Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Aggressive machismo keeps gay sportsmen in the closet

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 18 February 2007
I HAVE known John Amaechi for almost a decade now. We've had many interesting discussions on both sides of the Atlantic which have rarely had anything to do with sport. We even share the world record for the shortest ever visit to Disney World (two minutes, thanks to autograph hunters - for him, not me).
I consider him to be the most cerebral sportsmen I know, as well as a friend. Until last week, we'd never discussed his sexuality. But I knew.

When it came to this particular elephant in the room, I evaded the beast by using gender-neutral termin
ology - "seeing anyone?" - respecting John's decision to control his life as he saw fit.

Three years ago, however, he gave me the only interview during his playing career on the subject of the ordeals which a gay basketball player would go through in the NBA, telling this paper that the league was not ready for such a thing, that "it would be like an alien beaming down from space". Last week, those words were recycled and regurgitated in newspapers and websites across America and beyond. They now carried a much greater significance than when originally uttered.

Yet the quandaries, peculiarities and sensitivities of the subject of gays in sport are all wrapped up in this untidy package. Should sexuality matter on the field, court or arena? Of course it shouldn't.

But it does. Otherwise, Amaechi's book, fascinating though it is, would be buried on bookshelves rather than sitting near the very top of Amazon's bestseller list. Should it cause division? No way. But it does.

Observe the proliferation of gay rugby teams and football leagues, generated by more by a need to be included than to create exclusion.

Stereotypes reign. Gay men don't play sport, they go shopping. They don't watch sport, they watch romantic films with a box of tissues. "You could say there is an amount of that but it is more a stereotype than reality," said one rugby-playing gay acquaintance of mine. "If you are not out, you can go and play but if you are out, there is that atmosphere of being different. If you go to see a football game, there are chants, there is that machismo. It's not something a lot of gay men enjoy."

Allen Iverson, one of Amaechi's regular opponents during his spell in America, once composed a rap tune. "Come to me with faggot tendencies and you'll be sleeping where the maggots be."

Which perhaps explains why there are so few like Amaechi.

Ian Roberts, one of the toughest men in Australian Rugby League, is one of an even more exclusive club: those who came out while still pursuing their career. " Some people call you a poof and you laugh with them," he observed at the time, "while there are others who you just want to smack in the head."

It is widely rumoured that the list of covertly gay British sportsmen includes current and recent rugby internationals, Olympic medal-winning athletes and swimmers. Few in their sport care, but you need only think of the tormented Justin Fashanu to know that there is no guarantee of a happy ending. He was humiliated by Brian Clough, being sent off to train on his own, before being exiled to Hearts. Eventually, in a fit of self-loathing, he killed himself. Even Fash's own brother, John, disowned him.

Double standards apply in which gay sportsmen are beyond the pale while lesbians are so common in sport that they're barely worthy of note. There are entire female rugby and football teams in Scotland where there is not a single heterosexual. Not an eyelid is batted. Martina Navratilova was stigmatised as she blazed a trail but in more enlightened times, others such as Amelie Mauresmo have followed with little fuss. In golf, the predilections of Karrie Webb and Patty Sheehan attract minimal review. And rightly so.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 February 2007 9:17 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Gay and Lesbian issues
 
1

Alistair Stewart,

DUNDEE 18/02/2007 01:40:34

It will probably take another few centuries for most homophobia to die out .... it's so ridiculous as being gay does not define most people - it just happens to be their sexual preference.

2

Derek Williams,

Edinburgh 18/02/2007 08:43:31

Sexual orientation is a more accurate term than 'preference', given that no-one would prefer to be gay which is a stigmatised minority, any more than heterosexuals choose to be straight. Sexual attraction just starts manifesting all by itself at adolescence and that's when people have to learn how to deal with the consequences of what dear Mother Nature has delivered them.

It is to be hoped that by his coming out, the charismatic John Amaechi will inspire other closeted homosexual sportsmen to stop living a lie and come clean, and thus provide good role models for the benefit of self-hating gay youth and their tormentors.

Looking at the findings published in the recent "Caution: Sextrum" supplement published in Scotland on Sunday (Feb 11); it is now beyond doubt that most people are willing to live and let live and accept that that vast majority of homosexuals are like the vast majority of heterosexuals, decent, hard working, honest people committed to the rule of law and the ideals of family and their community.

That there are exceptions is to be deplored, but that should not take away the right of the majority who are committed to the service of their communities to be accorded respect and to live their lives in happiness.

Paradoxically, any man who is polite and helpful, works hard at school, dresses well, and speaks well is far more likely to be written off as a 'poof' by the yob element.

3

Shirley,

Southampton 18/02/2007 11:10:58

It must be difficult, especially for gay footballers in UK.
When knuckledraggers like Robbie Fowler think that reading a broadsheet newspaper and the ability to string a couple of coherent sentences together = gay (ref: the infamous Graeme le Saux incident) then it looks like a long time before we`ll see any progress.

4

Alistair Stewart,

18/02/2007 11:39:52

#2

Hi Derek
I must disagree with one part of your post, and that is where you say "given that no-one would prefer to be gay which is a stigmatised minority".

I would MUCH rather prefer to be gay than straight - I am very happy to be gay and feel I have a more balanced and healthy outlook to many more things because I am gay. I may get disapproved by some small minded homophobes but that is water of a duck's back.

I think most gay men (the ones I know anyway) thank whoever that they are gay and not straight.

That said I am not in any way being uncomplimentary or suggesting either are superior - just that if mother nature did give some of us the gay card then I believe the majority of us are quite happy with that.

Your line suggests that it's like having a bad skin condition - you'd rather not have it but get on with life anyway - conversely as a gay man with many contacts with other gay men over the past 30 years I can say with some degree of experience that that is sheer nonsense and not backed up by any real fact.

5

Derek Williams,

Edinburgh 18/02/2007 11:53:59

#4 - an interesting interpretation that I had not had in mind when commenting - my observation was intended to mean that if one were in a position to choose (all other things being equal), then choosing a sexual orientation that has the potential to alienate you from your family, friends and employers would not make sense.

It is beyond dispute that very advsere outcomes have been the experience for many people of actual or putative homosexual orientation. My point was intended to emphasise the fact that one's sexuality is not a personal choice but is handed down to us all by nature.

6

Helen,

18/02/2007 12:00:39

When I was at Hampden last May for the Scottish FA Cup final, it really bothered me that the Hearts fans were chanting 'Oh the Hibees are gay'. Apart from anything, they weren't even playing Hibs, but it's a bit more sinister than that. When other clubs are charged for racist and sectarian chanting, surely Hearts should be hauled over the coals for homophobic chanting. No the wonder gay footballers can't be open about their sexuality when that kind of nonsense goes unchecked at cup finals.

7

Derek Williams,

Edinburgh 18/02/2007 12:08:41

#5 typo "advsere outcomes" should read "adverse outcomes"; festina lente, mea maxima culpa!

8

,

18/02/2007 12:46:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 380122, Article id was mapped to record!
9

Derek Williams,

Edinburgh 18/02/2007 12:57:56

# 8 - While it is no doubt exceedingly funny if one is not the actual object of homophobic derision, I wonder how they'd feel about chanting "Oh the Hibees are niggers" - it would be intended as a joke of course.

10

alicia,

18/02/2007 13:18:51

8 - Football fans display some of the worst bigotry, sectarianism and intolerance around. That's NOT to say ALL fans display this, but it does appear to be a good ground for many of them to hide. I'm never convinced that the worst offenders are truly football fans anyway.

Your neolithic comment about Helen isn't worth airspace. Must be good to have a forehead that keeps the rain off your feet.

11

,

18/02/2007 17:29:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 380592, Article id was mapped to record!
12

billsmith1963,

19/02/2007 14:35:55

The homosexual community have done extremely well under this present government and they still find something to moan about. If they want to be accepted the first thing they will have to do is stop being homosexual.

13

Derek Williams,

Edinburgh 19/02/2007 16:30:39

#12 I guess homosexuals will stop being homosexual when Jews stop being Jewish and Blacks stop being Black. Sounds extremely straightforward - I wonder if bigots can as easily stop being bigots?

14

Kdv,

19/02/2007 17:04:35

13. Derek Williams
Would you class yourself as a right wing homosexual?
The reason I am asking is that you seem to leave have a comment, on all homosexual issues.

15

maestra,

19/02/2007 23:43:05

#13 - Yes! Great post!


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.