Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Stress leaves 'lasting legacy' in pregnancy

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 March 2008
EMMA Woods was a childminder and already had two children of her own, but her third pregnancy became one of the most stressful experiences of her life. Worse still, the 35-year-old from Orkney wonders if it has left a lasting legacy.
Woods fears the stress she suffered during those nine months could have had a direct effect on the health of her third child, Jack.

That is precisely the possibility highlighted by the research of Edinburgh University academic, Dr Mandy Drake. She
believes stress hormones can cross the placenta and damage the development of the unborn child.

Even more disturbing, she believes it is possible for generations to be doomed to poor health by the process.

In Woods' case she was employed as a full time childminder and felt she could not cut her hours during pregnancy because it would cause her clients too many problems.

Instead, she carried on working despite feeling overwhelmed with responsibility and looking after her two other children, Hugh and Sophie.

She said: "I felt invaluable as a childminder because I was helping other working mums and I was worried about money. I worked until two weeks before my due date.

"I was really stressed with all the work I was doing and on top of it all my husband became ill. He collapsed at work one day and had to have a lot of tests done. Thankfully he was OK, but it caused a lot of anxiety."

When Jack, now five, was born, he suffered a variety of health problems. Woods couldn't help but feel guilty.

She said: "He did not sleep well and was very fractious and cried a lot. He had feeding problems and allergies. It has also turned out that he is severely deaf. I did have a lot of guilt and I did wonder whether it was because I was so stressed. But he is a very happy and sunny boy now."

Woods, who now works for the parenting internet site netmums.com, changed her career in order to reduce her stress.

She said: "In the end I gave up my job because it was all too much. I realised that my own son needed me more than the other children I was looking after."

A degree of stress is generally considered normal – even desirable – in most conditions. But the stress suffered by today's expectant mothers, many of whom want to carry on their careers, can be extreme.

Everyone has a certain amount of the "stress hormone" cortisol naturally present in the body but levels rise under stress.

Cortisol is secreted by the adrenal glands and helps the body in stressful situations by providing a burst of energy needed for 'fight or flight'.

The base level of cortisol fluctuates throughout the day. In the morning it is higher and it reduces by evening.

The average level of cortisol is measured in nanomoles per litre and in a healthy adult would be between 150 and 500nmol/l. But under stress – such as a person on the night before an operation – this level could double to 300 and 1,000nmol/l. Sustained exposure to these levels is likely to cause serious health problems, including high blood pressure.

Usually the placenta stops most of the mother's stress hormones reaching the baby. But it is thought that if there are high levels of the hormones, or if the placenta is not working properly, significant amounts reach the unborn child.

One theory is that while the developing baby is exposed to the stress hormone their own developing reproductive organs may also be damaged, which would affect the health of future generations.

Drake will explain her research at a presentation at the Edinburgh International Science Festival on Wednesday.

Much of the work has been done on rats and mice administered with synthetic hormones. The scientists found that the more stress hormone they received, the greater the effects. Now Drake will carry out studies on babies, testing their cord blood and saliva, to try to identify those at risk.

The findings were last night met with concern from parents' groups. Cathy Rogan, a rights adviser for the campaigning charity Working Families, said: "There are plenty of reasons why pregnant woman suffer stress, including money worries and employment issues. Many just don't know what they are going to be living on when the baby comes and worry about the cost of childcare.

"I am concerned at these findings because there is a lot that can be done by employers to reduce working women's stress, such as reducing long hours and recognising that pregnant women do suffer fatigue and ill health.

"But there is often antagonism between women and their employers about who's getting the most out of the situation. Many women find their employer is not sympathetic. However, I hope this research does not make women even more stressed."

A survey last year by the baby charity Tommy's showed that 90% of 1,100 women suffered stress in pregnancy with money troubles the chief concern. Many worried about developing post-natal depression, and that they might not love their baby.

Andrew Shennan, professor of obstetrics for Tommy's said: "It is vital that we reassure pregnant women that it is OK to feel confused and uncertain during pregnancy."

Dr Lisa Thorn, a researcher from the Psychophysiology and Stress Research Group at the University of Westminster, London, said: "What goes on in your head does impact your health and it impacts on different people in different ways. To what extent depends on the person, the level of stress and how they appraise something as being stressful or not."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 29 March 2008 9:33 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 30/03/2008 02:46:12
This topic, is NOT new, and with a little thought, you would have known IS True!

So with that, there is not much more to be said!

But you know me!..'Of-Course'! there is! :-))

If and when My DYW, gets Pregnant,..'Old Charlie Boy', will be at the..'Rescue', ..for my DYW, if I detect any signs of "Stess"

If you care for your Woman, Like I do! and understand these things you can,

'Rid' your Wife from the "Stresses".. with very little effort!

A 'Pamper' your wife,,being the best, and let her know you Love her, and..
'Baby-To-Be'

And the,..'siesta time together'!

'Cuddle-up-Snuggle-up', for a few hours, and all 3 are in 'Heaven! :-**

On the MOST Important last point is!,

Andrew Shennan, professor of obstetrics for Tommy's said: "It is vital that we reassure pregnant women that it is OK to feel confused and uncertain during pregnancy."

'Totally Agree'! and to one to which, I shall implement, if our dream comes true!
2

DannyG,

Troon 30/03/2008 08:18:53
I am sceptical about this. I have three children and my first pregnancy fell during one of the most stressful periods of my life... sudden death, serious illnesses among family and close friends... and I was working full-time in a high pressure environment, with a two hour commute every day. My daughter was and is (now 16) a sunny healthy child.

There is far too much emotional pressure/guilt stacked on women these days from just this sort of dubious research and newspapers should be very wary of promoting such findings as if they were fact (the article is cautious but the headline is not...)
3

Hermitage,

Edinburgh 30/03/2008 08:18:58
Probably wants compensation!

The answer? Don't get pregnant.

My gran had 9 kids, one a year, (1911-1922), AND worked on the garage forecourt to help out with the business. No labour-saving devices, no disposable nappies or all the things modern parents take for granted.

She didn't have time to feel 'stressed' or to complain about it, but just got on with life.
4

Lenthecooper,

North York 30/03/2008 13:09:05
While I have no doubt that stress will effect the pregnant mother it cannot be the sole cause for the problems encountered in this case. The father collapsed because he was 'ill' yet she continued to work as a child-minder till two weeks before the due date because of worries about money and duty to her clients? This sounds as if there are more difficulties here than are reported.
Has anyone looked at the possiblity that the fetis was in stress and this in turn effected the mother?
I feel very badly for her and can relate to the situation; having an eight week old daughter (and a 20 year old one) but it does smack of being another pseudo-scientific article on the Scotsman.
What is the length of paid Maternity leave in Scotland now?
Cheers,
Len
5

Gavin MacColl,

Edinburgh 30/03/2008 14:23:15
This article generated a feeling of deja vu. The notion of maternal stress/foetal programming is not new and the original studies were carried out in the 1990s.

This work should be taken 'with a pinch of salt' as rodents have a quite different physiology, lifespan and stress hormone rhythm(s) to humans and any work on them cannot be directly extrapolated as such.

Also, the idea that the perceived effects of stress in pregnancy can be boiled down to a single hormone is a rather useless notion as so many environmental and other epigenetic factors play a role in generating illnesses post natally and later in adults, such as high blood pressure, depression and diabetes.
6

moira,

bangkok 30/03/2008 15:14:05
I was a posthumous child, my father having died a few months before I was born.

although I was under the impression that no damage could have been carried to me across the placenta, I have suffered from hypertension and anxiety for as long as I can remember. A psychologist did remark that I was born to a grieving mother.

I just keep taking the pills!
7

JT,

30/03/2008 18:48:18
Im sorry to hear that this woman got stressed outduring the 3rd pregnancy, however society puts pressure on you to have children no matter what. What about the people who try and cant, or like me dont want to have kids. I got asked seriously at work the other day when someone brought a screaming tot in (how stressful was that) that I better get my skates on if I want kids Im 36 and dont want kids! She looked at me like I was not normal. Your dammed if you do and dammed if you dont!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.