Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Catholic Church suspends gay priest whose cover was blown by office decor

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 October 2007
THE Catholic Church has suspended an Italian monsignor after identifying him as a priest who anonymously admitted being gay during a TV documentary.
The decision clearly illustrates the Vatican's stance that homosexuality is a sin.

Pope Benedict XVI has spoken out repeatedly about the issue, and even before becoming Pontiff he was known as someone who campaigned against homosexuality within t
he church.

The monsignor has not been identified by officials at the Vatican, but they have confirmed that he is currently suspended from his job.

The Rev Federico Lombardi, a spokesman for the Holy See - the church's government - said: "The case is being handled with utmost reserve.

"Higher-ups are evaluating the situation with the necessary reserve and with the obligatory respect for the person involved, even if this person has erred."

He continued that the Vatican had "to intervene decisively and with the severity required by conduct not compatible with priestly service and with the mission to the Holy See."

The priest at the centre of the row was a top official in the Vatican's Congregation for Clergy, which is an office set up to ensure proper conduct by priests.

He had given an interview to a private Italian TV network earlier this month for a programme that included talks with several priests about their homosexuality.

Both his face and voice were disguised by the show's producers, but watching Vatican officials recognised the room where the interview took place as the monsignor's office.

During questioning, the priest said that he "did not feel it was wrong" to have sex with gay men.

Within months of Pope Benedict becoming Pontiff in May 2005, the issue of homosexuality within the Catholic Church and how to tackle it had become one of the main issues for the Vatican.

He issued guidelines that attempted to ensure that gays could not begin training for the priesthood, even sending inspectors to tour seminaries in the United States.

The Pope is fiercely against same-sex relationships, having spent the 25 years before he came to head the church as its enforcer of orthodoxy.

During this time he created a number of official statements concerning the Vatican's stance on the issue.

Writing in 1986 for the National Catholic Reporter newspaper, the then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger said: "Although the particular inclination of the homosexual person is not a sin, it is a more or less strong tendency ordered to an intrinsic moral evil, and thus the inclination itself must be seen as an objective disorder.

"Above all, we must have great respect for these people who also suffer and who want to find their own way of correct living.

"On the other hand, to create a legal form of a kind of homosexual marriage, in reality, does not help these people."

Pope Benedict has also fiercely criticised allowing homosexuals to adopt children. He said: "Allowing children to be adopted by persons living in such unions would actually mean doing violence to these children."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 October 2007 7:24 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Roman Catholic church
 
1

'Suck' - McCrunchie,

the eighth 14/10/2007 01:12:54

How does the catholic church separate the men from the boys?

They suspend the priests who sleep with men, but hide in an other country the ones who sleep with boys!!!

2

The Daleks,

14/10/2007 02:01:32

#2 DH

The mad mullahs and their flock are just as hypocritical.

I've just spent some time in the Middle East, and boy do those characters drink and fornicate like there was no tomorrow!!

Pattaya in Thailand is a favourite hang out for the Gulf Brigade, and the planes between Dubai, and Muscat etc, are full of large groups of supposedly Muslim men heading to SE Asia for cheap alcohol and easy sex.

3

iRoy,

14/10/2007 03:43:25

You know this new pope is so far in the closet, he's in ruddy Narnia.

4

Neil, Texas,

Texas 14/10/2007 05:09:45

You couldn't make this up.

The Catholic Church prevaricates and does nothing when its priests rape children and yet condems sex between consenting adults.

This is one sick and twisted organization.

5

Mikey,

14/10/2007 06:34:09

Hold on. The CTS will be on shortly telling you that you're all sectarian!

Time to find out some juicys about the CofS!

6

Conan the Librarian,

14/10/2007 08:17:29

1
Thought it was "with a crowbar".

7

I'm no really here,

14/10/2007 09:29:16

#1 Well pointed out.

8

Media 1,

cape town 14/10/2007 09:48:00

The Vicars of Christ, these popes who deem themselves infallible demi gods are a disgrace to humanity.

Their history is littered with murder, rape and incest, their hatred knows no bounds, they are discriminatory racists hell bent on spreading their filth across the planet and its time that people stood up against them.

Its not so much that they see homosexuality as a sin that bothers me, its the fact that they are responsible for countless murders and wars, mass killings and rape, yet they see homosexuality as a crime against this god they spout to the masses.

The RC is without doubt, the woman who rides the beast

9

weemac,

Scotland 14/10/2007 12:23:12

How sad to see so many who are keen to look for every chance to attack the Catholic Church. The Church is simply trying to uphold its moral teaching on homosexuality.

10

I'm no really here,

14/10/2007 12:41:36

#11 Let it uphold it's moral teaching on homosexuality by suspending all those that have had sex with little boys (or little girls) too.

You cannot take a moral stand in one case, and turn a blind eye in another, and expect people not to be critical.

11

A Catholic,

USA 14/10/2007 14:21:15

"Let he who is without sin, cast the first stone."

"Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I build my church and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it." (although they'll try.)

12

Richard Hawkins,

Dublin 14/10/2007 14:23:51

First of all, the article is incorrect by stating that the Catholic Church sees homosexuality as a sin. The Catholic church sees homosexual ACTS as a sin, not homosexuality itself. That means that it wouldn't matter what sexual orientation a person is, committing homosexual acts would be a sin regardless (e.g. two heterosexual women making out). If anyone read at least one article from an official Catholic source about its stance on homosexuality, they would realize that the statement is wrong.

#2 The Catholic Church neither condones nor approves of any pedophilic acts done by priests. Just because there has been a sudden rush of allegations flooding the news media of priests molesting children, it doesn't mean ALL priests are like this, and it doesn't mean that ALL Catholics condone it. The reason why these things have been allowed to happen is because of those individual rotten apples. Blame them and don't "burn the whole church at the stake" like others have accused the church of doing to other people.

#5, who said the Catholic church has done nothing? what about those different times when the Vatican has defrocked certain priests for being pedophiles? It's in the news, why don't you go look it up and stop searching only for articles that cater to your biased opinions. And again, not all Catholics condone such acts. Stop generalizing all of us, nimrod.

#10, the pope is not infallible 100% of the time, only when he announces a new doctrine. This means that if the pope chooses to give his opinion about something, it doesn't mean he's protected from error. Only when it pertains to the Magisterium (teachings of the church). In other words, HE IS STILL PRONE TO MAKING MISTAKES. Also, since when has any institution's history been perfect? Protestant history is not perfect, nor is the history of the Jews and the Muslims. War and murder have never been OFFICIALLY condoned by the church (as in the whole Catholic church has

13

Granny,

14/10/2007 15:11:33

THANK YOU..Richard Hawkins... you have clearly stated the position of the Catholic Church and all of us who try to live out the teachings of the Catholic Church are grateful for your explanations.

14

jim b,

stirling 14/10/2007 15:26:33

#14 Several points well made but no church is above the law,and there are cases in scotland where the church did not report pedophile priests to the police that is clearly wrong.

15

Southern Cross,

15/10/2007 08:21:05

The key issue for the Catholic Church is not to get caught and bring scandal upon the church. Violate this rule and you're thrown out immediately. Get found out internally and you're just moved on somewhere else. The church puts its reputation above all else.

16

WL,

livingston 02/01/2008 20:30:48
But why does the Roman Catholic church have a problem with married priests; the only married priests in the R.C. church are Anglican priests who converted to the R.C. church. Not very consequent!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.