Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Drug expert recommends heroin 'shooting galleries'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 March 2008
A LEADING drugs expert will this week recommend that 'shooting galleries' are set up in Scotland to allow heroin addicts to inject drugs safely.
Larry Campbell, a Canadian senator, believes a similar scheme in Vancouver has saved many drug addicts' lives and cut the risk of infections from dirty needles.

At one state-funded clinic in Vancouver, addicts bring their own drugs and are given c
lean needles to inject, overseen by nurses who can monitor them for signs of an overdose.

The injecting rooms allow addicts to take illegal hard drugs without fear of arrest.

Campbell plans to lay out his idea on Wednesday at a meeting of the Scottish Parliament's Futures Forum, which is preparing a report on new ways of tackling Scotland's drug and alcohol problems.

He said last night: "We have set up a supervised injection site. Our approach has meant we have 7,000 drug-users registered and 400 overdoses have taken place at the site but not a single person has died. People can be treated by medical staff in the clinic. It's not without its controversy in Canada but it's a health clinic.

"This was set up to prevent the spread of disease through dirty needles. The fact that no-one has died is an amazing record. I can state unequivocally that people are alive as a result of this clinic. We have also made referrals to addiction counselling and treatment. Drug-users can register under a false name and they are given a dish that contains a swab, syringe and antiseptic wipe.

"It's something that should be considered in Scotland alongside prevention, treatment and enforcement. It lessens public disorder."

Similar clinics exist in Switzerland, Australia and the Netherlands, and there are growing calls for the introduction of them in Scotland.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 March 2008 7:38 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Drugs policy
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 00:42:25
Will they even...'take heed',? I doubt it!
2

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 09/03/2008 03:28:25
Australia has had them for years and they are a complete failure. What druggo is going to travel for miles to the nearest shooting-gallery if the can just use the closest alley, beach or public park. It has done absolutely stuff-all to alleviate the growing problem of discarded needles.
3

,

09/03/2008 07:27:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Mcsnagpile,

09/03/2008 10:07:35
They should also make it environmentally friendly by making the gallery a single end apartment with sterilised muck on the floor; a sink full of sterilised dirty dishes. A sterilised bent, blunt, dirty needle would also help. Free compulsory access to Second Life where they can shoot up all day for free.
5

David Raynes,

BATH 09/03/2008 14:44:30
This proposal is illegal under UK Law unless the Home Office were minded to grant special arrangements. It has shown no inclination to do that. Scotland does not have the delegated authority to do this as the Welsh Assembly found when an enthusiast tried to promote a "heroin bus" there a couple of years ago. We need to be very careful indeed about the suggestion, not everyone in Vancouver approves of it indeed theirs may be closed down soon. We should also be every cautious because injecting rooms are being pushed hard internationally by many of the same lobbyists (financed by big business) who want all drugs legalised. Superficially it sounds as though there may be an effect upon transmission of disease, through provison of clean needles, the reality is that by bringing addicts together in one place, other problems are created, not least encouraging sexual transmission of Hepatitis and HIV. There are other effects of increased localised crime and public nuisance. What addicts overwhelmingly seem to want is help to get off drugs. This proposal is not addressing that. Of wider concern is just why is the Scottish Parliament having such a one sided un-balanced debate? Who has paid Campbell's fare? Who has rigged the agenda and the speakers?
6

hassan i sabbah,

edinburgh 09/03/2008 14:51:18
McDonalds?
7

Al Arsenault,

Vancouver, BC, Canada 10/03/2008 13:36:39
I walked the beat down in Vancouver’s Skid Road as a police officer for decades and I watched a series of failed social experiments kill and infect thousands of people desperately in need of treatment in a place I now call the ‘chemical gulag’.

The drug legalizers would like you to believe that the Needle Exchange Program (NEP) and the Supervised Injection Sites (SIS) were huge successes. They were utter and abject failures, driving up the Hep C rate to saturation levels (95%) and the HIV rate to the highest in the developed world (from a starting point of 3% and 2% respectively in 1988 when the NEP opened up). Read the Dr. Garth Davies’ article: ‘A Critical Evaluation of the Effects of Safe Injection Facilities’ in Volume 1, Issue 3 of The Journal of Global Drug Policy and Practice, and Dr. Colin Mangham’s ‘A Critique of Canada’s INSITE Injection Site and its Parent Philosophy’ in this same journal (www.globaldrugpolicy.org) for some real insight on this matter.

Campbell should hang his head in shame for what he has put this community through by carrying on with this SIS nonsense.

Do you know what twenty years of so-called Harm Reduction will bring? Perhaps a live addict who will use up more precious health resources because he/ she will most likely be a sick addict on top of still having their habit, which you will also be paying for.

They say that you can’t detox a dead addict.

NO ONE has ever died nor gotten a drug-induced infectious illness in a good treatment program, because the addict is separated from the poison. It is not the dirty needle or the crack pipe lacking a rubber mouthpiece that is the problem: it is the relationship between the addict and the drug. Period. Coerced treatment works as good as voluntary treatment. At the end two decades of treatment, you will most likely have a healthy, productive and contributing member of society.

The poor get Harm Reduction and the rich get treatment. You don’t give an addict what they want.
8

Al Arsenault,

Vancouver, BC, Canada 10/03/2008 13:40:23
Part 2/2

True compassion lies in giving them what they need. It’s your choice to make but thousands of lives depend on running these snake oil salesmen out of town.

Al Arsenault
Member
Odd Squad Productions Society (www.oddsquad.com)
Drug Prevention Network of Canada (www.dpnoc.com)
International Task Force on Strategic Drug Policy (www.itfsdp.org)
9

Al Arsenault,

Vancouver, B.C. Canada john.mckay@vpd.ca 16/03/2008 17:46:47
From: McKay, John [mailto:john.mckay@vpd.ca]
Sent: March 16, 2008 5:43 AM
Subject: FW: SCOTLAND Drug expert recommends heroin 'shooting galleries'

Attn Kate Fisher.

I was the officer in charge of Vancouver's Down Town East Side between
2001 and 2006. In 2008, our city has been the victim of 7 years of
harm reduction and 4 years of the Supervised Lethal Injection Site. You
would think from listening to Mr. Campbell that the 4 Pillars has
created Shangri-la. Don't buy that for one second! The Four Pillars
policy has only succeeded in creating a ghetto where business has left,
residents aren't safe and the streets smell like a sewer. The addicts
are sicker and the community is falling apart. The truth is that this
experiment has been a complete failure.
Before you go down the road Mr. Campbell is directing you down, spend
some money and come take a look at this so called "success." Call me
when you get here and I can arrange the "reality tour." Then you can
judge for yourself.

John McKay Inspector
Operations Division Duty Officer
Ph (604) 717- 3600
email: john.mckay@vpd.ca
Loyalty above all...except honour!
10

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 18/03/2008 01:11:20
I am in favour of anything which is ore realistic than the current phoney war on drugs which has been raging totally UNSUCCESSFULLY for FIFTY years.

This sounds very sensible to me. Giving addicts the drug free in their arm every morning at a clinic sounds even more sensible to me.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.