Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Iain Morrison: 'Anywhere else in the world a bona fide hero such as Calder would romp home'

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 June 2009
THE SRU'S AGM has been shunted from its traditional Friday evening time slot to an 11am start next Saturday. The Lions kick off just three hours later, which should concentrate the delegates' minds wonderfully well.
Much of the focus will be on the presidential election. Anywhere else in the world a bona fide rugby hero and former Lions/Scotland skipper such as Finlay Calder would romp home but the clubs who make the decision are a quirky lot, as PC Brown will
testify.

A few years back Calder, pictured, spent his Saturday afternoons casting his eye over Edinburgh Accies reserves before collecting the corner flags at full time. It is difficult to imagine any other former Lions skipper rolling up his sleeves and getting involved at such a modest level of the game. Calder spoke last week of his hopes for Scottish rugby if he becomes president.

"It's time we brought ourselves up to the mark in our handling of our English neighbours. We have to offer them, and everyone else that visits Murrayfield, the proper respect because our behaviour has not always been the best. I want the match day experience to be an exciting one for everyone involved including the opposition. We have a great coach in Andy Robinson and I am 100% behind him and what he is trying to do. We have a good enough side to take anyone in world rugby on our day and we all need to get behind the coach and the team."

Since the French team was pelted with bottles after beating the All Blacks in Dunedin last week, Calder may have a point and he warns, "don't think it couldn't happen here".

Jim Gracie, a former member of the old, discredited general committee, is also standing for president as is the incumbent, Jim Stevenson, who cannot be accused of leaving any stone unturned in his fight for re-election, especially if there may be a vote lurking beneath it. The Cambuslang man attended two club dinners in the one night a little while back and he travelled to the Islay Beach Rugby festival just for the afternoon; a round trip of at least eight hours. Having criticised George Jack for standing for a second term last year last year, Stevenson is sufficiently infected by the presidential bug that he is canvassing like a Clinton for his own re-election. The populist president spoke last week from South Africa about "unfinished business" that he has on his plate and the honour he felt at being voted into the Union's top job. It promises to be a close vote.

Outwith the presidential arm-wrestle there are a couple of interesting political manoeuvres. Motion 8 suggests that the president should automatically chair the council no matter how useless he may be, although it isn't couched in those exact terms. Motion 6 asks that one rep from each of the premier, national and regional leagues is represented on the council in addition to the president and one other council member drawn from affiliates (refs, schools and women). This would put five council members on the SRU board despite Sheriff Bill Dunlop's carefully crafted advice that it should consist of four executives, four non-executives and four from the council.

Both these proposals emanate from Stirling County who also ask for integrated school and club leagues at U18 and U16 level to offer Scotland's youth a better standard of rugby. As things stand the best teams enjoy just one or two competitive matches each season but, for their own reasons, the private schools have already said they will play no part in leagues. The Union should instigate them anyway and hope the fee-paying schools jump on board later;none of them joined the schools cup until they saw the runaway success of the venture.

If Motion 5 is passed the ladies' SWRU will be fully integrated into the SRU. Otherwise the most interesting suggestion comes in Motion 4, a package of bye-law amendments emanating from the standing working party on governance, which is proposed by SRU chairman Allan Munro. One amendment requires that a person can stand for president just once. But before Stevenson reaches for the smelling salts, the motion would only come into effect next year.





The full article contains 732 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

dhu ron ron ron,

21/06/2009 09:34:57
Calder is indeed a Scottish rugby legend but exactly what is he bringing to the table ?
The current state of Scottish rugby is not great, and his solution seems to be that everything will be okay as long as our visitors have a very nice day out at Murrayfield.
Not exactly a balanced article Mr Morrison !
At least by making two dinners in the one day either Mr Stevenson;
a.Likes his food.
b. Is committed to trying to be president to do something for the good of Scottish rugby.
2

royco,

21/06/2009 13:33:15
Scottish rugby is not exactly scaling the heights just now and it is hard to see how an establishment blazer as President would move things forward. Calder seems to have a thing about Croke Park and Flower of Scotland and that's it, not exactly a blueprint for development and progress.

Stephenson's text on the SRU website calls for more money at the rugby end, proposals for a 3rd pro team and so on, he has some progressive policies. He has also apparently carried out 220(!) engagements over the year, according to his report sent to clubs, so looks pretty hard-working. No mention of these tangibles here though.
3

Millbrae,

21/06/2009 15:37:48
Not the unbiased & well researched stuff we expect of the Scotsman.

Calder's submission to the SRU, like Gracie's, was appalling void of any meaningful content.

Yet for some reason Morrison is giving calder another chance to expound his higher level aims for Scottish rugby, the presidency, et al.

I assume that as a totally unbiased & professional reporter he will provide the same open, unbiased facility to each of the other candidates, whereby he will give them air time then add little bitchy comments about each of the other candidates.

Mr Morrison....you are bringing your prefession into disrepute!
4

BrightonExile,

22/06/2009 09:18:13
Does the SRU have a large share in the Scotsman now? It seems to have lost entirely its editorial integrity.

"Much of the focus will be on the presidential election. Anywhere else in the world a bona fide rugby hero and former Lions/Scotland skipper such as Finlay Calder would romp home"???????????????

When are Scots going to lose the idea that a good international player would make a good go at all roles, including President. I've seen nothing (and have been looking) for Calders policies outside changing the anthem and rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic. Stevenson at least is pushing hard for change, and has done a stirling job this year.

The only reason the SRU media machine (where are they ever in evidence when it comes to promoting the game) is pushing so hard is that they hate the loss of power and control that Stevenson will bring and push forward their puppet.
5

Shameless,

Bucaresti 22/06/2009 09:20:16
Excessively biased tripe which only serves to underline why Jim Stevenson should receive the support of every progressive right-minded voter at the AGM.
6

THE DREADED SILVER CROC,

Around the Kraal, chewing biltong, drinking numero 24/06/2009 17:41:13
Election to office of SRU President is not a beauty contest, nor indeed a process of settling tired former players (no matter whom) and worn-out bufties of uncertain origin, lineage, administrative, managerial or ambassadorial capacity in their dotage.
7

THE DREADED SILVER CROC,

Kraal voting station 24/06/2009 17:42:47
Support Stevenson!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.