Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Rise in drink deaths among Scots women

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 February 2009
SCOTLAND'S alcohol crisis has dramatically worsened, with the country's women now at a greater risk of dying from drink-related diseases than men in England.
A new national "alcohol death map" compiled by Glasgow University researchers reveals that the average women's death rate from chronic liver disease and cirrhosis is almost 16 per 100,000 population compared with 15 among English men.

The average death rate for men in Scotland remains higher – at 38 deaths – but the map shows that in some areas, such as Glasgow Ibrox, it rises as high as 176.

But the map also exposes the shocking effects of the increasingly entrenched drinking culture on Scottish women. The female death rate also reaches a high of 59 in Glasgow Ibrox, an economically deprived area on the city's south side.

The map will provide further ammunition for ministers determined to curb Scotland's damaging drinking culture. Legislative changes are expected from the Scottish Parliament next month.

Dr Richard Mitchell, of the university's public health department, who compiled the map along with Dr Carol Emslie of the university's Medical Research Council public health sciences unit, said the death rates in some areas were "astronomical" and indicative of a growing national trend.

"Scotland is facing a huge public health problem, which will require strong and radical action by the Scottish Government," he said.

"The results suggest to us that men and women are both vulnerable to the social, economic and cultural pressures which can make people drink too much."

The researchers say at least 1,000 men and 448 women are now dying every year from alcohol-related conditions.

The map is the most detailed survey carried out into the geographical spread of alcohol-related deaths in Scotland, compiled from Office for National Statistics data for 144 areas between 2000 and 2005.

New figures published today from the drinks industry analysts Neilsen's suggest Scotland has the eighth-highest alcohol consumption level in the world.

As revealed in Scotland on Sunday last week, the country drank nearly 50 million litres of pure alcohol in 2007 – equivalent to 11.8 litres per head for every person aged over 16. This is considerably higher than England and Wales, which had an average consumption figure of 9.9 litres per head.

Culture of over-consumption that must be reversed

THE findings published in today's Scotland on Sunday make for very worrying reading. They blow apart any notion that alcohol misuse is some kind of marginal problem and show that in fact large numbers of people in every part of Scotland are drinking potentially harmful amounts of alcohol.

This is already causing alcohol-related illnesses and deaths to skyrocket – but with young people drinking more than ever before, the future health consequences could be even worse.

The Scottish Government sees tackling alcohol misuse as our most pressing health priority. We have consulted on a radical package of measures and will outline our next policy steps shortly.

Our central argument is that the big fall in the relative price of alcohol over the past 25 years means a culture of over-consumption has taken root which we must reverse for the sake of our nation's health. With drinking habits formed at an early age, we also think encouraging a more sensible approach among young people is vital.

It's clear that over-consumption of alcohol cuts across society. The Scottish Household Survey showed that while nearly half of men in the most deprived socioeconomic group binged on their heaviest drinking day, the highest proportion of men (nearly 40% per cent) drinking more than 21 units per week were in the most affluent group.

Meanwhile, women in the wealthiest group also showed high consumption – with nearly a third exceeding weekly guidelines.

Scotland has led the way with progressive action to tackle smoking and we can do the same with alcohol, but only if we get over our denial and face up to the fact that alcohol is causing serious harm to us as individuals, communities and as a society. Already, the fallout from alcohol misuse in terms of the extra strain put on public services and lost economic productivity is costing Scotland at least £2.25bn per year – that's £500 for every adult in our country.

It's a cost we could all do without.

• Nicola Sturgeon MSP is Health Secretary in the Scottish Government


The full article contains 732 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 February 2009 11:25 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Alcohol & binge drinking
 
1

Tussler,

22/02/2009 02:20:44
We can't idly sit back and allow our beautiful Scottish women to do this to themselves surely.
2

Bob dublin,

22/02/2009 04:56:59
The female death rate also reaches a high of 59 in Glasgow Ibrox, an economically deprived area on the city's south side.
But once Rangers start winning again, it will all change.
3

Regulator II,

Edinburgh 22/02/2009 07:10:10
"Our central argument is that the big fall in the relative price of alcohol over the past 25 years means a culture of over-consumption has taken root which we must reverse for the sake of our nation's health."

I don't understand why or how the problem is related to price. You can hire a transit van, drive to a ferry, pay for the ferry to the continent, buy cheap booze and bring it back, paying for all that fuel and it's still cheaper than buying it in Scotland.

It looks like the government are going to try to price it out of the market, at least for younsters and whilst this is commendable, you will open the doors for cheap European drink to be brought into the country by criminals who will make a very health profit out of it and you'll still have an alochol problem, but you will have succeeded in making a good number of criminals a lot richer.

Can responsible newspapers like Scotland on Sunday not produce a balanced report on subjects like this and not simply report what the governmment is saying?
4

an interested party,

22/02/2009 08:41:52
price
yet more with the problem in deprived areas

if drink has gone up in line with inflation
and dole money has gone up the same
then how is it cheaper

perhaps its cheaper to those on the average wage

or more likely they are drinking more bang for buck
drinks than before, vodka instead of wine
5

Pocket Dictionary,

22/02/2009 08:48:32
Far too many off-licences. There are 5 within a 1/4 mile radius of my workbase, which is located in a socially deprived area.
Then again, that's 5 fees generating income for Fife Council. Is that why there is a reluctance not to grant licences?
6

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 22/02/2009 09:14:54
11.8 litres per head works out at:

11.8*1000/10/365*7 = 22.6 units per person per week.

If the purpose of this article is to provide useful information to people about the average level of alcohol consumption in Scotland, why is it that different ways of expressing that consumption are used? Unless someone gets out a calculator and knows how to do the calculation, there is no way that anyone reading the article has any idea whether 11.8 litres per year is more or less than the recommended maximum intake of 21 units per week for a man and 14 units per week for a woman.

Are journalists congenitally innumerate? It would appear so.
7

Road to the isles,

22/02/2009 09:37:06
#3

Good post but, without any intent to have a go at you, the Scotsman hasn't been a responsible journal for some time now and its journos wouldn't recognise a balanced report if it jumped up and bit them on the b@m.
8

Regulator II,

Edinburgh 22/02/2009 09:53:53
Apologies RttI, but I was only comparing SoS and The Scotsman with the likes of the News of th World. No matter what paper you read there doesn't appear to be any investigation done, it is pure reporting (and by "pure" I don't attach any purity to it). No doubt Jeremy Watson wouldn't know what 11.8 ltr of alcohol constituded either.
9

Pomodora,

Gravesend 22/02/2009 10:49:25
I am always sceptical, even suspicious, of university projects and of the obsession of the media to rush to report non empirical data and unsubstantiated reports. In my own experience as a student I always found Sociology to be more entertaining than enlightening but for what it's worth, in the pursuit of data the first step is to establish the demographics of obvious models, in this case Glasgow Ibrox, and guide the parameters to suit the objective. I have no doubt that the consumption of alcohol is a cause for concern if allowed to go unfettered but to sensationalise the story is tacky at least.
10

soapy1,

Rainworth 22/02/2009 11:09:52
Alcohol abuse has been with mankind for millenia, there will always be a minority who do not know when to stop, this article gives the impression that Scotland is a nation of alcohol and smoking suiciders.

I appreciate there is some dispute between nationalists and the English, some justified most not. As an Englishman I have reservations about full independance for Scotland but if her people desire it then so be it.

I would ask though why is it that the Scots parliament is so hellbent on destroying/damaging the distillation industry?

The world knows and loves whiskey, they know it's home is Scotland, to campaign against alcohol will damage the distilling industry reducing its income, reducing the taxation revenue an Independant Scotland would badly need to survive. Am I wrong, does not the SNP stand for independance? If so why destroy one of the anchors of financial stability?
11

Munguin,

22/02/2009 11:43:52
A sad state of affairs indeed. What a legacy of 10 years of Labour/Lib Dems here in Scotland and 12 years of Labour in the UK.

Labour and the Liberals did nothing to address this issue during their tenure in office.

In contrast both parties in conjunction with the Tories have done everything to block and oppose the SNP's attempts to do something about this.
12

lulach mac gille coemgain,

22/02/2009 11:56:03
Most of these deaths are in Labour Council Controlled areas - what does that tell ye ?

Labour - keeping areas of Scotland deprived since the 1960’s!
13

The Ayrshire Bard,

22/02/2009 12:09:03
Forgetting the serious health issues, how many young women have been left literally holding the baby because they lost control of their inhibitions and sense through too much booze? Young women used to pride themselves on their dignity and common sense. They also knew how to keep their knees together. Time for a cultural upheaval to restore some moral values to our feckless youngsters.
14

The Ayrshire Bard,

22/02/2009 12:12:22
#12 The world may love whiskey, but Scotland produces WHISKY.
Doubtful if that's the favoured drink of young women though.
15

radge dug,

22/02/2009 12:55:53
Aye, taxes on malt whisky should come down. At the very least it would help the industry during the recession.

AS to alcohol... I thought cannibis was the big threat???!!
16

,

22/02/2009 12:57:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

EK,

Edinburgh 22/02/2009 13:00:50
I am sorry to say no one forces people to drink the copious amounts of alcohol people seem to drink in the UK with the sole purpose of getting "wasted". Many of these people are a detriment to society because:
1-They cause active damamge to the streets in the form of vandalism, broken glass, rubbish (bottles, food and food wrappers after a night out). Tax payers' money spent to clean that out.
2-Excessive noise duringthe night - people are tired, ill, have children etc.
3-Days off work (if working) for hangovers
4-No attempt to better themselves through reading etc. so people like this useless at their jobs, unhelpful
5-Fights and accidents caused by drunkenness - waste of police and casualty resources.
6-Long term health problems - paid by our taxes and the NHS.

What about MY rights for MY taxes to be paid on what I want???? Where are my rights to live in a quiet, clean city? Who cares about this? Who supports MY rights? Who do you you sue/ Society? The government? The police? The council? I am not an organisation and cannot fund a lawyer.

It's society's role to control bad behaviour and make it feel unacceptable to be dirty , uneducatted, loutish, lazy drunks - which is what a lot of people ar e now. Get rid of this drink habit and please never call it a drink "culture".
18

KTK...,

Tampa,FL. 22/02/2009 13:40:25
It's all the fault of the Gasgow Rangers......!
19

Tartan Viking,

22/02/2009 15:34:10
#12. Soapy1.

"As an Englishman I have reservations about full independance for Scotland but if her people desire it then so be it."
Oh really? Think you'll find that if the people desire independence they will vote accordingly, whether people like you have reservations or not. It's called democracy. The trouble with most people down south is that that on one hand they seem to have "reservations" about independence (without justifying why in most cases), yet on the other hand they are only too keen to point the finger at the 'scrounging Jocks'. It makes my blood boil. Make your minds up one way or another.

And by the way it's whisky - not whiskey.



20

Tartan Viking,

22/02/2009 15:38:50
As far as the headline is concerned - the rise in drink deaths among women is bad, but it's even worse amongst men. You'd think that, on balance, the headlines should have included the word men as well wouldn't you.
21

Fifi la Bonbon,

22/02/2009 15:41:56
#13, when Scotland wins its freedom from the evil yoke of English domination, women throughout the land will stop drinking alcohol. after all, you never hear of English women being drunk, do you?

Wee bit hill an' glen!!!
22

,

22/02/2009 15:55:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
23

skuterua,

mississauga, Ontario Canada 22/02/2009 20:06:43
Having travelled annually to Scotland every year to visit family for the last 13 years, One night out in Edinburgh shows the degree of alcohol consumption. I as a special education teacher have been deeply concerned about the amount of Fetal Alcohol Effect which must be apparent in children-behaviour, learning. In Canada considerable research has been done in the area of alcohol's effect on a growing fetus and it is widely accepted among young women that NO alcoholic beverage is acceptable during pregnancy. At one time it was only thought that children who showed physical signs of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome were negatively affected by their mothers' drinking but we now know that it is a considerably larger group of children who may not show physical symptoms but whose brains have been negatively affected by alcohol-one drink is too many
24

Tartan Viking,

22/02/2009 20:33:52
#25. skuterua
Sir/ Madam - You make some interesting points but your grammar leaves a lot to be desired! As a 'special education teacher' you really must try harder.
25

im brian and so is my wife,

edinburgh 22/02/2009 21:51:40
50 years of labour in scotland,and still people die from drink related illness
every chancer be he tory or labour has hit the drinks industry in scotland by upping the tax duty,so as to fill westminsters coffers
all revenue from the whisky industry should go to holyrood for the use of scotlands people
wonder what could be achieved by this?
26

Tartan Viking,

22/02/2009 22:12:41
#28. I wonder indeed what would be achieved if all the revenue from the past 30 years from whisky and oil etc was pumped into Scotland. I wonder indeed what society we would be now if we had contol of all out revenue, to spend and apportion as we see fit. Alas, we are not. Thanks to the Union and the despicable unbelievers who masquerade as "Brits" (sick !) and vote for them, we have to give all our cash to Mother England, and stand in line to receive our "pocket money" - all the time being told we are scrounging too much. The Union can GTF.
27

Tartan Viking,

22/02/2009 22:18:38
#29, "Is it just me, a cannae wait tae hear whit this Klown has got tae say."

Is it just me, a cannae wait tae hear whit you yerself has got tae say on yir next post cause you ur a nob AND a Klown.

28

Baillie Guthrie,

Caithness 22/02/2009 23:43:56
It's a global problem...
29

soapy1,

rainworth 23/02/2009 00:08:49
#21 Tartan Viking, AS long as Scotland remains a part of the United Kingdom I hold an equal right to express reservations about Scottish independance. The grounds are financial (could Scotland afford to look after her people and would Scotland be able to defend her own borders without becoming a threat to the security of the United Kingdom by becoming a client state of a foreign power?)both are valid reasons for reservations.

Nowhere have I said the Scots are scroungers, I suspect it is just a stick to beat the Englishman with, it does neither you nor Scotland any credit.

Like Scotland, England is a nation of individuals each with a different viewpoint, do not allow your inflated sense of nationalism to blind you to any support you may get from Englishmen. If the Scots decide on Independance then I personally wish them well, to be honest I do not believe Her Majesties Government will be quite as charitable.

As for women and whisky (thanks for the correction Tartan Viking) there are a lot of women world wide who actually do like a dram!

#28 actaully I am inclined to agree, taxation on Scotch should go to Holyrood, it is after all a wholly Scottish product.
30

MattyMat,

Cali 23/02/2009 17:23:58
Asking a Scott not to drink is like asking an Englishman not to be a self-absorbed, arrogant p00fter-- just ain't gonna happen.
31

Haggis MacBagpipes,

Central Canada - ex Perth & Glesca' 24/02/2009 06:12:24
#21-Tartan Viking.
For your information, my dictionary states that the word 'Whisky' is derived from the Gaelic, and the word 'Whiskey' is a translation of the other word, into English...thus making both words acceptable.
My Dictionary was printed in Scotland.
Cheers,
Haggis MacBagpipes™©

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.