Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


True extent of unreported rapes revealed

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
26 November 2006
AS FEW as 6% of women who seek counselling for rape will report their ordeal to the police, according to a study by Scotland's leading support group for sex assault victims.
Rape Crisis Scotland asked women if they had also made a formal complaint to police and discovered that in East Ayrshire, only 28 out of 464 clients had done so.

Figures from elsewhere in Scotland were also shockingly low, running at 15% in Dunde
e, 16% in Lanarkshire, 21% in Argyll and Bute and a quarter in Central Scotland.

The "best" result was in Glasgow, but even there only 40% of Rape Crisis clients contacted the police for help.

Last night, the Scottish Police Federation admitted it was disturbed by the findings and called for an urgent inquiry.

But Rape Crisis claims the police themselves are a key part of the problem, and says it has compelling anecdotal evidence that old-fashioned and insensitive attitudes to rape victims persist.

Concern has been growing about the poor conviction rate at rape trials and the ordeal victims are often put through in court. But the Rape Crisis study reveals for the first time just how few rape victims contact police in the first place.

The figures from the six Rape Crisis centres which took part in the study show that last year a total of 2,783 women sought counselling but only 857 - 31% - said they had reported the attack to police.

Rape Crisis also collected evidence of inappropriate questions asked by police of rape victims, including "Are you sure you didn't lead him on?", "You were out drinking - could you not put it down as a learning experience?", and "Why could you not fight them [two rapists] off? You're a big girl."

Frances O'Boyle, a Rape Crisis counsellor in Grampian, said: "Most of the women who come to us don't even go near the police. There used to be a specialist unit in Grampian that dealt with rapes but that only deals with child abuse now so women are being dealt with by CID officers and they get whoever happens to be around and we have had quite bad reports of how individuals deal with it."

A spokeswoman for Rape Crisis in Glasgow said: "The main issue is about women feeling they are not believed and not taken seriously by the police. We are getting anecdotal evidence of poor responses and unsympathetic and unhelpful comments being made."

She added: "We know that there are pockets of good practice. Some women say they have had a superb service from the police, but it is a lottery."

Sandy Brindley, national coordinator for Rape Crisis Scotland, said: "Rape is particularly under-reported as a crime. Many women are worried about being disbelieved and being blamed and about what will happen in court.

"There have been huge improvements in the past 15 years, however some women do still tell us they have encountered disbelieving attitudes. Officers should be specially trained if they are to be the first point of contact for a woman reporting rape or sexual assault."

Police were forced to overhaul the way they deal with victims of sex crimes after a shocking 1982 fly-on-the-wall documentary caught three Thames Valley Police officers bullying an alleged victim of gang rape. The footage led to the creation of the first female rape squad and prompted the introduction of rape suites in police stations.

Yesterday police said they would investigate the matter. Joe Grant, general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation, said: "This is a very worrying trend which needs urgent examination. I think the causes of this are underlying and this subject may be worthy of an evidence-based research project. This is now within the capability of the police with the introduction last week of the Scottish Policing Research Network."

Paddy Tomkins, chief constable of Lothian and Borders Police, insisted the service was "committed to ensuring victims of rape and other serious sexual offences receive the highest levels of support and understanding from our officers - both male and female".

He added: "A rape and sexual offences working group has now been set up and is examining the full range of police procedures and response in relation to these offences."

SNP justice spokesman Kenny MacAskill said: "We have come a long way and there have been significant improvements by the police.

"However these statistics show just how long a journey we still face."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 November 2006 7:17 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Rape and the legal system
 
1

Calum Mcleod,

26/11/2006 10:16:41

Dreadful crime and right that the fullest support possible should be given to the victim. And of the High Court is the only court which can hear rape trials. But one statistic rarely quoted is that, apparently, in over 85% of cases the culprit is known to the victim - ex-boyfriend, relative etc. Would that not be a significant factor in non-reporting but no mention.... ? It doesn't make any crime less vile but it does partially explain reluctance to report to the police.

2

Anthony,

Glasgow 26/11/2006 12:53:28

I take your point Gordon (2). I've no doubt there is truth behind these figures and this problem has to be addressed. But we always have to be cautious of publicly funded bodies 'revealing' these sorts of statistics, when they stand to benefit financially from doing so. Cynical? Maybe. But I'm not saying we should dismiss these findings, simply that we have to keep this in mind when considering them.

3

Rob me blind,

26/11/2006 13:03:49

While there is no excuse for anyone to carry out a rape on another person I can understand the reluctance of anyone to report any sexual crime. For all there pontificating neither the police or the PF service show any real empathy with those who report these crimes.

4

Neil,

9% Growth Party 26/11/2006 13:04:30

"Are you sure you did not lead him on" is an entirely proper question, indeed an investigation which does not consider that possibility in a date rape ought to be thrown out.

Waking up with a hangover & a memory having sex is not proof of rape. It is quite possible that the man may also have a hangover & a memory of a somewhat predatory female.

5

Cynic,

Dalkeith 26/11/2006 14:02:12

In reality, rape is a very difficult crime to prove unless the victim carries marks of violence to corroborate her statement. Much of the time there is little evidence of this unless it is a sadistic attack. And very few rapes are actually committed in front of ordinary bystanders. Awkward questions, which may appear insensitive, and which form part of the witnesses statement, have to be asked by the police to test the veracity of the victim and thereby avoid malicious complaints. Oh, yes, they are made. Such questions will invariably be put to the victim under examination in court. One can be forgiven for thinking that the Rape Crisis has not been disengenuous in it's comments.

6

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 26/11/2006 22:26:21

1....cultural issues....prostitution as an occupation (occupational hazard)...previous experience in the courts of reporting rape and not wishing to repeat them...well liked colleague at work...attack by person in position of authority or held in religious respect...police officer....minister...Teacher.....knowing that you would be held accountable for your clothing and behaviour..ie miniskirt at the disco which we all know is 'leading someone on'. What is your definition of that as a man?....I am curious...I think we may find that these definitions vary from individual to individual. I hope so...I have heard an adult male say of a teenager in a mini skirt "Its no wonder they get raped eh?" Regarding being 'led on'..is this then the green light that turns to red when a man realises that a woman has said no or decided not to have sex after all? Obviously by this stage it is too late as men are incapable of controlling themselves once they get to a certain stage of sexual arousal.....indeed we only have to look at dogs humping lamp posts in the street to understand the poor creatures frustrations.....men that is.

7

Caitlin Thenew,

Traprain 27/11/2006 12:08:18

I'm continually bemused by the need of some to vilify the victim. The sentiment seems to be that women must at all times behave in a seemly manner so that they don't invite an attack. And who, by the way, defines seemly?

Not only are women not afforded the protections due to them as human beings, their rights are proscribed. We are not to drink (it means we asked for it); we are not to wear what we please (again, inviting attack); we are not be in public alone (must mean she wants it); and heaven forsake any female who ever flirts.

Where is the concern about the number of men getting away with rape?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.