Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 11th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Eddie Barnes: Feelgood factor will only last if Salmond delivers real change


Notebook

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
04 May 2008
AMID all the talk of the SNP's honeymoon – which as of yesterday had extended to 12 months – was one message which appeared on BBC Online. "Honeymoons usually last for a month at the most. Well, any I have been on or witnessed anyway," said the commentator. "I think it's time the media realised this isn't a honeymoon but a successful MARRIAGE. between the SNP and Scotland."
As Alex Salmond celebrates the latest polling data, which shows he is now a thumping 14 points ahead of Labour at Holyrood, the blogger might have a point. The row over the Trump development has come and gone. Weekly opposition attacks over the "brok
en promises" on cancelling student debt or cutting class sizes trundle along like buses. And what happens? Salmond and his SNP administration just become more popular.

Another poll last week found that 53% of Scots are satisfied with Salmond's performance (compared with only 20% happy with Scottish Labour leader Wendy Alexander). Twelve short months ago there were many who doubted whether Scotland and the Nationalists would be able to so much as get through the church door before splitting up. But are we now talking about a lifelong commitment?

Certainly, when this newspaper contacted several well-known Scots for an entirely unscientific survey of opinions on the SNP a few weeks ago, an overwhelmingly positive picture emerged for Salmond. But within the eulogies there was also a warning. "I can't put a finger on it but there is a freshness of approach," said Sir Tom Farmer. "Although I can't put a finger on anything in particular… there is just a better feeling in Scotland," said artist John Byrne. "Although they haven't actually made any major changes to date, one thing they have done for the first time in many years is create a feelgood factor," added Sir Peter Burt, the former chair of ITN.

In other words, goodwill abounds towards Salmond's still fresh-faced Government. But it is, for many, a nebulous, vague type of approval. People like Salmond. They like most of his team. They like their style and the way they get out and communicate. But ask them about what they've done and they shrug their shoulders. Forth Road Bridge tolls: check. Freezing council tax: check. Anything else? Um. Not sure. Not too bothered either, though.

Given the current state of the political parties in Scotland, none of this need concern Salmond at present. Labour is still drifting. Last week, Wendy Alexander's shadow cabinet was diverted by a discussion over whether or not to vote at Holyrood on matters which didn't come under the Parliament's control, thereby once again displaying its talent for getting stuck in constitutional treacle.

Leaving this aside, Alexander is struggling to escape from under the bigger story of Labour's UK-wide collapse, courtesy of plunging poll ratings and disastrous local election results. She is in a near impossible position of being asked to turn a tide over which she can never have any control. Consequently, Salmond's pre-eminence, for the time being, looks assured.

But Salmond does appear to have realised that if the popularity of his Government is based largely on something as precarious as a vague public sense of satisfaction, he must build firmer foundations if he is to achieve lasting success. Consequently, the buzzword around Bute House at present is "delivery".

The last month has seen a blitz from the SNP on the theme. Hundreds of thousands of leaflets have been sent out to families highlighting the various initiatives introduced by the Government since last May. In a briefing last week, meanwhile, Salmond claimed that for his first year in office he had deliberately prioritised "unambiguous" changes to the country such as the council tax freeze and the cut in prescription charges. This was planned to make sure his Government got noticed.

As we report today, in the next couple of weeks, in a far more important step, Salmond will unveil his plans for public sector reform. In particular, he will replace the old target-driven, input-led style of government with a more outcome-based approach. It is a move which is designed to transform the way health, education and other public services are delivered.

This is certainly what the SNP is hoping: that despite letting us down occasionally, despite the occasional fib, we'll not bother too much because, after all, it feels natural and reassuring to have them around.

A bit like a marriage, in other words.



The full article contains 759 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 May 2008 8:11 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: SOS News columnists
 
1

Richardinho,

04/05/2008 00:28:51
The fact that WEndy Alexander is still moaning about 'broken promises' a year after everyone has probably forgotten what the election manifestos were shows that the Labour party is still intent on fighting last years election rather than living in the present. (sort of like teams complaining about goals not being allowed last season.)

The SNP's success goes beyond mere policy. It is about attitude; attitude that Scotland's best interest should always be foremost-not the UK's, not the Labour party, not Gordon Brown's.

Commentators talked about Alex Salmond picking fights with Westministers-the reality is that people like fighters! And furthermore it has been Westminster that more often than not has came looking for a fight with the Scottish parliament, to which the SNP has stood up and fought Scotland's corner.
2

a proud doonhamer,

Dumfries 04/05/2008 02:25:14
Eddie, time for the Scotsman to create a feel good scenario for the paper. It means that you will have to acti like independent journalists instead of unionist apologists and Labour controlled spin doctors.

We know you can do it... but the real question is

WILL YOU?
3

Conan the Librarian™,

04/05/2008 07:26:16
2
Will their Bowdlerising paymasters let them?
4

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 04/05/2008 09:28:06
The Nationalists have confounded everyone by doing as little as possible? It's called small government.

Prior to 1997, the Forsyth-led indigenous Tories used to bang on about "small government" in an attempt to stop the clamour for Devolution! Instead of attempting to prevent the inevitable, the Tories missed a historic lost opportunity, and are still paying a massive price in political support to this day!

Who would believe 10 years on that the indigenous Tories are 34 percentage points behind the Nationalists in this recent poll! The indigenous Tory Party has paid a terrible price for its intransigence towards Devolution, and could well remain a minority party for a generatiobn?

During 8 years of the Labour/Lib-Dem coalitions a confetti trail of legislation was produced to little effect! The statute books are cluttered with laws that few can even remember?

The Nationalists with a wafer-thin majority have produced less legislation and done much more in a short 12 months!

Like all new governments, no doubt the honeymoon will eventually come to an end but who amongst the Scots Unionist parties would bet against it!
5

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 04/05/2008 10:02:07
For me the biggest achievement of the SNP Government is to go out and promote Scotland globally as Salmond has done. Every time he does this he is opening up opportunities for Scotland that would never have existed under the old regime.

I also like his stance towards London. Is it not quite right to stand up and argue a case where you feel that Westminster is giving Scotland a raw deal? The BBC commitment to Scotland is a good example of this and I doubt that many Scots would disagree with his argument. The sad thing is that the last Executive would never have had the courage to do the same. Sadder still is that they did not even have the intelligence to realise it was happening.

I think this is the major reason for the feel-good factor currently sweeping Scotland.
6

MartinR,

Inverness 04/05/2008 14:52:40
An interesting article from Barnes, which highlights the success that Salmond and co have had to date. The bigger question will be whether they can keep the momentun, given that they'll eventually have to start making some hard choices (continuing with the unpopular Local Income Tax proposals, for example, which are unlikely to get through the Parliament; supporting a renewable energy project in the face of local NIMBYism, etc).
7

Queen D,

Glasgow 04/05/2008 16:51:19
Exactly WHO was it said "we'll do less, better"
He should have removed the comma in the first place!
8

JohnMcDonald,

London 07/05/2008 09:31:44
Crivens, journalists actually read what "bloggers" write.

Strikes me that if this was the case then Scotsman hacks would all have suffered a collective nervous breakdown. Never have I witnessed so much - well deserved - vitriol aimed at a single group as that thrown in the direction of that biased bunch of toerags.

I suppose if they actually are reading this stuff then at least we can be somewhat assured by the fact they possess a degree of literacy. Somewhat but not much...
9

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

11/05/2008 00:13:47
It's definitely a sign of the times when newspapers are leading with quotes from anonymous posters to websites. How much can the SNP actually do, anyhow, with a minority government? I think they've exceeded anyone's expectations, and hopefully The Scotsman will start covering politics on the country in a fair manner.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.