Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 11th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

'I love the Black Watch bagpipe music, but it makes me cry when I hear it'


Mother dreads New Year her son will never see as victim of war in Iraq

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 December 2007
THE call came at 4.30am. Carol Paterson opened the door to two men who said her son was dead, killed in a bomb attack while on patrol in Basra. At first, Carol thought she was dreaming. Then she prayed over and over again that it wasn't true.
Six months on, Carol is dreading the New Year her son will never see. She locks herself away and listens to her favourite music.

"I love the Black Watch bagpipe music, but it makes me cry when I hear it," she said. "I focus on the music, on that a
nd keeping the house and the garden nice.

"I planted a rose in the garden there for Scott, and it was beautiful. It came out as orange roses."

Private Scott Kennedy, Black Watch, 3rd Battalion, The Royal Regiment of Scotland, was 20 when he died, yet another coalition soldier killed by a roadside bomb. Private James Kerr, also 20, from Cowdenbeath, and Corporal Paul Joszko, 28, from Mountain Ash, Wales, died in the same attack last June.

The incident was the deadliest in a year in Iraq which saw the deaths of more than 40 other UK troops. The combined death toll for operations in Afghanistan and Iraq since 2001 recently passed 250. Many military families are dreading the midnight bells.

Carol remembers the last time she spoke to her son, a few weeks before he died. "It was in Kuwait, just before he went into Iraq," she said. "It lasted 40 minutes. He was more bothered about the heat than about anything else. I was telling him to make sure that he was drinking plenty of water, and he said he would."

Carol is in her 50s, slim, with short, greying hair. She works as a lollipop lady and has been involved for years in helping to run local youth organisations. Her two-storey house in Oakley, near Dunfermline, is neat with a TV in one corner and a computer in the other. Despite her tragic loss, she managed to put up a few, modest Christmas decorations.

"Since what happened, the whole Christmas and New Year hasn't really sunk in," she said.

"We always used to love Christmas and this time of year, but that's changed for me. I'm not looking forward to the New Year. In fact my mother died on the December 31 of last year, so there's that too. There's none of us in the family contemplating anything for the New Year."

Scott, the youngest of three brothers, came from a family with a forces tradition. Both of his grandfathers had been in the army and Scott decided early he would follow in their footsteps.

Carol said: "It wasn't a surprise at all when he said that he was heading into the army. It had always been there. He was always interested in that and he didn't like school. He couldn't wait to leave school and join the army. He was clever, but he didn't like school at all.

"He would watch all the shows on Sky and the Discovery Channel about it. He loved his fitness. He always liked jogging; rain or snow, he always did it. And then he was working on his exercises in the house, he was doing these chin-ups, and at first he couldn't even do one, but then he persevered and worked on it.

"I have never seen a man who could iron or polish shoes like he could. Even before he was in the army. And his ironing, I remember him ironing his brother's trousers, and everyone was commenting about the beautiful crease he put in them."

Alongside the fitness and discipline, Carol said her son had a kind side to his character. "He was very close friends with a blind boy who lives nearby," she said. "Scott was always helping him with things. They had exactly the same sense of humour, they loved the funny DVDs, especially Lee Evans and Peter Kay. You would hear their laughter all over the house.

"There was nothing he wouldn't do. He would help around the house and do everything without being asked. He was very kind. That's the way I brought him up."

One of Carol's favourite memories was at the infantry training base at Catterick, North Yorkshire. "I sat right at the front and saw him on parade," she said. "It was a wonderful day. I was so proud of him. He was very proud of being in the army. He would get in his combats and practise drill with a brush."

She added: "His nickname was Casper. That came from one of these weekends where they could go away with the Black Watch. When they were doing their practice in an empty building, they flung a bag of flour in and Scott was covered in it and he came out all white. White as a ghost, just like the cartoon character.

"I always said he was my special one, because he had done something none of the others had done: he had gone into the army and decided to do something."

Scott joined the army at a time when it was almost certain he would become an active participant in the war on terror. So when Carol heard he was going to Iraq, she wasn't shocked. "Was I worried? Like everything else, he was big and he knew what he wanted to do. I wouldn't have told him what to do."

She added: "We talked a lot on the phone. He wasn't a letter writer. I sent packets of wipes to help him cool down out there. He said that he was very well looked after. He was such a character, he was even learning Japanese because of interest in martial arts. He was a big Bruce Lee fan."

Carol returns to her last conversation with Scott, on a phone line to Kuwait. "When we were speaking, he was in good form. He was very, very happy. We had a great blether. He kept saying to me: 'Don't worry mum, don't worry mum. I'll be fine. All the guys are here and we're looking after each other.'

"And he said to me during that phone call: 'If you don't hear from me, mum, don't worry. It's because I'm busy.'"

Scott was indeed busy in his final hours on the morning of Thursday, June 28. He was on a resupply mission to the British base at Basra Palace. He and his colleagues left the relative safety of their Warrior armoured fighting vehicle to carry out a routine check of the ground ahead and were caught by the blast from a roadside bomb.

Carol will never forget the moment the two men from the army knocked on her door. "I was in my bed. I was woken up at half past four in the morning," she said. "I thought I was dreaming. At first I couldn't believe it was happening, then I realised that it was all real and it was happening. I kept hoping and praying that it wasn't true, that it wasn't really happening."

Scott returned home in a closed coffin. A song by Joe Longthorne – one of Carol's favourite artists – was played at his funeral.

She said: "I have been amazed about the support from everyone. The cards, from all over. I got cards from England, from families who had been in similar situations.

"A lot of soldiers wrote to me, very nice letters. I haven't even read them all, but one day, when I'm stronger, I'll start reading them again. I received flowers from Prince Charles, a beautiful bouquet of flowers.

"I even received letters from MPs, including from Gordon Brown, from the hospital. Everyone has been so good to me. Quite a few of the soldiers have come to see me and gone to lay flowers on his grave."

Understandably, other bereaved parents have railed against the politicians who sent their children to Iraq. "There's no point," said Carol. "It can't bring anyone back. I don't watch the news from Iraq. There are just too many sad things which I see. When I hear of things I feel sad for the families, I remember how they were for me.

"Other families, who haven't lost people in Iraq should be very grateful for what they have got. I would do anything to have what they have got. I was a mum who dedicated myself to my boys. I was a mother who did everything for my boys."

In memorium: those who gave their lives in 2007

IRAQ

• Guardsman Stephen Ferguson, 31, of the 1st Battalion Scots Guards, from Lanarkshire.

• Two un-named SAS soldiers were killed when an RAF Puma helicopter crashed in November.

• Lance Corporal Sarah Holmes, 26, from 29 Postal Courier and Movement Regiment and attached to 3 Logistic Support Regiment, from Oxfordshire.

• Sergeant Mark Stansfield, 32, serving with 32 Close Support Squadron, UK Logistic Battalion, from Oxfordshire.

• Sergeant Eddie Collins from the Parachute Regiment.

• Lance Sergeant Chris Casey, 27, from London and Lance Corporal Kirk Redpath, 22, from Essex, both serving with the 1st Battalion, Irish Guards.

• Leading Aircraftman Martin Beard, 20, of No 1 Squadron Royal Air Force Regiment, from Nottinghamshire.

• Private Craig Barber, 20, of 2nd Battalion The Royal Welsh.

• Corporal Steve Edwards, 35, of the 2nd Royal Tank Regiment, from Northampton.

• Lance Corporal Timothy Darren Flowers, 25, of the Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers, from Northern Ireland.

• Senior Aircraftsman, Matthew Caulwell, 22, of Birmingham, Senior Aircraftsman, Christopher Dunsmore, 29, from Leicester and Senior Aircraftsman, Peter McFerran, 24, of North Wales, all of the RAF.

• Corporal Christopher Read, 22, of 158 Provost Company, 3rd Regiment Royal Military Police, from Dorset.

• Lance Corporal Ryan Francis, 23, of the 2nd Battalion The Royal Welsh, from Wales.

• Rifleman Edward Vakabua, 23, from 4th Battalion The Rifles, from Fiji.

• Corporal Paul Joszko, 28, of Wales, from the 2nd Battalion The Royal Welsh (The Royal Regiment of Wales), Private Scott Kennedy, 20, of Dunfermline, and Private James Kerr, 20, aged 20 from Cowdenbeath, both of the Black Watch, 3rd Battalion The Royal Regiment of Scotland.

• Corporal John Rigby, 24, of the 4th Battalion The Rifles, aged 24, from Sussex.

• Major Paul Harding, 48, of the 4th Battalion The Rifles, from Winchester

• Lance Corporal James Cartwright, 21, of Badger Squadron, 2nd Royal Tank Regiment, from London.

• Corporal Rodney Wilson, 30, from 4th Battalion The Rifles. Born in Germany.

• Corporal Jeremy Brookes, 28, of the 4th Battalion The Rifles, from Birmingham.

• Private Kevin Thompson, 21, of the Royal Logistic Corps, from Lancaster.

• Major Nick Bateson, 49, of the Royal Corps of Signals.

• Rifleman Paul Donnachie, 18, of the 2nd Battalion The Rifles, from Reading.

• Kingsman Alan Joseph Jones, 20, from 2nd Battalion The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment, from Liverpool.

• Corporal Ben Leaning, 24, from Scunthorpe and Trooper Kristen Turton, 27, of Grimsby, both of the Queen's Royal Lancers.

• Colour Sergeant Mark Powell, 37, from south Wales, of the Parachute Regiment, and Sergeant Mark J McLaren, 27, of Northumberland, serving with the RAF.

• Second Lieutenant Joanna Yorke Dyer, 24, from Yeovil and attached to the 2nd Battalion Duke of Lancaster's Regiment, Corporal Kris O'Neill, 27, from Yorkshire and serving with the Royal Army Medical Corps, Private Eleanor Dlugosz, 19, from Southampton of the Royal Army Medical Corps and Kingsman Adam James Smith, 19, from the Isle of Man and serving with of the 2nd Battalion The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment.

• Rifleman Aaron Lincoln, 18, of the 2nd Battalion, The Rifles, from Durham.

• Kingsman Danny Wilson, 28, of the 2nd Battalion, The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment, from Cumbria.

• Private Jonathon Dany Wysoczan, 21, of the First Battalion The Staffordshire Regiment, from Staffordshire.

• Rifleman Daniel Lee Coffey, 21, of C Company, Second Battalion The Rifles.

• Private Luke Daniel Simpson, 21, of the 1st Battalion, The Yorkshire Regiment.

• Second Lieutenant Jonathan Bracho-Cooke, 24, of 2nd Battalion The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment, from Sussex.

• Private Michael Tench, 18, of A Company, 2nd Battalion The Light Infantry, from Sunderland.

• Kingsman Alexander William Green, 21, of 2nd Battalion The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment, from Cheshire.

• Sergeant Wayne Rees, 36, of The Queen's Royal Lancers from Nottingham.

AFGHANISTAN

Sergeant Lee Johnson, 33, of 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment (Green Howards), from Stockton.

• Trooper Jack Sadler, 21, of The Honourable Artillery Company, from Devon.

• Captain John McDermid, 43, of The Royal Highland Fusiliers, 2nd Battalion The Royal Regiment of Scotland, from Glasgow.

• Lance Corporal Jake Alderton, 22, of 36 Engineer Regiment, from London.

• Major Alexis Roberts, 32, of 2nd Battalion The Royal Gurkha Rifles (serving with 1st Battalion The Royal Gurkha Rifles), from Kent.

• Colour Sergeant Phillip Newman, 36, from Coventry of the 4th Battalion The Mercian Regiment, and Private Brian Tunnicliffe, 33, from Ilkeston of the 2nd Battalion The Mercian Regiment (Worcesters and Foresters).

• Corporal Ivano Violino, 29, from 36 Engineer Regiment, from Salford.

• Sergeant Craig Brelsford, 25, of Nottingham, and Private Johan Botha, 25, from South Africa, both from 2nd Battalion The Mercian Regiment (Worcesters and Foresters).

• Private Damian Wright, 23, of Mansfield, and Private Ben Ford, 18, of Chesterfield, both from the 2nd Battalion The Mercian Regiment (Worcesters and Foresters).

• Senior Aircraftman Christopher Bridge, 20, from C flight, 51 Squadron Royal Air Force Regiment, from Sheffield.

• Privates Aaron James McClure, 19, from Ipswich, Robert Graham Foster, 19, and John Thrumble, 21, both of Essex, all of 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment.

• Captain David Hicks, 26, of 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, from Surrey.

• Private Tony Rawson, 27, of 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, from Essex.

• Lance Corporal Michael Jones, 26, of the Royal Marines, from Yorkshire.

• Sergeant Barry Keen, 34, of 14 Signal Regiment, from Gateshead.

• Guardsman David Atherton, 25, of the 1st Battalion Grenadier Guards, from Manchester.

• Lance Corporal Alex Hawkins, 22, of 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, from Norfolk.

• Guardsman Daryl Hickey, 27, of the 1st Battalion Grenadier Guards, from Birmingham.

• Sergeant Dave Wilkinson, 33, of 19 Regiment Royal Artillery, from Ashford, Kent.

• Captain Sean Dolan, 40, of the 1st Battalion, The Worcestershire and Sherwood Foresters Regiment, from the West Midlands.

• Drummer Thomas Wright, 21, of 1st Battalion The Worcestershire and Sherwood Foresters Regiment, from Derbyshire.

• Guardsman Neil 'Tony' Downes, 20, from Manchester.

• Lance Corporal Paul 'Sandy' Sandford, 23, of 1st Battalion The Worcestershire and Sherwood Foresters, from Nottingham.

• Corporal Mike Gilyeat, 28, from the Royal Military Police. Born in Germany.

• Corporal Darren Bonner, 31, of the 1st Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, from Norfolk.

• Guardsman Daniel Probyn, 22, of the 1st Battalion the Grenadier Guards, from Tipton, Staffordshire.

• Lance Corporal George Russell Davey, 23, of the 1st Battalion the Royal Anglian Regiment, from Suffolk.

• Guardsman Simon Davison, 22, of the 1st Battalion Grenadier Guards, from Newcastle-upon-Tyne.

• Private Chris Gray, 19, of A Company, 1st Battalion, from Leicestershire.

• Warrant Officer Class 2 Michael 'Mick' Smith of 29 Commando Regiment Royal Artillery, from Liverpool.

• Marine Benjamin Reddy, 22, of 42 Commando Royal Marines, from Ascot.

• Lance Bombardier Ross Clark, 25, of Zimbabwe, and Lance Bombardier Liam McLaughlin, 22, from Lancashire, both of 29 Commando Regiment Royal Artillery.

• Marine Scott Summers, 23, of 42 Commando Royal Marines, from Sussex.

• Marine Jonathan Holland, 23, of 45 Commando, from Lancashire.

• Lance Corporal Mathew Ford, 30, of 45 Commando Royal Marines, from Immingham.

• Marine Thomas Curry, 21, of 42 Commando, from London.



The full article contains 2648 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 30/12/2007 00:09:17
God Bless them all,
2

albafoto,

didcot 30/12/2007 03:01:30
Please Scotsman take the advert out of this article, it is inapropriate.
Thank you
3

Kenny A,

30/12/2007 06:22:38
A long list of names. May they rest peacefully.
4

ThaiScot,

Thailand 30/12/2007 06:29:28
My heart goes out to Carol and her family. Scott and his comrades are unsung heroes in todays selfish world and deserve our grateful thanks, no matter what we think of these wars. But, what was the army doing waking up that poor woman at 0430? Are not those the tactics of an army we fought against 65 years ago?
5

queen_sandra8,

US 30/12/2007 09:19:15

To be remembered with honor!
6

glassbenmhor,

Fairbanks,Alaska 30/12/2007 09:53:23
Dear Carol and Family,
My hopes and thoughts are with you this New Year,I like Scott have the Colours in my heart,and so your story comes right home to me sitting here 4000 miles away.
Yours Sincerly
Angus (ex-Piper 1st BW)
7

JD11,

Donabate 30/12/2007 10:15:31
My thoughts are with each of them , and their families.
8

Lanna,

30/12/2007 17:57:20
as well, my thoughts and prayers with each one and their families
9

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 30/12/2007 18:12:24
A very long list of brave men and women killed in Afghanistan and Iraq for a cause which day by day seems more futile and unmanageable.

One hope these brave soldiers have not died in vain and my heart goes out to their loved ones at this time of New Year's celebration.

Let us celebrate their lives and the bravery they demostrated in the performance of their humanitarian duties.
10

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 02/01/2008 00:01:55
god.bless.them.all
11

dieselted,

Picton 15/01/2008 10:52:38
Dear Carol, may my prayers go out to you, but i have to say i never anjoyed the bagpips. Love from Ted ex Sáline & ex BW.
12

dieselted,

Picton 15/01/2008 10:52:41
Dear Carol, may my prayers go out to you, but i have to say i never anjoyed the bagpips. Love from Ted ex Sáline & ex BW.
13

A Better Way,

Edinburgh 23/03/2008 08:36:43
Carol, all the best lass. Theres nothing any of us can say that will take away the pain of your loss, but from me I will think about your laddies sacrifice everytime I vote. No more Scottish Laddies or any other Nations bairns should die for the sake of a politicians greed.

Perhaps a good law to bring in after Independance would be that every politician should be made to send their bairns to any future wars no matter what their circumstances.If they dont have kids of a suitable age then they go in their place. There wont be another bullet fired in anger, thats for sure.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.