Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


MSPs voice approval at software

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
02 September 2007
THEY are among the greatest sources of frustration in the workplace: a repository for festering lunch fragments and a leading cause of repetitive strain injury.
But the time may finally be approaching when it is safe to throw away the much hated computer keyboard. Speech recognition - after a series of false dawns - could shortly be coming to a PC near you.

Blazing a trail in the UK is the Scottish Parli
ament, which has offered all staff and MSPs the chance to dump their keyboards and install software which automatically converts speech into text, even allowing for accents and background noise. One member of the Parliament - Nationalist Alasdair Morgan - has already taken up the challenge with gusto and now dictates all his correspondence direct into his PC at Holyrood.

Voice recognition software has been a Holy Grail for computer technicians for decades, and the makers of successive versions of software have promised to consign keyboards to history.

However, consumers have found that the reality often fails to live up to the promises, with users having laboriously to train programmes to recognise their voices and then spend as much time correcting their text as they spent dictating it.

The latest software packages - costing about £150 - claim to work at up to 160 words per minute and can figure out the differences between words that sound the same.

One of the key reasons why they work better is that computers now have faster chips and more memory, which allows more rapid and extensive examination of sounds. Morgan said: "I had already used voice recognition software on my computer at home, so I was glad to have the chance to use at Holyrood.

"I found it works best if you take the time to train it so it gets used to the accent. Some of my fellow MSPs see me talking into the headset on the computer and wonder what I'm doing, but I find that it works very well.

"I find that I would use it for all but a very short one or two word e-mail. If I have a lot of letters and e-mails and reports to get through then I will use this. And I can do it very quickly."

A Scottish Parliament spokeswoman said: "It's being made available for MSPs to use for their own correspondence and we think that the technology has a lot of potential to help them."

In July, the United States Attorney's Office, which employs 15,000 staff across the US, installed speech recognition software on its machines in order to ease the workload on staff.

Speech recognition programmes include IBM ViaVoice, iListen for the Mac, and Talk It Type It.

The software offered by the Scottish Parliament, and being used by the US Attorney's Office, Nuance Dragon NaturallySpeaking 9, costs about £150 and the firm claims up to 99% accuracy.

Simon Howard, Nuance UK productivity applications manager, said: "There have been a number of developments which make speech recognition much more efficient than in the past.

"The software itself is improving, but computers are ever-more powerful and sound cards and microphones are getting better. That makes a considerable difference.

"And we've dealt with the issue of background noise. It used to be that you had to record noises, like a door shutting, so the computer would know to ignore them."

But Stephen Brewster, professor of computing at Glasgow University, warned that problems remained.

He said: "Voice-recognition software is getting better all the time, that's right. But it is still some way from being perfect. Every time you make some progress, you still realise that there is still so much to do."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 September 2007 7:06 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: The Scottish Parliament
 
1

Mallory,

02/09/2007 00:07:45

All voice recognition software needs and benefits from lengthy training - in other words each user needs to spend time reading texts into the system so the software refines it's recognition base.

The 99% accuracy figure is very optimistic, unless our MSPs have limited vocabularies, and the price for a bulk order seems high.

2

Boy Wonder,

02/09/2007 00:18:37

The sooner it's available, the better. My fingers can't spell as well as I can on the keyboard. Too many typos slip through!

But not with this post.

Obviously ......

:)

3

Guga II,

Rockall 02/09/2007 02:11:28

The trouble with all the currently available voice recognition software is that unless you have an American or English (bool in the mooth) accent, you have to spend so long training it that it becomes a waste of time.

As for the 99% accuracy, try about 69%. Then you have to spend longer correcting all the mistakes than it would have taken you to type it in the first place.

If you've got the cash to spare, fair enough, but otherwise it is a waste of money.

4

BK,

Cyberspace 02/09/2007 08:03:33

The problem is that all the software is expecting is expecting Laura Nawdah for Law and order, and Perthshire and Persia to be pronounced identically!

5

Pocket Dictionary,

02/09/2007 08:27:06

The Exec should have helped fight Microsoft dominance by making OpenOffice the standard in the Parliament.

6

Douglas,

Bathgate 02/09/2007 11:29:27

Whittle they day a boot low cull axe sents?

7

NorT,

Edinburgh 02/09/2007 14:37:25

As a user of voice recognition software if you train it properly you can achieve 99% accuracy. It also deals with accents, dialects and technical words but you have to make the initial investment in training it to understand your voice and inflections. Well worth it in the end.

8

Norbert Dentressangle,

02/09/2007 16:23:42

Having met, dined and spoken with Alasdair Morgan several times I can emphatically deny any claim that he has bools in his mouth.

Anyone remember the probably apocryphal story of Sir Awex Ferguson driving down the motorway pulling into services then being unable to restart his flash Audi as it couldn't understand his accent.

9

Suck McCrunchie,

http://www.stirlingpark.net for public contracts? 03/09/2007 22:48:28

Wee wood leek two Anne ounce they Rhyl beep LANs too add opts oft where four voice recognition.

Is seems readers of the Gruniard can read the output effortlessly.

10

Alberto.,

17/02/2008 09:19:34
If training to recognise voices and differing accents is necessary or seemingly essential, this must surely restrict the use of the Computer a great deal, especially if universal use is required, then surely if this facility is required it must place great restriction on 'separate' computer usage, which in turn must obviously make for much time wasting in use -especially where 'time maybe of the essence' and vitally important!

The 'Keyboard' - as we know it, does afford the facility of almost complete universal use by anyone so acquainted with its use!

In view of the massive financial 'blunders' we have read about so far, in the Political field concerning 'Computer' installations, many at massive wasted expense caused by decisions of Politicians (probably not understanding - what its all about Alfie!), and no doubt 'Sold' by Computer Company salesmen to seemingly, either 'ignorant or gullible' Politicians, perhaps they should sit back and consider 'Let's see how it goes' in the Market place first, and not forget that 'Technology' bought today, may well be obsolete, or 'Something much better' (after purchase commitment!' could pop its head round the door, even before the Party, celebratory dinner (for friends, of course!) for the 'alleged' masterly stroke of the decision to buy!



 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.