Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 20th July 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Jobless future looms for 100 doctors



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 December 2007
UP TO 100 Scottish doctors face unemployment next year because of a shortage of jobs, wasting £25m of taxpayers' money.
Scotland on Sunday can reveal that the number of jobs available to junior doctors next year in the NHS across Scotland will fall far short of the number of applicants.

Doctors' leaders last night warned that those who are unsuccessful could be for
ced to abandon the NHS despite years of training that has cost the taxpayer £250,000 per doctor. And they predicted huge pressure for hospitals next summer, with managers rushing to match junior doctors to vacant posts.

Last night patients' groups described the revelation as "an almighty mess". The move to train more doctors was an attempt to help fill a recruitment crisis at the most senior levels in the NHS.

Although more doctors are now being put through medical school, there are not enough jobs for them to go to. The problem comes as the number of long-term consultant vacancies stands at an all-time high, with 4.2% of posts lying empty for six months or more.

In summer 2008 there will be 1,382 junior doctors who have trained in Scotland chasing just 1,279 vacancies in the NHS. They also face stiff competition from colleagues from England and overseas who are also allowed to apply for jobs in Scotland.

Dr Alan Robertson, the head of the British Medical Association's junior doctors committee, warned many could be forced to quit medicine altogether if they do not get a suitable job. He said: "There will be a large number of applications and it will be a big problem to sort through them. We are encouraging Scottish applicants not to undersell themselves and do the best they can. We may have some good candidates from down south applying for jobs in Scotland.

"We want an increase in posts, but we have been told there is no funding. This raises the prospect of doctors being unemployed after seven years of training post-graduation. It costs the taxpayer £250,000 to put someone through medical school. As a worst-case scenario they could leave medicine, which is taxpayers' money wasted."

The number of jobs available next year for junior doctors was revealed yesterday in an open letter to all applicants from the Chief Medical Officer Dr Harry Burns. In his letter, Burns admits that next year's process of matching doctors to jobs will be "difficult" with "areas of concern and controversy".

There were problems with the junior doctor recruitment process this summer, when there were also far more applicants than vacancies.

Operations had to be postponed to allow managers time to deal with a last-minute dash to fit staff into vacant posts. Doctors took to the streets in protest.

A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: "We expect that, as has always been the case, a proportion of Scottish doctors will move to England and elsewhere at this point in their training. We expect there will be flows in both directions across the Border with England and with other countries."



The full article contains 517 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 December 2007 7:53 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Health of the NHS
 
1

Louisa,

Perthshire 16/12/2007 01:54:53
We need ALL the doctors we train - but the government restrict the amount of money to pay for NHS placement positions to train for post-graduate qualification, clinical experience and professional career progression. It's not too many doctors - the real problem is it's not enough money spent on the right things. Get rid of non-productive NHS managerial 'jobsworths', get rid of political ad hoc ideology and associated preposterous reforms/changes/targets/blundering IT systems/'modernisation' etc. and use the money in the patients best interests by employing many more much needed doctors, nurses and PAMS. How many more times does this simple fact need repeating before the government listens to the professionals who actually know what's needed as they are the only ones who understand the priniciples and reality of the NHS.
2

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 16/12/2007 02:27:28
#1 Louisa,Perthshire'
"We need ALL the doctors we train" I Agree!
Our Doctors are 'second to none' in this world, unfortunately this excludes the 'GP', who is at best,
'Elusive' and 'don't want to know', they have every barrier, in place 'not to see the real sick', these days, starting of, with a well trained receptionist to,
'block your call for help'
So they bring in the 'pharmacist' now!, to bridge their disgraceful behaviour!
While our Doctors that work in A&E and in our hospitals, will do anything to help the sick and work their 'cotton socks off'
This article don't make this clarity clear!
If its a Doctor wanting to become a 'GP' or a Doctor that wants to help the sick, in our society!
These days unfortunately there is a major difference between the two above, this is why this problem, maybe arising!
3

Pete40,

Tassy 16/12/2007 06:15:58
Doctors are sorely needed all over the world. In Australia they tend to give them not too great a deal. We have had in Tasmania doctors of international standards and ability, at the end of the day they are asked to sit tests to prove their ability to meet Australian standards. The failure rate appears to some to be rather high. Whether it is the content of the exam or the unwillingness of doctors to be assessed by those of inferior standards, it is difficult to find out. Certainly, it is one of those peculiarities that could be better answered by the Australian Medical Association, rather than an OAP.
4

Mallory,

Edinburgh 16/12/2007 08:38:56
Do the Royal Colleges nopt have any say in the number of medical students then?
5

fred bloggs,

16/12/2007 09:09:42
2. 'Charles': I 'think' you need to see your 'GP' about your "'excessive punctuation syndrome'"?!
6

giuseppe de santis,

london 16/12/2007 11:16:04
This is happening when the NHS keep emplying plenty of foreign doctors and nurses.
It's time to stop this madness and offer training to all the British graduate doctors even if this means sack foreign staff,something the British National Party support.
Before accusing me of being racist I want to remind that developing countries are upset because we poach medical staff strongly needed there.
7

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 16/12/2007 15:13:22
#2 Charles Linskaill

I see the disgruntled nitpickers are still with us in this new webdesign.

Perhaps they could be more positive and look at the substance of your postings rather than dwelling on peripheral matters that, in the end, do not affect what it is that you have to say.
8

Roballe,

Aberdeen 16/12/2007 16:50:56
Louisa, it’s the customers the government should be listening to, not the providers. If you let the medical staff run the show they’d only give themselves further pay increases and buy a few more toys to play with. One of the downsides to significantly higher pay for doctors is that we employ far fewer of them. It’s not rocket science - there’s only so much money in the pot; and hospital managers are discovering it can be more cost effective to fill posts with pretendy doctors - nurse specialists. Not good for you and me. Yes, vacancies are sometimes filled by staff that qualified overseas, but although we train a fair number ourselves, I suspect you wouldn’t necessarily want one or two of them treating you at your local surgery; certainly not when we can continue to recruit superior foreign personnel. If it’s value for money you want and are upset at blowing £250k on training and then not getting your investment back, stop training those women that graduate and work for barely five minutes before have children: then return on a part time basis or not at all. But that wouldn’t be fair, would it? Remember, nothing’s perfect and we can’t always have everything we want. Until Scotland bites the bullet and begins supplementing taxpayers money with some form of universal medical insurance I doubt we’ll ever receive that so-called ‘world class’ service we hear so much about.
9

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 16/12/2007 16:55:04
#7.Tim, as I said before the new web site will just take time to get use to, its called 'progress' and it dont matter how much we moan, its here to stay, my problem with it, is 70% of my posts are from my mobile phone, which now wont let me sign in, plus the fact subject matters on here, seem to vanish into another catogery at times.
Hope you are well and nice to see ya!
10

lachlan,

16/12/2007 20:44:26
well i'll be looking for some well educated trolly collectors down the supermarket.it's a sin thier union got them such a good pay rise that we can't afford to pay them all.
11

fylk,

Dryden Ontario Canada 17/12/2007 16:25:43
Send your doctors here. We will hire all of them and grant relocation bonuses.
12

fylk,

Dryden OntarioCanada 17/12/2007 16:26:57
Send your doctors to Canada. We will hire all of them.
13

Goomba,

Ohio 28/12/2007 17:35:04
We would love your doctors in the US! We've never heard of an unemployed doctor before....

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Should gastric band ops to aid weight loss be available on the NHS?
Yes, this surgery will save lives
Yes, as long as it’s not a cop out for the obese
No, these people are responsible for their weight

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.