Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Harper tipped to be Presiding Officer

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
28 January 2007
GREEN MSP Robin Harper has emerged as a hot favourite to be the Scottish Parliament's next Presiding Officer, according to insiders.
Senior sources at Holyrood believe the likelihood of a closely fought election in May will mean that none of the main parties will be willing to 'waste' a hard-won seat to fill the politically neutral role of chairing Holyrood debates.

The curren
t Presiding Officer, Sir George Reid, of the Scottish National Party, is standing down in May, meaning it will be seen as another party's 'turn' for the post.

The first Presiding Officer was Liberal Democrat Sir David Steel, making it unlikely a Lib Dem will get the job.

Although Labour is the largest party at Holyrood, party insiders have said it is "dead against" one of its MSPs taking on the post.

The revival of the SNP, as indicated by polling levels which show it might beat Labour in May, means the main parties are unlikely to want to give up a single seat.

Presiding Officers are barred from voting or speaking in the chamber, and a close-run contest would mean that losing an MSP's vote might be crucial.

A senior Holyrood source said: "Labour, the SNP and the Lib Dems won't want it. There will be suspicion about a Tory. That leaves a Green as a possibility.

"Robin Harper has been in parliament since 1999 and is widely liked. People think he's pretty fair and has now got a lot of experience. It would show that we're an inclusive parliament and that there's a place for smaller parties."

Harper said:

"No one has talked to me about this, but... it would be an honour even to be considered.

"I think we have to get the election out of the way first - whether I am even an MSP after the election is a matter for the voters."

In addition to the Presiding Officer, Holyrood has two deputy presiding officers, who are each free to take part in debates and votes when the senior Presiding Officer is present.



The full article contains 347 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Mallory,

28/01/2007 05:02:36

If he is re-elected, a worthy choice.

2

Grant,

Edinburgh 28/01/2007 06:47:56

I thought he'd make a good Environment Minister in a possible SNP/Green coalition government.

3

,

28/01/2007 08:05:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Ted,

28/01/2007 08:58:07

Robin would be a great choice, he'd be very fair and he'd also be excellent at the ceremonial side: meetin' and greetin'.

However, with it looking likely that the Greens could hold the balance of power, he'll probably be needed elsewhere. Under those circumstances, Deputy Presiding Officer would be a good role for him: he could still vote with the others.

If he can't do it, maybe Annabel Goldie will want out of the Tory leadership and might do it. She's respected across Parliament, but doesn't seem to have taken to her current job.

Or Trish Godman, who's been an excellent Deputy Presiding Officer.

Murdo's right about one thing, though: it can't be another Nat or another Lib Dem. Narrows the field..

Quickly: AJS, what nonsense about George Reid! Undoubtedly the right man at the right time, capping the architects' fees, pushing through the inquiry, and really putting his back into it. Also an exceptionally able chairer of Parliamentary business.

5

Steve,

Bo'ness 28/01/2007 09:26:29

George Reid a grossly overrated egotist? Garbage.
A more decent guy you wont find.
Good luck to Robin Harper, but I'd rather this turkey of a job was handed to Labour even though they have very little in the way of what you could call a statesman.

6

GW,

28/01/2007 09:34:02

How about Malcolm Chisolm? He has shown his ability to stand up for his principles even at the cost of losing ministerial position - twice! Perhaps the ideal person in that he would be seen to have the courage to take a stand against anyone, including his own party if need be.

7

Ted,

28/01/2007 09:58:11

If the SNP beat Labour and can make a coalition, someone from Labour will certainly be more acceptable. Chisholm is not a bad choice, but he would need to cheer up a little!

8

Edinbro,

28/01/2007 10:23:21

Well only if Chisholm holds his seat!

My grandmother has lived in Pilton for 30 years and got her first ever non-election Labour leaflet through her door, all attacking the Lib Dems.

If Labour feels they have to campaign in Pilton, they must be worried.

9

,

28/01/2007 10:31:29
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

Scaramouche,

28/01/2007 10:45:55

Malcolm Chisholm for Presiding Officer - no.
Robin Harper?? Yeah sure!

The office itself is like the Speaker in the HoP in England. You don't belong to any party, your efectiveness as an MSP is severely curtailed and you have no vote.

Yeah, go on. Give it to Robin (sh*tebag) Harper! He deserves it!

11

Edward,

28/01/2007 10:53:20

"Although Labour is the largest party at Holyrood, party insiders have said it is "dead against" one of its MSPs taking on the post"
Very prosumtious of the Scotland on Sunday to assume that Labour will remain the largest party in the Scottish Parliament after the May elections

12

Edward,

28/01/2007 10:54:09

correction 'Presumptuous' (no spell check on this)

13

Edward,

28/01/2007 10:56:44

I also think its Presumptuous to speculate on who would be the next presiding officer (why cant we call him/her speaker?) as at the moment there is no guarantee who will survive the May elections

14

,

28/01/2007 11:48:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

Edward,

28/01/2007 12:03:20

#14 Thanks, I knew it was along those lines and agree that Ross Harper is the obvious choice
I just thought that there is still 3 months to go....

16

Jack F.,

28/01/2007 13:20:50

AJS, actually, I worked with George a long time ago, and I've kept in contact with him, and I disagree. He's got a level head, he's fair, and he's exceptionally smart. A shame he was never First Minister.

And if you think he was soft on the architects and the builders, talk to them. RMJM nearly went bust, Bovis took a pounding, and rightly so. End result: a great building that is only disliked by the Tories, the fundamentalist fringe of SNP and Prince Charles.

17

,

28/01/2007 14:05:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
18

sheena,

Ochil 28/01/2007 15:41:31

AJS:17 says: 'Check it out, he's only retiring as the local nats would not back him to stand in Ochil again'.

This is so not true. As George was our sitting MSP (and a first past the post one at that) Ochil SNP would have backed him *if he had wanted to stand again*. The constituency party waited (more or less patiently) until he made up his mind to retire and put that in writing, before seeking nominations for candidates.

Of course we were proud when he was chosen as PO and of course we were disappointed when it sank in that the SNP had effectively 'lost' one of our most articulate and respected MSPs. George Reid has, however, continued to be a hardworking and effective constituency MSP so his supporters got their 'votes worth' in that respect.

I do think we have to review the 'impact of the last one' in terms of the office itself. It is unfair that a party should lose a vote and a voice in the parlie in order that there should be an unbiased PO. Very few MSPs would be prepared to put parlie before party in this way and if an Independent took on the role the platform on which they stood would be completely unrepresented. To resolve this inequity I would propose that when an MSP becomes PO, they are replaced on the 'benches' by whoever is next on their party's list. Any other ideas.

19

Scots Man,

28/01/2007 16:57:19

Robin is certainly honest, likable, charismatic...

20

,

28/01/2007 17:05:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Sophia,

Edinburgh 28/01/2007 22:31:37

SIR George???????? Since when???? Someone jumping the gun????

22

,

29/01/2007 08:35:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.