Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Mather rules out direct action on public sector jobs



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 May 2008
JIM Mather, the enterprise minister, has ruled out direct Government action to shrink Scotland's oversized public sector, despite claims that it is a drain on the economy.
In a move likely to disappoint business groups that have been calling for a large scale transfer of jobs from the public to private sector, Mather says the Government will not intervene directly to reduce the size of the state sector, which accounts
for 23% of all Scottish jobs.

Groups including the Institute of Directors (IoD) in Scotland argue that the size of the sector is inhibiting long-term economic growth and want the Government to take active steps to ensure that more jobs are transferred to the "wealth creating" private sector.

But Mather told a gathering of business leaders in Edinburgh last week that the Government thinks the process should only happen "organically rather than imposing it from the top and getting a whole raft of unintended consequences".

While recognising that the size of the public sector is a problem, he indicated that Alex Salmond's Government is unlikely to take any steps to resolve the situation.

Instead, he argued, the Government is more interested in measures to help grow private enterprise. To that end, he is in discussions with the Irish Consul General for Scotland about the potential for collaboration between Irish and Scottish businesses.

David Watt, director of the IoD in Scotland, said the Government's approach was "astonishing". He said the SNP Government would be unable to meet its target of matching the UK growth rate by 2011 unless it was prepared to take bold action to remove the economic burden of Scotland's large number of public sector employees.

"They can't do that unless they get the workforce into the private sector and into wealth creation. It's astonishing to hear that they're letting that just happen.

"Surely they should be taking a lead on that? The private sector for quite a long time has almost unanimously felt that the public sector is too big and it's a drain on the economy."

The IoD warned that Scotland, with its ageing and declining population, will not have enough manpower in future to expand.

"We have a population challenge that people don't seem to face up to at all in terms of demography and age," said Watt.

However, a poll in The Scotsman last week showed that, overall, the SNP has impressed the Scottish business community since it came to power 12 months ago.





The full article contains 419 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 May 2008 8:22 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

The Answer,

Glasgow 03/05/2008 23:07:49
580,000 public sector jobs in scotsland (99% filled by white scots)

480,000 public sector jobs in Yorkshire and The Humber (which has a larger population than scotsland)

4.8 million public sector jobs in England (with 11% filled by "ethnics")

23.5% scotsland workforce in public sector.
19.6% Yorkshire and the Humber in public sector.
19.0% of England's worforce in the public sector.
2

AstroNought,

edinburgh 04/05/2008 11:20:07
The problem here is that these lemming public sector workers are exactly the ones that voted the SNP in.
3

Hamilton,

04/05/2008 11:27:22
The Scottish Government will be unable to match UK growth unless it reduces the spending on public services. Matching the UK growth is Scotland's ultimate ambition?

On the UK growth rate. "The [UK] Government's forecasts for the economy are looking increasingly "foolish" and its key fiscal rules are about to be broken, according to some of the most respected independent observers of the scene", said the Independent last month.

The developed world has a huge problem adjusting to globalisation, not only the UK and Scotland. Globalisation increases equality worldwide, but increases inequality nationally. This is politically unsustainable especially in the developed world, as the presidential campaign in the United States is showing.

How ambitious is Scotland?
4

Chris Cook,

Linlithgow 04/05/2008 16:14:50
"They can't do that unless they get the workforce into the private sector and into wealth creation. It's astonishing to hear that they're letting that just happen."

I pay £20.00 a year to the Council to have my bin emptied and the bin-man gets £10.00. This is a "burden" and creates no "wealth". Although I do get my bin emptied.

I pay £20.00 a year to a private contractor: the bin man gets £5.00, the shareholders £5.00 and I pay another £5.00 in taxes to give the bin-man the £10.00 he needs to survive.

This is "wealth creation".

I guess that comes down to definitions: of "wealth", "public" and "private".

When we say "Private" we mean "owned by a "For Profit" Limited Company"....and by "Wealth" we mean the profits generated by such a Company.

So BY DEFINITION the "Public Sector" cannot create "Wealth". The economic "Value" I receive in having my bins emptied is quite another matter.

Orwell's 1984 NewSpeak comes to mind.

But as the City of Glasgow is now demonstrating with a series of Limited Liability Partnerships ("LLP's") with private sector service providers the good old "cost-cutting" "shareholder value" creating Corporation is no longer the only game in town.

It is in fact possible to provide services on a "Not For Loss" basis, without unnecessary returns to "rentier" shareholders.

I'm all for Capitalism - Productive Capitalism - without an entirely unnecessary overlay of Finance Capital.



5

Paddi,

04/05/2008 20:31:29
#4 What you forgot to mention is that the council use 4 bin men and the private sector company use 2 and guess what? the private sector bin men empty more bins. Why? because everyone is motivated and incentivised to do the job efficiently. At the council the only motivation is to have more and more ancillary workers helping the 4 bin men.

One way is economically efficient the other is not. Introduce completion and you get efficiency. No completion and you end up with double the bin men.

Bloated councils are no more than client states for SNL, the quid pro quo is you vote for us and we’ll make sure you keep you inefficient, wasteful non productive jobs.
Russia circa 1955.

No thanks

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.