Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Brown under fire for 'lack of leadership'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 27 April 2008
GORDON Brown was under renewed pressure last night after one of Tony Blair's closest allies launched a stinging attack on his leadership of the Labour party.
Lord Levy, Blair's chief fundraiser, said that the party under Brown lacked "strong leadership" and he was saddened about what had happened since he had taken over.

The criticism came as Brown was accused of dithering over the Grangemouth fuel cri
sis and of dismissing it as a regional problem.

In an interview with a Sunday newspaper, Lord Levy, the part fund-riaser at the centre of the "cash for honours" probe, hit out at Blair's successor.

He said: "I am saddened to see what's happened to the party now, I am saddened to see all of the bickering and I am saddened to see that somehow there does not appear to be that strong leadership that the Labour Party so desperately needs."

Brown attempted to regain the political initiative by writing that he was always "ready to listen" as he sought to limit the damage to Labour from last week's 10p tax row.

Amid predictions of a backlash at the polls in Thursday's local elections, the Prime Minister insisted in an article for the Labour-supporting Sunday Mirror that it was Tory and Liberal Democrat councils that were letting down "hard-working families".

Brown said: "Whatever the differences and debates of the past week, I know every member of the Labour Party will be working flat out over the next few days. Labour is always ready to listen to people's concerns, and take action on them."

After last week's U-turn on scrapping the 10p tax rate – the Government made concessions to head off a backbench revolt – critics said Brown had neglected to deal with the potentially devastating consequences of the Grangemouth strike which could cost the UK economy £50m a day, half of which would be paid for by the taxpayer.

The Prime Minister was spending the weekend in his country retreat, Chequers. On Friday he urged union leaders and the refinery owners to reach a deal but yesterday his spokesman said he had no plans to make any further statements on Grangemouth. Brown did, however, make a statement on Zimbabwe, but it was left to Business Secretary John Hutton to reassure the public that Grangemouth was under control.

"There is plenty of petrol and diesel in Scotland to meet demand during this period of time. But of course there is going to be a challenge if people change the way that they consume fuel," Hutton said.

Hutton said a national emergency plan drawn up after the 2000 fuel protests would only be triggered by a shortage of supplies, which would not be the case for "a significant period of time".

The opposition parties said the Government had been slow to react. Shadow business secretary Alan Duncan said: "The Government has dithered, which is characteristic of them. I don't think they thought it was anything than more just a regional problem."

Duncan also blamed Brown for increasing industrial action after he scrapped the dividend tax credit when he was Chancellor, costing pension schemes an estimated £5bn a year.

He said: "Gordon Brown's destruction of employee pensions has put strikes back on the agenda for Britain. This is one of his particularly ugly chickens coming home to roost."

The fuel dispute is one of a raft of challenges that Brown is facing in one of the toughest weeks of his premiership.

On Thursday, local elections are being held in England and Wales as well as the London Mayoral elections – Brown's first electoral test since he became Prime Minister. The best Brown can hope for is a narrow Ken Livingstone victory in the knife-edge London Mayoral contest and an improvement on the dismal 26% share of the vote Labour recorded in England and Wales the last time the same set of seats were up for election in 2004.

In Parliament, Brown faces the biggest defeat of his premiership over plans to extend the time terror suspects can be detained from 28 to 42 days, unless he promises opponents a substantial compromise package.

The Counter Terrorism Bill is going through detailed debate in the Commons this week but key votes are not expected until late May or early June.

There will be further embarrassment for Brown tomorrow when the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs is expected to say that cannabis should retain its class C status. After the May 1 elections, he is expected to press ahead with plans to reclassify it as a class B drug.

Downing Street said it did "not recognise" a report that Brown's anger at recent setbacks led to him kicking over a table and smashing three mobile phones. But one Cabinet minister reported last week that the Prime Minister was becoming increasingly "mental" and appeared to be cracking under the strain. The minister complained that Brown was phoning him and other colleagues at all hours, making it difficult for them to get on with their jobs.






Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 April 2008 12:22 AM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Angus Ogg,

26/04/2008 22:15:30
One of Gordon Brown's image consultants said he had to smile more. Unfortunately, Gordon Brown uses a smile like a some form of Tourettes.

He cracks a grimace here and there like punctuation, but at the most inappropriate points of when he is speaking. This leads to the clear impression that the man is seriously insincere.

As for one Cabinet Minister reportedly saying Gordon Brown he is going "mental". Well this is indeed worrying for all of us, and if he is borderline unhinged this week, goodness knows what the May election losses will do to him. Especially when combined with economic meltdown caused by 1970's style strikes and Brown's dithering driven, forthcoming attraction.... the Summer of Discontent
2

Jimmy the Pie,

27/04/2008 00:30:16
Not long to go now Comrade Broon.

Then it'll be your time for publishing your memoirs, signing lucrative directorship contracts with your city pals and waltzing about the world telling people how they should live.

Red Wendy will not be far behind you.

Not a moment too soon
3

clochoderic,

renfrewshire 27/04/2008 00:45:38
I can already see the political obituaries a few years hence - references to Shakespearean or Greek tragedy, a good man compromised by a fatal flaw, integrity sold for gain towards an increasingly ill-defined great moral purpose etc.
We are witnessing a cruel drama where Brown has no option but to soldier on until events eventually do for him.
In the meantime watch his "team" closely ...
4

McX,

27/04/2008 00:52:07
It's getting cruel now, someone should put the poor barsteward out of his misery.
5

frank mcbride,

lusitania 27/04/2008 01:41:14
Call me cynical, or call me cynical, but this dispute is a ploy to enable the rerouting of NS Oil, and all future fields to "safe" areas.

Why is the company intent on changing pension agreements when oil is at an all time high?

Why is this problem Scotland specific?

Are the current owners related to Haliburton?
6

Willie Macleod,

Wick 27/04/2008 02:17:41
#6 Jade the Obscure You can get most of the articles at scotsman.com before the paper comes online,but Angus Ogg can get on before that I tried the RSS feeds to no avail I dont know how he does it, but we will find out its probably something quite simple at least thats what he hints at.
7

Damy Ruby,

Edinburgh 27/04/2008 06:31:15
So he is going mad, sounds like Hitler in bunker in the film Downfall and unfortunately that's not where the similarity ends either!
8

HKLad,

27/04/2008 07:36:22
"11 years of Labour government have proved a boon for the super-rich, rarely seen before in modern British history." - BBC
9

Vaughan,

lafleur7@telus.net 27/04/2008 07:49:50
One one hand, Brown is a babe in arms politally with a smile as beaming as Dick Chany's, on the other hand, I would deal with people saying there is infighting (yes, you are helping the infighting) in a Flash!!!
10

Vaughan,

New Wstminster, Canada 27/04/2008 07:56:54
Who is this "Vaughan" person, and why can't he spell. Love the way he nailed "The Big Brown Complain" and "Lord StabintheBack", though.
My main worry, after Brown is gone, without anyone else to run the ship, is the return of a 'Maggie' type matron.
11

Auld Twa,

Edinburgh 27/04/2008 08:08:17
Brown is more concerned about events in Zimbabwe than Grangemouth.
12

Damy Ruby,

Edinburgh 27/04/2008 08:10:35
Blair split the country up and now Brown is making seem like a good idea! I would never have thought to vote SNP before these pair got into power and did so much damage. However, I will now and support them all I can.
13

Mike555,

Falkirk 27/04/2008 08:34:41
Brown said: "Whatever the differences and debates of the past week, I know every member of the Labour Party will be working flat out over the next few days. Labour is always ready to listen to people's concerns, and take action on them."

The country is fed up with the constant lies and it will all come home to roost in the May elections. Even then he won't take the hint and go and of course Cameron will love this as his ratings go higher by the week as each countrywide crises takes it's inevitable toll.

Bendy Wendy is just as bad and Alex Salmond has a real easy time at Holyrood. Labour opposition - what opposition?

Labour are no longer the listening party, at least you can believe that for sure!!!!
14

Neil McCart,

Cheltenham 27/04/2008 08:48:59
The fact that Brown had to be taught how to smile, and the fact that he can see no wrong in taking money from the poor to help the rich, leaving the poor to claim some complicated form of State Benefit, really says it all about this man.
15

Neil McCart,

Cheltenham 27/04/2008 08:55:54
Re my last comment No 19, what I should have said was "the fact that Brown had to be taught how to smile, and the fact that he can see no wrong in taking money from the poor to help the rich, leaving A FEW of the poor to claim some complicated form of State Benefit, really says it all about this man."
16

nuffnuff,

Edinburgh 27/04/2008 09:03:52
"What is important in a leader is a resolute will and determination. A man may be versatile and learned, but if he lacks resoluteness and determination, of what use will he be?"
17

McX,

27/04/2008 09:10:18
It's ok, everything's fine. Mariella Frostrup has just defended Broon on the AM1 Show, it's all the medias fault.
18

Union is Best,

27/04/2008 09:39:51
This is not a great day for us Unionists. Tony Blair saying Gordon Brown is rubbish, coming as it does after Margaret Curran said Wendy Alexander was "shockingly and appaulingly bad".

We need to regroup!
19

GM,

27/04/2008 10:02:15
Is there anything in this paper about Fatty-Foulkes London expenses of £45,000?
20

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 27/04/2008 10:45:01
And we're expected to vote for this bunch of deadbeats? :-O

Scotland deserves better than a bunch of London - based losers squabbling amongst each other.

And the answer AIN'T Cameron!
21

pehman,

27/04/2008 11:05:30
24

Union is Best,27/04/2008 09:39:51
This is not a great day for us Unionists. Tony Blair saying Gordon Brown is rubbish, coming as it does after Margaret Curran said Wendy Alexander was "shockingly and appaulingly bad".

Forgive me down here in exile, but I hadn't heard of M Curran's statement, can you supply some detail please ?

22

Union is Best,

27/04/2008 11:11:04
27, well, OK, but don't spread it around - we have enough problems without everyone knowing that even our own Labour MSPs think Wendy Alexander is pure mince.

-------------------------------------------------
'SCOTTISH LABOUR appeared to be in crisis last night after one of the party's most senior MSPs was caught up in a row about briefing against Wendy Alexander.

Margaret Curran, the party's shadow health secretary, has admitted being at the centre of unflattering comments about Alexander's performance as party leader.

A recent newspaper piece had stated that Labour MSPs were critical of her performance and judgement, with the phrase "shocking and appalling" quoted in the story, which is now revealed to have been based on a briefing by Curran.

Curran was said to have been confronted by Labour business manager Jackie Baillie about her behaviour.

http://www.sundayherald.com/news/heraldnews/display.var.2104844.0.0.php?act=complaint&cid=1246782

23

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 11:18:12
28 U i B,

Cheers for that, much appreciated
24

brownlie,

27/04/2008 11:18:34
28 Union

To be fair Margaret had been enjoying George's renowned hospitality at the time but Jackie jumped on her from a great height.
25

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 11:24:28
U i B,

PS, it can't be doing your cause any good that maggie is being described as "mental" and des[perate]browne is having a breakdown, while red[faced] wendy is getting pelters AND baron foolks continues show how deranged he is.

Jeeze and it's all comming from lab supporters an all

26

shivago8,

livingston 27/04/2008 11:30:52
Dont know why the Engalanders have not sent him back a long time ago
Ruined the economy
Ruined the Armed services
Leader of a corrupt Government
Grin of a Chesire cat.
Turncoat.
Keeps talking Scotland down
That CV wont get him a second job when shortly he is to be flung out on his neck.
Goodbye Mr Broon you certainly will not be missed or remembered by the good people of Auld Scotia
27

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 11:33:11
U IB,

PPS, And andy kerr still thinks slab are doing a good job attacking the SNP and cairns thinks he's defending the union.

Oh my oh my, I really feel for you.

Q - what are your plans - do you see anything comming from this ?
28

Alfred E. Neuman,

27/04/2008 11:41:26
I think that Methalions better invent a new moniker character that blasts the Scotsman for bias against Labour.

It is rather telling that there are two stories running today on Brown and Salmond and only people are chipping in to defend Salmond.

The SNP are worshippers not voters. The minority pressure group has more in common with scientology than you could possibly know.

Anyone who disagrees with the SNP will be "fair gamed" on this site.

Shameful.
29

Union is Best,

27/04/2008 11:44:34
31. No, dark day today for us today. Our Red Baron van Glenmorangie revealed to be gouging the taxpayer for £45,000 for London accommodation, for staying at a flat he owns and after buying another one with no mortgage (and all this after he made a song and dance about Salmond using his car...). Gordon described as an electoral liability by Blair. Red Wendy being described by her own shadow cabinet as inept and useless.

We will rally next week I expect - the English local elections are sure to go our way! Onward the Union.
30

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 11:46:58
34 Alf,

Oh come on be fair, UiB's on your side and so are M Curran, des browne, maggie himself, Lord levin,Baron Foolks, Cairns etc
31

Union is Best,

27/04/2008 11:48:34
34. Alfred - just a wee performance note - can you avoid use of the word "game" or phrases incorporating "game" - such as 'on the game',,,, it reminds one of the looming story of hookers and cocaine besetting our biggest Tory donor Lord Laidlaw, festering on another page. Thanks and keep up the good work.
32

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 11:51:39
35 UiB,

Now I think I understand why lab didn't want a vote on the Lisbon Treaty, they want at least one union to be in.

Sorry the one union thing, no pun intended re the TU pulling out of funding lab

33

Union is Best,

27/04/2008 11:57:39
38. Now, it is because we cannot afford the new phones and new furniture bills caused when things go wrong for Gordon ------------"Right now there is a mini boom in rumours about the PM's psychological condition. He's variously said to have taken a wobbly after the election-that-never-was, plunged into depression over Christmas, and brought in the New Year by kicking chairs across the room. A Labour MP told the London Evening Standard that Brown had "recently got through three mobile phones in one week by hurling them against the wall in anger". Of course, phone-hurling may be a perfectly natural response to a series of events that has conspired to undermine Brown's government.-------

34

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 12:00:15
U i B,

I hear also that calman of wendy review.comm, has given up on handing powers back to the incomming tory gov.

So things can't be all that bad for you

35

Alfred E. Neuman,

27/04/2008 12:01:21
39 Meths

Who's that at 1,4,22 amongst others then?
36

Union is Best,

27/04/2008 12:05:04
41. Well yes, but to be honest the Constitutional review thing has not set the heather alight and stolen the SNP thunder like we had hoped. When Brown down-graded it to a working group, then Cairns said it was an issue for the McChattering classes, and now it being leaked to the Herald that the appointments were blocked by London over-ruling Wendy, it isn't going quite as well as hoped. Still, not to worry, Alfred is sniffing out Methalions everywhere on these threads, using a combination of paranoia and obsession, so some progress is being made!
37

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 12:11:48

Yeah I see your problem(s),

So when are you flittin ? or are you able to afford the gas price increase
38

pehman,

sussex 27/04/2008 12:21:16
UiB,

STOP DON'T DO IT, help is at hand !

Tom Brown is on the other thread asking the What If, question

True he doesn't get round to asking -what if lab had stuck to their promise of home rule for Scotland, would lab now be in such a mess. BUT HE MIGHT
39

Matt there,

somewhere 27/04/2008 12:34:55
"D" seems to feature rather heavily in Mr Brown's Political Lexicon:

Dither, Dawdle, Dim, Dally, Dreich.

Not up to the job, is he?
40

Angus Ogg,

27/04/2008 13:11:28
#5,
#6,
#7

How does one post before midnight?

Well stop hitting the repeat button for starters !

#9 Willie is quite right, it is very simple. If I can manage it, and I ain't no whizz with a computer, then anyone should. Just use a little imagination and your "copy" and "paste" functions.

From what I see, the editorial staff start to assemble the pages online between 7pm and midnight when the main access page goes online. You just have to find what is a fairly simple way to go via the back door.

Though last week the Scotsman staff didn't put their stories up until 11.55 so I think the back door is now being locked. Perhaps because the stories sometimes change btween 7 and midnight during what may be a "live" sub or final edit proccess.

Or it may be that staff on the Scotsman are concerned with a rash of pre-midnight posting. Which is a pity as the Ogg is in his bed by midnight as he needs to be up early to catch sheep the next morning.
41

subrosa,

27/04/2008 13:12:18
Meths 2: Poster at 22 (McX) mentions a programme AM1. I have no idea what this programme is. I don't have British TV or radio.

AM1 means the Andrew Marr Show on BBC 1 this morning at 9am I think meths. You'll get it on iplayer if you're quick.
42

,

27/04/2008 14:00:08
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

Tris,

Dundee 27/04/2008 14:06:49


I suppose that we are paying for these tables and cell phones that Brown keeps damaging?

Can we afford him any more?

I see he's had to ask Alex Salmond for help over the Grangemouth situation.


Was there ever anyone as deplorable as a prime minister?
44

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 27/04/2008 14:36:48
#52

No we can't afford this guy any more. The poor and underprivileged are the very ones to come out badly from his attention to the economy, despite his assurances otherwise. The rest of us who can afford a meal are hammered to pay for his reckless excesses. I believe he thought that because Grangemouth is in North Britain that it was just a little local restlessness among the natives in the province. However he may have had his concern exercised a wee bit more on realising that the North Sea oil shutdown will cost his English Exchequer quite a substantial sum. I wonder which flag he'll be waving this week? Apart from the white one that is after the 1st May meltdown!
45

Eve,

Scotland 27/04/2008 15:52:44
#34 Alfred E. Neuman: Poor wee Brown!!!

Poor wee Labour!!!

Shame they won't apaulges to the people of Scotland just to the Labour party members.

Some of us have good reasons why we don't like the Labour party. It was one of there run education board that lied to me about my dyslexia and humiluted me a varous stages through out my school education because of this. My treatment was shocking at school and they never apolagesed to me.

I'm still holding out for an apualgy. I dought I'll ever get one.

I have every right NOT to trust the Labour party.
46

zigzag,

27/04/2008 17:29:51
Wonder if he will go hide in the butt an' ben with Daphne Broon.
47

Richard M,

Scottish Raj 27/04/2008 17:32:15
The kindest thing you can say about Gordon Brown is that he just aint up to it. He wanted the job so badly for so long, and there was a lot of goodwill towards him too, as everybody had had enough of Tony Blair. But what has he actually achieved? Insofar as he is doing anything at all, he is undoing all the things that he previously did such as the 10p tax rate. What is unforgivable is that he will be handing the next election on a plate: in England to the Tories, and in Scotland to the Ace enn Pee
48

Proximaking,

Dundee 27/04/2008 17:59:28
Doesn't Gordon Brown think it is about time the charges against Levy and his side-kick Blair, ..... (or was it the other way round? I can never remember) were revived? The sooner British justice puts those two nasty pieces of trash behind bars the better. What was that thing Levy forgot? People who live in glass-houses shouldn't throw stones, they should keep their traps well and truly shut. llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
49

steve green,

preston, lancashire. 27/04/2008 20:38:39
bliar was full of bulls..t but even bulls..t can make things happen, brown is no leader and is a poor manager,God help us.
50

Lulach mac Gille Coemgáin,

28/04/2008 00:50:44
‘The criticism came as Brown was accused of dithering over the Grangemouth fuel crisis and of dismissing it as a regional problem.’

Aye . . . and with all the planned belittling of the Nationalist Government by arranging a little local crisis - it looks like it’s backfiring on the dirty Broon stuff !
51

,

28/04/2008 16:46:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
52

,

28/04/2008 16:46:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.