Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 29th June 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Scotland 2080: a nation hit by severe drought



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 March 2008
FROM dreich to drought in just 70 years. The most detailed-ever study of predicted rainfall and temperatures in Scotland has revealed precisely where climate change is likely to hit hardest.
Scotland's rainfall map for the period 1961-1990
Scotland's rainfall map for the period 1961-1990
The maps are the first to pinpoint future drought areas in such detail, and show that by 2080, summer rainfall in many parts of eastern Scotland will have tumbled by around 100 millimetres – one eighth of the annual average.

Particularly low-lying areas around cities and towns such as Edinburgh and Perth – which show up as deep orange on the maps – and around the Tay and Moray firths could be even more badly affected, losing up to a quarter of annual rainfall.

Such losses would mean that drinking-water reservoirs are likely to run lower for longer periods, river levels will fall, crops and trees will be more difficult to grow, and there is a greater chance of insect and disease damage.

And the projection for 2080
And the projection for 2080
Conversely, the west of Scotland is expected to get wetter for longer periods.

The maps have been produced by Forestry Research, an arm of the Forestry Commission, which will this week launch a new strategy to help combat the effects of global warming.

Researchers studied three distinct periods in Scotland to draw up a picture of how rainfall patterns might change, using data produced by the UK Government's official Climate Impacts Programme (CIP).

They found that in terms of the average summer rainfall for the period between 1961 and 1990, the amount that fell in Scotland outweighed the amount that evaporated. The more sodden country was depicted in shades of green and blue for the entire summer.

But by 2050, if rainfall declined as predicted under worst-case scenarios produced by the CIP, large sections of the east coast will experience much drier summers, and an increased frequency of these conditions, leading to drought.

On the maps, this shows up as the warmer yellow areas, indicating that evaporation was outpacing rainfall and the emergence of drought-prone areas.

The 2080 map clearly reveals the areas where rainfall has declined to such an extent that water shortages may have serious drought effects.

Duncan Ray, the forest ecologist who produced the maps, said they were an assessment of the areas that would be most prone to drought in the near future.

"In the yellow to orange areas, there will be a reduction in rainfall of around 100 millimetres over the summer period," he said.

"The reservoirs will still fill in the winter but may run lower for longer periods in the summer. The problem will come if there is very little rainfall in the winter, too.

"The very low-lying areas will get less rainfall because they are in the rainshadow of the mountains to the west. The land to the east – around the Forth, the Lothians, parts of Fife, Perthshire and the Moray Firth – may get even less.

"The implications for forestry would be that certain commonly used species – such as Sitka Spruce – might have to be replaced by more drought-resistant species.

"But there are likely to be issues with agricultural crops, too. There may be a need for more irrigation in eastern Scotland."

Ray stressed that the 2080 map was based on a worst-case scenario. "There are two things that could happen," he said. "We could go on burning fossil fuels in a business-as-usual way and then this is what may happen as a result. Or we could gradually use less fossil fuels and the scenario will not be as bad as predicted."

Climate researchers are forecasting that global warming will lead to drier summers and warmer but wetter winters, with more violent storms in Scotland.

Most scientists believe the warming is being caused by concentrations of so-called greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide (Co2), produced by the burning of fossil fuels such as coal, oil and gas, in the atmosphere.

The current concentration, which is progressively trapping heat in the Earth's atmosphere, is now higher than at any time in the past 400,000 years and levels are expected to rise through the 21st century.

The resulting rise in global temperatures has, in turn, caused changes in rainfall patterns.

On Tuesday, in Edinburgh, the Forestry Commission will launch a Climate Change Action Plan to help mitigate the effects of global warming.

The Commission, one of Scotland's biggest landowners, will outline plans to create new woodlands to help soak up Co2 emissions and to promote the use of sustainably produced wood for a renewable source of energy and construction.

High points

THE long hazy days of sunshine, space hoppers and nostalgia mean that 1976 is widely regarded as being the warmest summer ever.

But Scotland's hottest season actually took place as recently as 2003. On August 9 of that year, the mercury at Greycrook in the Borders soared to 32.9°C, beating the previous Scottish high of 32.8°C in Dumfries, which was recorded in July 1908.

Although the summer was the sunniest on record at most weather-recording stations, the freakishly hot weather lasted for most of the year.

Between April 15 and 18 2003, a heatwave occurred as an anti-cyclone over Scandinavia returned westward and warm southerly winds blew across Scotland.

The temperature reached 26.9°C at Lochcarron on the 17th, setting a new record April high.



The full article contains 899 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 March 2008 10:55 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Climate change
 
1

Sanny,

09/03/2008 00:14:29
Here we go again! another scare story in search of research funds.
2

truthsleuth,

09/03/2008 00:28:23
You may be right Sanny but if you really held the courage of your convictions you would give them the money to prove it was just that - a scare story.
Of course you like other deniers cannot accept the mounting evidence that the threat of accelerated climate change and its effects are mounting almost day by day.
Still I suppose with your eyes shut, your ears plugged and your brain out of gear you probably will not notice it.
3

TiminPhoenix,

Phoenix, Arizona 09/03/2008 01:14:56
Truthsleuth, makes me laugh. You talk about courage of convictions, but it's your side that tries to shut down debate.

Your use of the pejorative, Denier, is such a tactic.

Your High Priest, Al Gore, says the debate is over. Nevermind the many actual climate scientists that say Global Warming is a joke.

And as to mounting evidence, what is it? There is as much that argues against it now than argues for it. But that doesn't suit those of you leftists, and that's what 99% of the Global Warming crowd is. No, you want to use this false science, where those who disagree are ridiculed as Deniers (a term linked on purpose to the vile Holocaust Deniers) for other social actions, i.e. more government control.

It's your who has every orifice plugged.
4

Jock MacSprog,

09/03/2008 01:24:59
having spent most of my life in this country damp, please god please make this story be true. And the sooner the better !
5

thewitness,

09/03/2008 01:30:13
Global warming = High level political con-job.
6

tomi,

09/03/2008 02:40:19
Tell me another fairy story!!

But these modern "fairy stories" don't begin with "Once upon a time" but with "In the future" and don"t end with "happily ever after" but with gloom and doom. What nonsence they are, and non-science too!
7

bill inch,

EDINBURGH 09/03/2008 03:13:17
Truthsluith. You are being propogandised with the arrogance of your (Fed SH*t think mushroom reiteratate comments
8

Tatties ower the side,

Johannesburg 09/03/2008 04:49:43
Editor: Jeremy, away you and write a story about Global warming.
Jeremy: But, whit will I write aboot? The Climate Impacts Programme report only shows bad results in the "worst case scenario"
Editor: Then focus on that and ignore the rest of the report! Oor readers dinnae want to hear good news!


But by 2050, if rainfall declined as predicted under worst-case scenarios.....
9

Greenheatman,

TAIN 09/03/2008 06:54:14
Let's pepper Scotland with thousands of windturbines - that should do the trick - not!

.........oh, just noticed that we are already doing that and carbon emissions are going up, not down.

The long term solution is to build renewable energy desalination plant any time soon to counter the drought conditions that already occur in Scotland every Summer. (Not unknown in Fort William and Shetland)
10

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 09/03/2008 06:58:16
Where can one emigrate to where things will be better?
11

eric,

Lothian 09/03/2008 07:48:21
What no Buckfast for Neds in Edinburgh
12

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 09/03/2008 08:19:36
Encarta #6,

The city of Mackay on Queenslands central coast had 20inches in 24hrs a couple of weeks back and down here about 12 days ago we had 2inches in 15min, so, you'd be wasting your time coming here
13

,

09/03/2008 08:53:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 09/03/2008 08:57:47
This stuff is rubbish of the highest order. The average rainfall across the UK is more than a metre of rain for every square metre of land; that's a metric tonne of water for ever single square metre you can see around you. The area of East Lothian around Dunbar receives less than 22" (about 200mm) of rain a year, which makes it ideal for the seed potato industry. I haven;t noticed any dying crops or thirsty people around East Lothian.
These clowns in the Forestry Commission could not even predict what kind of trees to plant for the last 50- years and covered Scotland in useless Sitka Spruce, which is almost valueless due to a Chinese and world surplus of pulp-trees. Unbelievable statements like:

"
"The very low-lying areas will get less rainfall because they are in the rainshadow of the mountains to the west."

Oh really? I suppose these mountains did not cast a rainshadow for the past million years?

The Forestry Commission has received £billions of taxpayers cash since after WWI and the end result is we have virtually no hardwoods in this country and the landscape has been covered in ugly, alien sitka spruce that is useless for timber and valueless for pulp. This quango should be would up and its money given back to the taxpayer.
15

It's me!,

09/03/2008 09:15:38
Scare! Scare! Scare! If they are so good at forecasting the future how come they can't forecast six numbers correctly for a saturday night? At one time in this country the only scare story was that if you didn't behave you wouldn't go to heaven. Now it is several scare stories a day. When will these mental terrorists shut up and give us peace? We don't believe you! T
16

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 09/03/2008 09:23:11
Exactly what form of equestrian poo is this article to alert flys to ?

However the unpredictability of the Jet-stream renders such speculation useless.

Garbage. Fafometer?
17

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 09:23:31
Rainfall has definitely increased in the last 20 years.

I have not had to use the water sprinkler on the lawn for at least 15 years.
18

yockel,

09/03/2008 09:27:35
I suppose adaptation would be out of the question.
19

Chris W,

Argyll 09/03/2008 09:33:31
This is such a load of rubbish. They can't even tell us accurately what the weather will be like next month, let alone in 2080. Anyone who beleives this scaremongering claptrap was born yesterday.
20

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 09:36:07
This report came out two months ago:

http://www.forestresearch.gov.uk/pdf/scottish_climate_change_final_report.pdf/$FILE/scottish_climate_change_final_report.pdf
21

Alan Reid,

NZ 09/03/2008 09:47:37
TiminPhoenix,Phoenix, Arizona,
Have a look at the following, and anyone else that are "Deniers"
Maybe just maybe it will chance your mind, but I doubt it.

http://www.durangobill.com/Swindle_Swindle.html

22

Unimpressed one,

09/03/2008 09:48:28
#1, "Here we go again! another scare story in search of research funds."

Think you might find we're too late - the money's already been spent. Pure green pi*sh supported by taxpayers.
23

drew 33,

duddingston 09/03/2008 09:52:13
Full marks to the people of Scotland for their heroic determination, grit, stoicism and fortitude in the face of this impending environmental disaster. The Dunkirk spirit is truly alive and well in Scotland. I hope the rain forecast for this evening arrives!
24

Gothic Rose,

09/03/2008 10:07:47
I`ll not be on the planet,so don`t care!
25

Jimmy the Pie,

09/03/2008 10:24:42
Might happen if New Labour Sleaze and Corruption flog off the water company and Engerland need the water! ;)
26

Klaus Dubois,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 10:27:32
Anyone remember how the science of MMR immunisation jabs was hijacked for media gain & political capital ?
Proper science always results from peer review & debate among the informed; it's not best served by political interpetation. Findings should be challenged & tested.
Many now see global warming as another symptom of over population.
27

sceptic,

09/03/2008 10:32:18
It won't matter how much rain falls. Scotland is going to be an icy frozen wasteland, possibly within five years.
Oops! that was last year's environmental disaster in search of more taxpayer's funding.
28

David MacVicar,

web 09/03/2008 10:32:24
On the 2080 map it is more humid in the West than it is even now (and in Kintye in the last two weeks it has been abysmal)!

Headline could be:

Nation hit by severe precipitation in the west forcing migration towards the Sunny East!
29

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 10:36:30
The maps actually show 'moisture deficit' which is not quite the same thing as 'rainfall'.
30

Conan the Librarian™,

09/03/2008 10:40:25
So the days of Scottish vineyards are coming.

What would be a good name for Scots wines?
A Clydeside Red? Shiraz ya Baz? Oan a Mission?
31

Mcsnagpile,

09/03/2008 10:48:43
The privatised foreign companies will have shipped the water somewhere else long before the drought. The Scottish whiskies will be changed to the
Central African Whisky and Palm Wine Co. The Scots will have to retire to the giant caves under the North Sea where the oil used to be.
Mean while I will have to go for a sail round the garden on the tool shed.
32

Gothic Rose,

09/03/2008 10:52:11
32# What are you going to use for oars,Fork and Rake?:)
33

Hunky Dorey,

Glesga. 09/03/2008 11:24:14
Wi the extra duty aboot tae be poot own the whisky,am no a bit surprised. BURP!
34

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 09/03/2008 11:33:41
Hopefully there will be enough water - imported or domestic - to make Scotch whiskey so all living at the time can forget their plight in many wee drams of that elixir of life.
35

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 09/03/2008 11:35:40
Should have read "whisky" instead of "whiskey" which is Irish.

Hope nobody is offended by my misspelling.
36

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 09/03/2008 11:43:22
Thanks to #22 Alan Reid for the link to the Bill Butler demolition of the fraudulent C4 Climate Swindle programme made by disinformer Martin Durkin and featuring several other disinformers. It is well worth a read, but it is clear that there are still a large number of folk in the “Don’t bother me with the facts - I’ve already made up my mind” camp, who wouldn't dare to read it.

Thanks also to #21 Fred Bloggs for finding the Forestry Commission report upon which the above article was based.

The above maps show what is expected with the "business as usual" scenario. Clearly, if most of the above respondents get their way then that is the future to which we are most probably heading.
37

Gothic Rose,

09/03/2008 12:00:15
36#TimW.

Of course we`re not,We know your limitations.:)
38

WJohn,

Linlithgow 09/03/2008 13:00:45
Never mind, it could be worse. SE England will have sunk beneath the waves and all those affluent English will have bought up all the but-and-bens as haciendas.
Employment in Scotland will boom with the increased need for servants - sorry property-maintenance-engineers, caddies, and personal dietitians.
39

Guga II,

Rockall 09/03/2008 13:20:16
Where is all this global warming? We badly need some of it up here.

If this rubbish was true, it would be a simple matter to pipe excess water from the west to the east of the country.

Why is Mars warming up at the same rate as the Earth? Is it because of all the 4x4's on Mars?

#39 I was hoping they'd all have bought their haciendas in France.
40

Alexander,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 13:33:46
Absolutely brilliant piece of sub "O" level statistical analysis by Forestry Research. Conforms with the First Law of the statistical charlatan, first draw your conclusions then choose the chronology to deliver the required result.
This post has been reviewed by 10 of my peers(all science/engineering graduates) with over 90% in agreement. Seven agreed fully, one wasn't sure and two disagreed. In the best IPCC tradition I decided that the two who disagreed were excluded as they were known to frequently take a contrary view.
41

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 09/03/2008 14:42:04
#38 Gothic Rose

CAD - ESSE! :))
42

dido-bendigo,

Sunny West Argyll (Above the clouds!) 09/03/2008 14:58:47
If this is a 'worst case' prediction, could the reporter publish what is the 'best case' prediction please? Can we then come to the conclusion that the actual result will probably be halfway between the two? So things may well be about the same as they are now? Where can I apply for a job with the Forestry Commission's Climate Change Study Group? Do SEPA and SNH also employ climatologists?
43

Jacqueline Hyde ,

09/03/2008 15:13:42
First we're told that the low-lying areas were going to be under water by 2080; now they are going to be in the grip of drought!

Surely it's time to put these "experts" back in the asylum and get on with our lives.
44

Gothic Rose,

09/03/2008 15:15:54
42 Timw.
No I`m Not.I`m lovely:)
45

Breezy,

Argyll 09/03/2008 15:23:23
''Conversely, the West of Scotland is expected to get wetter for longer periods.''
Impossible mate, absolutely impossible. Unless they're going to add more hours on to the day !
46

Queen D,

Glasgow 09/03/2008 15:26:51
I read in the Times that the world is experiencing strange weather of the freezing , snowing variety.
So waterlogged , drought or new ice age Which?
I really am beginning to think we have some very loopy people in the climate change lobby , or could that be people with financial rewards in view?
47

Teemackell the Scribe,

09/03/2008 15:29:22
On the page above there is a dynamic frame that occasionally reads "Click here to participate in the deception." At first I took this to be an invitation to contribute to the Forestry Research findings. On closer inspection it's an invitation to consider merits of Lexus cars:"appearances can be deceiving."

It strikes me that the auto company and the research body have something in common: each is trying to sell us something. I place a higher trust in Lexus.
48

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 09/03/2008 16:14:03
Wondered why Reporting Scotland do not issue forecasts for more than 3 days ahead?

However our forest ecologist is confidently predicting "around 100mm" reduction in rainfall over the next 70 odd years.

So the outcome is a Climate Change Action Plan by the Forestry Commission which is expected to include planting trees. Eh? You could not make this up. Is that not what they're supposed to do regardless of climate change?! But the research and Plan and committees and publications will cost you and me the taxpayer a considerable pile of money which of course has to be generated from economic activity, which in itself inevitably involves production of further CO2 and blah, blah....

49

Foulkes Off the CyberNat,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 16:29:41
Hud on I thought the polar ice caps were melting and we were all going to evolve with gills and live under water.
Can these b*ggers no make their minds up?
50

Kenny A,

09/03/2008 16:36:53
Just ordered up an Asbestos coated 4x4 Camel with gills.
51

Sambo,

The deep south 09/03/2008 17:11:16
More piffle from the scaremongers. The grant money must be drying up.
52

Sambo,

The deep south 09/03/2008 17:15:23
This is a scam perpetrated by cheuchters to sell lots in the highlands.
53

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 09/03/2008 18:59:51
Contrary to what this report indicates, the maps were produced by the Met Office Rainfall and Evaporation and Calculation System (MORECS).
54

Van (not white) Diesel,

Amsterdam & Augsburg 09/03/2008 19:19:18
#40 Guga II
You need to move house pdq, matey, as your little rock is about to become submerged. Whoops. Just changed my mind. It is about to poke out of the sea. You'll soon be planting trees.

#46 Breezy
Superb

#53 Sambo
... to sell lots of what? :-)
55

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 09/03/2008 19:40:53
45 Gothic Rose

Sez hoo?
56

Gothic Rose,

09/03/2008 20:22:02
56# TimW.
Thats for me to know and you to find out.
57

Gothic Rose,

09/03/2008 20:22:21
Smug EH.!!!
58

9/11 was an inside job,

09/03/2008 20:30:05
USA PATRIOT ACT
UK Civil Contingencies Act 2004
Hitler's Enabling Act 1933
59

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:01:25
A High Court judge who ruled on whether climate change film, An Inconvenient Truth, could be shown in schools said it contains nine scientific "errors".


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/education/7037671.stm
60

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:02:12
Mr Gore's assertion that a sea-level rise of up to 20 feet would be caused by melting of ice in either West Antarctica or Greenland "in the near future". The judge said this was "distinctly alarmist" and it was common ground that if Greenland's ice melted it would release this amount of water - "but only after, and over, millennia".
61

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:02:41
Mr Gore's assertion that the disappearance of snow on Mount Kilimanjaro in East Africa was expressly attributable to global warming - the court heard the scientific consensus was that it cannot be established the snow recession is mainly attributable to human-induced climate change.
62

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:03:19
Mr Gore's reference to a new scientific study showing that, for the first time, polar bears had actually drowned "swimming long distances - up to 60 miles - to find the ice". The judge said: "The only scientific study that either side before me can find is one which indicates that four polar bears have recently been found drowned because of a storm."
63

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:05:20
Gore: Low-lying inhabited Pacific atolls are already “being inundated because of anthropogenic global warming.”

Judge: There was no evidence of any evacuation having yet happened.
64

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:05:45
Gore: The documentary described global warming potentially “shutting down the Ocean Conveyor” - the process by which the Gulf Stream is carried over the North Atlantic to western Europe.

Judge: According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), it was “very unlikely” it would be shut down, though it might slow down.
65

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:06:23
Gore: He asserted - by ridiculing the opposite view - that two graphs, one plotting a rise in C02 and the other the rise in temperature over a period of 650,000 years, showed “an exact fit”.

Judge: Although there was general scientific agreement that there was a connection, “the two graphs do not establish what Mr Gore asserts”.
66

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:07:04
Gore: The drying up of Lake Chad was used in the film as a prime example of a catastrophic result of global warming, said the judge.

Judge: “It is generally accepted that the evidence remains insufficient to establish such an attribution. It is apparently considered to be far more likely to result from other factors, such as population increase and over-grazing, and regional climate variability.”
67

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:07:35
Gore: Hurricane Katrina and the consequent devastation in New Orleans to global warming.

Judge: There is “insufficient evidence to show that”.
68

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:08:20
Gore: Coral reefs all over the world were bleaching because of global warming and other factors.

Judge: The IPCC had reported that, if temperatures were to rise by 1-3 degrees centigrade, there would be increased coral bleaching and mortality, unless the coral could adapt. But separating the impacts of stresses due to climate change from other stresses, such as over-fishing, and pollution was difficult.
69

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:16:12
Gore says that in each of the last four interglacial warm periods it was changes in carbon dioxide concentration that caused changes in temperature. It was the other way about. Changes in temperature preceded changes in CO2 concentration by between 800 and 2800 years, as scientific papers including the paper on which Gore’s film had relied had made clear.

Ms. Kreider says it is true that “greenhouse gas levels and temperature changes in the ice signals have a complicated relationship but they do fit.” This does not address Gore’s error at all. The judge found that Gore had very clearly implied that it was changes in carbon dioxide concentration that had led to changes in temperature in the palaeoclimate, when the scientific literature is unanimous (save only for a single paper by James Hansen, whom Gore trusts) to the effect that the relationship was in fact the other way about, with a carbon dioxide feedback contributing only a comparatively insignificant further increase to temperature after the temperature change had itself initiated a change in carbon dioxide concentration.

The significance of this error was explained during the court proceedings, and was accepted by the judge. Gore says that the 100 ppmv difference between carbon dioxide concentrations during ice-age temperature minima and interglacial temperature maxima represents “the difference between a nice day and a mile of ice above your head.” This would imply a CO2 effect on temperature about 10 times greater than that regarded as plausible by the consensus of mainstream scientific opinion (see Error 10).

Ms. Kreider refers readers to a “more complete description” available at a website maintained by, among others, two of the three authors of the now-discredited “hockey stick” graph that falsely attempted to abolish the Mediaeval Warm Period. The National Academy of Sciences in the US had found that graph to have “a validation skill not significantly different from zero” – i.e., the graph wa
70

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:17:51
Gore says scientists had been giving warnings that hurricanes will get stronger because of “global warming.” They will not. Over the past 60 years there has been no change in the strength of hurricanes, even though hydrocarbon use went up six-fold in the same period. Research by Dr. Kerry Emanuel, cited by Ms. Kreider, has been discredited by more recent findings that wind-shear effects tend to nullify the amplification of hurricane strength which he had suggested, and, of course, by the observed failure of hurricanes to gain strength during the past 60 years of “global warming.”



71

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:18:33
Gore says insurance losses arising from large storms and other extreme-weather events are increasing, by implication because of “global warming.” They are not. Insured losses, as a percentage of the population of coastal areas in the path of hurricanes, were lower even in 2005 than they had been in 1925. In 2006, a very quiet hurricane season, Lloyds of London posted their biggest-ever profit: £3.6 billion.
72

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:19:11
Gore says flooding in Mumbai is increasing, by implication because of “global warming.” It is not. Rainfall trends at the two major weather stations in Mumbai show no increase in heavy rainfall over the past 48 years.
73

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:19:45
Gore says that 2004 set an all-time record for tornadoes in the US. More tornadoes are being reported because detection systems are better than they were. But the number of severe tornadoes has been falling for more than 50 years.
74

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:20:54
Gore says the Arctic has been warming faster than the rest of the planet. It is not. While it is in general true that during periods of warming (whether natural or anthropogenic) the Arctic will warm faster than other regions, Gore does not mention that the Arctic has been cooling over the past 60 years, and is now one degree Celsius cooler than it was in the 1940s. There was a record amount of snow cover in the Northern Hemisphere in 2001. Several vessels were icebound in the Arctic in the spring of 2007, but few newspapers reported this. The newspapers reported that the North-West Passage was free of ice in 2007, and said that this was for the first time since records began: but the records, taken by satellites, had only begun 29 years previously. The North-West Passage had also been open for shipping in 1945, and, in 1903, the great Norwegian explorer Amundsen had passed through it in a sailing ship.
75

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:22:15
Gore says “global warming” is making the Greenland ice sheet unstable. It is not. Greenland ice grows 2in a year. The Greenland ice sheet survived each of the previous three interglacial periods, each of which was 5 degrees Celsius warmer than the present. It survived atmospheric CO2 concentrations of up to 1000 ppmv (compared with today’s 400 ppmv). It last melted 850,000 years ago, when humankind did not exist and could not have caused the melting. There is a close correlation between variations in Solar activity and temperature anomalies in Greenland, but there is no correlation between variations in CO2 concentration and temperature changes in Greenland. The IPCC (2001) says that to melt even half the Greenland ice sheet would require temperature to rise by 5.5 degrees C and remain that high for several thousand years.
76

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:22:49
Gore says 40% of the world’s population get their water supply from Himalayan glacial melt waters that are failing because of “global warming.” They don’t and they are not. The water comes almost entirely from snow-melt, not from ice-melt. Over the past 40 years there has been no decline in the amount of snow-melt in Eurasia.
77

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:23:28
Gore says that a Peruvian glacier is less extensive now than it was in the 1940s, implying that “global warming” is the cause. It is not. Except for the very highest peaks, the normal state of the Peruvian cordilleras has been ice-free throughout most of the past 10,000 years.
78

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:24:14
Gore says that “the ice has a story to tell, and it is worldwide.” He shows several before-and-after pictures of glaciers disappearing. However, the glacial melt began in the 1820s, long before humankind could have had any effect, and has continued at a uniform rate since, showing no acceleration since humankind began increasing the quantity of CO2 in the atmosphere. Total ice volumes in three of the last four Ice Ages were lower than they are today, and “global warming” had nothing to do with that.
79

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:25:12
Gore says terrible tragedies are occurring in the southern Sahara because of drought which he blames on “global warming.” There is no drought caused by “global warming.” In 2007 there were record rains across the whole of the southern Sahara. In the past 25 years the Sahara has shrunk by some 300,000 square kilometers because of additional rainfall. Some scientists think “global warming” may actually mitigate pre-existing droughts because there will be more water vapor in the atmosphere. Before 1200 AD there were frequent, prolonged and severe droughts in the Great Plains. Since 1200 AD, there has been more rainfall. Likewise, the US has had more rainfall since the 1950s than it had in the earlier part of the 20th Century, when the great droughts which were then common were described by John Steinbeck in The Grapes of Wrath. South African rainfall was also more stable in the second half of the 20th Century, when human effect on climate is said to have become significant, than in the first half
80

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:26:00
Gore says disturbing changes have been measured under the West Antarctic ice sheet, implicitly because of “global warming.” Yet most of the recession in this ice sheet over the past 10,000 years has occurred in the absence of any sea-level or temperature forcing. In most of Antarctica, the ice is in fact growing thicker. Mean Antarctic temperature has actually fallen throughout the past half-century. In some Antarctic glens, environmental damage has been caused by temperature decreases of up to 2 degrees Celsius. Antarctic sea-ice spread to a 30-year record extent in late 2007.
81

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:26:44
Gore says half a dozen ice shelves each “larger than Rhode Island” have broken up and vanished from the Antarctic Peninsula recently, implicitly because of “global warming.” Global warming is unlikely to have been the cause. Gore does not explain that the ice shelves have melted before, as studies of seabed sediments have shown. The Antarctic Peninsula accounts for about 2% of the continent, in most of which the ice is growing thicker. All the recently-melted shelves, added together, amount to an area less than one-fifty-fifth the size of Texas.

82

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:28:05
Gore says that, as well as malaria, “global warming” is spreading dengue fever, Lyme disease, West Nile virus, arena virus, avian flu, Ebola virus, E. Coli 0157:H7, Hanta virus, legionella, leptospirosis, multi-drug-resistant TB, Nipah virus, SARS and Vibrio Cholerae 0139. It is doing no such thing. Only the first four diseases are insect-borne, but none is tropical. Of the other diseases named by Gore either in his film or in the accompanying book, not one is sensitive to increasing temperature. They are spread not by warmer weather but by rats, chickens, primates, pigs, poor hygiene, ill-maintained air conditioning, or cold weather.
83

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:28:54
Gore describes carbon dioxide as “global warming pollution.” It is not. It is food for plants and trees. Tests have shown that even at concentrations 30 times those of the present day even the most delicate plants flourish. Well-managed forests, such as those of the United States, are growing at record rates because the extra carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is feeding the trees. Carbon dioxide, in geological timescale, is at a very low concentration at present. Half a billion years ago it was at 7000 parts per million by volume, about 18 times today’s concentration.
84

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:30:23
In the book accompanying Gore’s film, the story of the pied flycatchers and the caterpillars is accompanied by a picture of a bird feeding her hungry chicks. However, closer inspection shows that the bird is not a pied flycatcher but a black tern; and that she is not carrying a caterpillar in her beak, but a small fish. Gore similarly misuses spectacular footage of a glacier apparently calving off enormous slabs of ice into the sea – footage that is often shown on television to accompany stories about “global warming.” However, the glacier in question is one that is known to be advancing – and to be doing so more rapidly and more often than previously. It is in southern Argentina, where its snout crosses – and eventually dams, Lake Argentino. Water builds up behind the ice dam and eventually bursts it, causing the spectacular collapse of ice into the lake that is so misleadingly used as the iconic image of the effect of “global warming” on glaciers. The breaking of the ice dam used to occur every eight years or so: now, however, it occurs every five years, not because of “global warming” because of the regional cooling of the southern Atlantic.
85

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:31:11
Gore says that rising sea levels are compelling the operators of the Thames Barrier to close it more frequently than when it was first built. They are not. The barrier is indeed closed more frequently than when it was built, but the reason has nothing to do with “global warming” or rising sea levels. The reason is a change of policy by which the barrier is closed during exceptionally low tides, so as to retain water in the tidal Thames rather than keeping it out. Yet even the present leader of the official Opposition in the UK Parliament recently used a major speech as the opportunity to mention today’s more frequent closing of the Thames Barrier as though it were a matter of grave concern.
86

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:31:49
Gore says that his prediction that the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide will rise to more than 600 parts per million by volume as soon as 2050 is “not controversial in any way or in dispute by anybody.” However, not one of the half-dozen official projections of growth in CO2 concentration made by the IPCC shows as much as 600 parts per million by 2050.
87

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:32:50
Conclusion

35 serious scientific errors




As many as 35 serious scientific errors or exaggerations, all pointing towards invention of a threat that does not exist at all, or exaggerations of phenomena that do exist, do not reflect credit on the presenter of the movie or on those who advised him. The movie is unsuitable for showing to children, and provides no basis for taking policy decisions. Schools that have shown the movie to children are urged to ensure that the errors listed in this memorandum are drawn to the children’s attention.
88

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:33:52
[1] For a detailed discussion, see (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_originals/current_issues_in_climate_science_focus....html) and also (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_reprint_series/the_role_of_greenland_in_sea_level_rise....html)



[1] See (http://www.ff.org/centers/csspp/pdf/20060331_issues.pdf)



[1] See: (http://ff.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=336&Itemid=77)



[1] See discussion at: (http://www.ff.org/centers/csspp/pdf/Kiliman-MAC-4-8-04.pdf)



[1] For a serioius examination of this issue, see (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_reprint_series/polar_bears_of_western_hudson_bay_and....html)



[1] Are Coral Reefs Endangered by Global Warming? (http://ff.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=382&Itemid=77)



[1] For a discussion of future hurricane trends for Florida, see: (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_originals/current_issues_in_climate_science_focus_on....html)



[1] For an in depth look at these issues, see (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/originals/hurricanethreat.html)



[1] For a discussion of the sun’s role in climate, see (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_originals/the_unruly_sunne_cannot_be_ruled_out_as_a_cause....html)



[1] See: (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_originals/current_issues_in_climate_science_focus...html)



[1] For fuller discussion of Polar regions and Greenland, see: (http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/sppi_originals/current_issues_in_climate_science_focus_on_the_poles.html)



[1] Discussion by world-class expert and IPCC reviewer: (http://ff.org/centers/csspp/pdf/reiter-climate-change-mbd.pdf)

89

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:35:56
Gore the Bore you are named and shamed.

Is it any wonder people have trouble taking on board what the Eco Fascists are wanting us to with stuff like Gores crap being shown to kids. Scaremongering he should be publicly thrashed for it.
90

A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND ;o)),

09/03/2008 22:36:31
http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/monckton/goreerrors.html
91

Conan the Librarian™,

09/03/2008 23:22:27
91
31 posts in a row.A record?
92

Frodo the Scot,

ootside lookin in 10/03/2008 00:34:42
#90.. A VOICE FROM SCOTLAND....Excellant comments Sir Did you know that Mr Parasite gore's electricity bill exceeds 30000 dollars A MONTH....THATS 30 THOUSAND He and wife Tipsy keep the A/C cooling their butts and 30 room mansion at a cool 62 degrees.
93

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 10/03/2008 08:38:07
ABOVE: A RAUCOUS VOICE FROM THE FOSSIL FUEL INDUSTRY.
94

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 10/03/2008 08:49:51
95 clarry

You really must get a life. Keeping track of my spelling mis-strokes has got to be the most boring thing in the world to do. All of us on these forums make them because there is no spellcheck here.

My loyal band of resident proofreaders are otherwise involved and not available for duty.

So sorry. so VERY sorry to have offended your delicate sensibilities.
95

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 10/03/2008 09:30:13
From the report:

'In the last 40 years, a 1.00C increase has occurred in the annual mean minimum daily temperature in all parts of the country, with the biggest increases in eastern Scotland.'
96

Neanderthal75,

Rocky Mountains USA 10/03/2008 10:27:02