Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Brown faces rebellion over scrapping of 10p tax band

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 April 2008
GORDON Brown is battling to subdue a Labour rebellion over tax changes coming into force this week that will leave more than 600,000 low-paid Scots out of pocket.
The Prime Minister was talking to his advisers this weekend to try to reassert his authority after loyalist MPs warned of a public backlash over the abolition of the 10p tax band.

A Treasury source insisted last night that there was no prospect of
a U-turn on the 10p band but did suggest that the Government was looking at other ways of compensating people who will lose out as a result of the change.

"No specific promises have been made (to critical MPs] but everyone in government knows that it's our intention to help people on low incomes and I'm sure that we will continue to look at what can be done."

Tax experts say that people earning between £5,931 and £15,075 a year will be worse off by up to £446 when the 10p band is scrapped, pushing them on to the new basic rate of 20p in the pound.

Figures from the 2007 Annual Survey of Hours and Earning, show that around 608,000 Scottish workers – just over a quarter of all employees – could be hit by the tax change.

People not in work, including under-65s who receive a pension, could also be badly affected.

Most people earning more than £15,075 will be better off as a result of changes to income tax and National Insurance.

Brown announced the changes in his last Budget as Chancellor, but backbenchers say the rising cost of living and looming recession have provoked more and more constituents to express their anger. And, once people see their wage slips, MPs expect an even greater reaction.

Some of the 26 MPs who signed a parliamentary motion opposing the change were seen as the "usual suspects", but the danger for Brown is that previously loyal MPs are beginning to question his judgment.

Shadow Chancellor George Osborne said: "Families are already struggling with rising food prices, higher council tax bills and more expensive mortgages – and now Gordon Brown is hitting them with extra taxes.

On top of his tax rises on a pint of beer and family cars, this month he is putting up taxes on low-paid workers, on employee share-ownership and on small companies.

"Instead of helping with the rising cost of living for families Labour's economic incompetence is adding to it."

Vince Cable, the Liberal Democrats' Treasury spokesman, said: "Labour MPs are finally waking up to Gordon Brown's con-trick of hitting some of the poorest members of society in their pockets just so that he could get some cheap headlines.

"If there had been an election last year he might have got away with it, but as the credit crunch starts to bite people will find this kind of short-term political manoeuvring hard to forgive."

Stewart Hosie, the SNP's Treasury spokesman, said: "Gordon Brown seems to have abandoned Labour's core supporters – and it seems that his MPs are prepared to abandon him.

"The Prime Minister is looking increasingly out of touch and out of time."

Energy firms to be forced to help poor

Energy companies will be obliged by law to introduce low-rate gas and electricity tariffs for poorer households under plans due to be unveiled by ministers this week.

Up to a third of Scottish households, including families on low incomes, pensioners and claimants, could benefit from compulsory "social tariffs".

Although Chancellor Alistair Darling threatened in last month's Budget to use legislation if the big energy companies failed to increase their spending on voluntary social tariffs, ministers had planned to give them time to act of their own accord. The Government has been forced to act sooner than it wished because the Energy Bill is progressing rapidly through Parliament.

Graeme Kerr of consumer watchdog Energywatch said: "It is welcome news – it shows a shift of emphasis by the Government."



The full article contains 675 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 05 April 2008 6:58 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Labour Party
 
1

democrate,

central Scotland 06/04/2008 01:01:00
comment from Wendy please? Socialism, definition in Scotland 2008, take from the poor and give to the ????
2

Guga II,

Rockall 06/04/2008 03:34:55
Maggie Broon could easily afford to bring back the 10p tax rate for lower wage earners. All he needs to do is stop people, like himself, from stealing money from the taxpayers to pay for his dry cleaning, groceries, make-up, taxis for the wife to do the shopping, utility bills, TV licences, and claiming for second homes despite the fact that they live in freebie homes paid for wholly by the taxpayer.

As for Broon, The Mouth of the South, or any of the rest of the New Labour Sleaze and Corruption Party being socialists, that is garbage. My dog is more of a socialist than any of them; and could probably make a better job of running the country too.
3

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 06/04/2008 05:54:39
Is the ILLEGAL WAR IN IRAQ and Afganistan GOT ANYTHING TO DO WITH THIS???????
4

Jimmy the Pie,

06/04/2008 08:21:01
Will Red Wendy be giving 10 out of 10 for her 'Socialist' comrades for this 'peoples budget'??
5

Brian M,

Edinburgh 06/04/2008 09:04:51
It is rumoured that Red Wendy is consulting with herself to see if she can award herself 950 out of 10
6

shivago8,

livingston 06/04/2008 10:03:36
Another nail in his coffin,HIP HIP HOORAY.
Back to grass in Queensferry I say
7

Publius,

Girvan 06/04/2008 10:42:45
Watch it Wardog. Swinney's local income tax will hit ALL the low paid - including those without children - even harder than the end of the 10 per cent band.

You nats are in a glasshouse on this one. Suggest you stop throwing stones.
8

Toast,

06/04/2008 10:44:48
There is nobody at Westminster who has the guts to take on "stalin" Brown,one or two made little noises and claimed to have gained concessions which were a joke,Brown does not lead, he terrifies people into agreeing to his increasingly erratic and destructive policies.Brown, the man hell bent on destroying democracy.
9

shivago8,

livingston 06/04/2008 12:10:42
11# publius
With a name like that and stupid comments I suspect you are suffering from manic depression.
If you and the newwwwwwwwwww labour think that the poll tax is fair then there is a space for you in a special ward in the ERI
10

pehman,

sussex 06/04/2008 12:14:44
First it was a refusal to give the £25 million to Scottish farmers

Then it was £xx million for the olympics

Then it was a refusal of £400 million of the Scottish budget

Then it was the refusal of the £120 million for the prisons

Now it's at the point of actually taking extra back to london

So that's the black hole,

London

11

alanh,

ek 06/04/2008 12:33:06
cheap political stunt by the nu labs trying to get some sort of vote out for the locals in england?

surely, if they really objected to it they should have done that LAST year when it was included in the budget not a year on?
12

democracy,

Galashiels 06/04/2008 14:26:58
Gordon Brown's "rob the poor to feed the rich" proves their "neo-con" label, and will all be gone soon, thankfully!!
13

Sanny,

Glasgow 06/04/2008 14:42:37
11 Publius
Were you born stupid or did you work hard at it. Perhaps you didn’t go to School.
The LIT will increase tax on earnings by 3p max. For those on benefits or on low wages and hence not paying tax, they will pay nought. For those who are already paying tax on their wages, their tax will increase a little; depending on the amount of their taxable income. In the majority of cases, this additional tax will be more than off-sett by the amount they will no longer pay in Council Tax. Only those on substantial salaries will in fact pay more.

In other words the Tax Burden is being shifted to those best provided to pay it. The total tax taken to pay for council services should remain essentially the same and the total spending on services should also remain constant. Indeed if they can improve the collection procedure there may even be a saving that can be used to reduce the tax burden or extend services.

If you think you can disprove the above by all means do come back but make sure you have a solid case in figures.
14

Pilrig.,

Livingston 06/04/2008 15:14:43
Prepare to see Wendy the Red, Lord Foulkes and the rest of the working class heroes take to the street to protest about the scrapping of the 10p abolition .
15

antifa,

06/04/2008 16:20:55
18. I back your call for more evidence on the distributional impact of the LIT proposal. Any links?

Also, could we have a bit more evidence on the 10p tax? Labour are saying it will have little impact when considered alongside tax credits and other benefits. No-one seems to agree. Anyone know the reality?
16

Brian M,

Edinburgh 06/04/2008 17:15:35
#19

"Prepare to see Wendy the Red, Lord Foulkes and the rest of the working class heroes take to the street to protest about the scrapping of the 10p abolition"

and to call for an increase in council tax (bad SNP froze it), and the return of bridge tolls (bad SNP scrapped them), and an increase in prescription charges just like England (bad SNP policy reduced them by £1.60by £1.60).
17

,

06/04/2008 17:31:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
18

man-in-a-suitcase,

Northern Hemisphere. 06/04/2008 20:11:51
Whatever happened to Publius in Girvan? I was waiting for a detailed breakdown as to how the poorest in Scotland were going to be worse off with the LIT. Perhaps he has escaped from the madhouse and is running loose in the Ayrshire hinterland looking for an internet cafe. Poor soul.
19

ochone,

Sauchie, Clack's 07/04/2008 11:23:48
You are all wrong, we have a unionist style of government and therfor everything has always been wonderful, is wonderful and will always remain wonderful.

So long as we just do as we are told!
20

Mike555,

07/04/2008 13:34:46
This man Brown and his pigswilling cronies must go. Not only does he raid the private pension pots of millions of decent hard working people he now stands by his lackluster Chancellor while he takes away the 10p starting band for tax pushing the poorest in the population even closer into debt. Shame on this "Socialist" government.

The Tories and the SNP must be loving this as Labour has now lost any chance of winning next time round.
21

Tim C,

Southern England 07/04/2008 13:36:30
"So what!", as uttered by the MP Eddie Balls when David Cameron spoke about taxation being now the highest for 20 years (approx) in his reply to the glove-puppet-chancellor's speech last month .
Then Ed sneaked off to Hansard and changed his remark to
"so weak".
Let's face it: when you are a Member of Parliament with a salary, expenses, great pension scheme and Status, the hard pressed voter is nowt but a fly on your windscreen. There are not many suits in Whitehall who earn less than £15,000 per annum.
22

Mike555,

Falkirk 08/04/2008 02:43:52
The current Labour Government has made a serious error by deleting the 10% tax threshhold that they will never ever recover from.

The so called Socialists have now decided that they need to hit the poorest in our society by removing the 10% Tax Band. Why??? I can only think they want the Tories in England and the SNP in Scotland next time.

Meanwhile has Red Wendy uttered any pearls of wisdom on this touchy subject?? Silence is golden Wendy I suppose.

Stand up for once and be counted Wendy and you just might get a following you never ever had before.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.