49:44
Wanted: Pole Dancer, Edinburgh Fire Brigade; must be willing to pole dance in various states of dress including welly boots and fireman’s helmet. No discrimination will be made to the sex of the canditate.
38

Thistledhu,

04/01/2009 14:59:02
you would have to be pretty niave to apply for a job as a Escort or masues and then be shocked if asked dureing the job interveiw would u be prepared to have sex with clients
39

Eve,

Scotland 04/01/2009 15:23:24
I'm guessing that most of party planner jobs on offer there are for the likes of Anne Summer, so this job possibly isn't to bad.

Though it's not everyone who can work in these areas, even with the exclusion of prostatutin (which is ilegeal but does happen in some jobs).

Thing that alrems me is that the Job Centre Plus are well know to force theos claiming job seekers allowence to aply for at least 3 jobs a week, something that is not alway posible. They also expect these people take any job they can do. Correct me if I'm wroung but is prostatution not something that anyone could phyicaly do.

I've said something like this before, but it's worth while to say it again, while talking about the job centre;

The job centre should become more intelgentent and help match jobs to people strenghts. Instead of this any job will do, cause some jobs will have negative effect on some people mental health or cause anlariming amout of stress. Some people get strested easyer than other and can't take un due presure in the work place and end up being to ill to work.
40

Eve,

Scotland 04/01/2009 15:37:22
#40 Thistledhu: Some how, I don't think they ask it at the interview.

From what I've seen on the telly be it, don't know how acurate this is but it does explain, may be why so many get mixed up in this sort of thing.

That they all of a sudden come across a cleint that asks for some extra services and the empolyer is on the clients side. So they feel presuresed to do something they won't normaly do.

Though some jobs do sound a wee bit dogge.

41

TREV,

Poland 04/01/2009 18:17:42
Surely with all the Poles in Scotland they actually mean "POLISH-Dancers"
42

St Andrew 01,

04/01/2009 18:20:42
There is nothing immoral about strip clubs and brothels, there are only varying opinions and perceptions regarding strip clubs and brothels..
Let them work as strippers and call girls, at least they will be earning money as opposed to taking it.
And besides, if you can become a dancer or a call girl you can become a waitress or a cleaner.

43

Eustace,

/ 04/01/2009 19:25:08


Many of these comments suggest that the advertising of these jobs is ruining the reputation of Job Centres and anyone who applies for work there.
44

Eustace,

/ 04/01/2009 19:27:53



There also appears to be a particular bias against women.
45

Navvy,

04/01/2009 19:38:07
if the work is legal then so is the job centre's advertising

I would be happy to see the end of such clubs, happy hours, scruffy pubs, chewing gum, fast food and its associated litter, swearing in public an dmuch more

but

clearly

a lot os Scots love all these

How?
46

fair scunnered,

edinburgh 04/01/2009 19:54:01
#2 thank you for putting me off my food,the thought of the great pie eater and wee bendy cavorting round a pole YUK
what did the pole do to them,bet he runs back to poland
and georgie porgy lord haw haw foulkes,stuffing fivers down their breeks?,nae chance it will be iou,s and his expense claims for entertainment for doing that
47

,

04/01/2009 20:33:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
48

L. Dawson,

Edinburgh 04/01/2009 21:24:14
Why are forms of prostitution even allowed on the system in the first place?
Does the job center endorces prostitution?

And yes lap dancing IS prostitution.
- there is no difference between a prostitute charging someone to look at their p*ssy and a 'dancer' charging someone for the same thing.
49

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

04/01/2009 21:42:51
26) Dora's was a reputable social club for the lonely and inadequate, and the Deep Sea, which still exists at a slightly different address, was and still is a chipper.
Care to argue?
50

Shamus,

Glasgow 04/01/2009 23:43:47
Hamas to introduce night clubs. You can sheg the wummin but do not look at them.
51

Kornelius,

Aberdeen 05/01/2009 08:19:09
Supply and demand perhaps?
Can a man apply?
52

Hickory,

US 06/01/2009 20:04:56
Aye Jimmy, Ye can be sure, if Red Wendy swung on a pole, she would 'ave been doin' tha payin'.
53

Al's maw,

08/01/2009 12:29:21
hey Observer, you are being old-fashioned and prudish and a bit of a d**k also. is it that you are complaining about people being exploited, cause we all know you love to fly the flag for the underdog, if that's the case mate do you think you should be refering to people as tarts....what a t**t you are, just cause no-one would pay you for it!
54

shell b,

Edinburgh 08/01/2009 13:58:09
well what can i say i dont know why its such a big thing its a job you dont have to do it if you dont want to.

my freind is a lapdancer and she enjoys her work she dose not do any extras and she chooses is she wants to go topless or not but as you can imagen there is more money if you are topless so thats sucks a bit i guess but then its still her decision to work in that enviroment.

The way i see it is they are provideing a service in a club out off sight not on the street corners like some do so the more that are off the street doing this kind of work then all the better.

if advertsing these jobs are such a big thing then really they should not promote anything in the sex line and come on everyone knows that sex sells and always will.

its time to move with the times which means being more open minded.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.