Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Best small country in the world no longer

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 August 2007
IT'S official: Scotland is no longer the best small country in the world. Three years after Jack McConnell first claimed the title for the nation, the former first minister's slogan has been officially ditched.
SNP ministers confirmed last week that the much- maligned slogan which has been plastered all over the nation's airports and railway stations for the past three years will now be torn down.

Posters will gradually be withdrawn and officials at the
Scottish Executive have been told to no longer use the slogan in promotional material.

The death of the slogan was long expected after First Minister Alex Salmond railed against it while in opposition, arguing that it summed up the limited ambition of his predecessor's reign.

Salmond also claimed it managed to combine the worst of two Scottish characteristics the "'Wha's like us' bombast and the debilitating Scottish cringe".

Culture Minister Linda Fabiani confirmed last week: "The Scottish Executive is no longer actively using this promotional slogan. Any promotional materials containing the phrase are being replaced over time".

The decision brings to an end one of the more controversial slogans to have been produced in recent times.

Used to promote Scotland abroad and during the 2005 G8 summit, it was criticised, according to one commentator, for making Scotland look like "a pygmy nation hanging on to the coat tails of the global big boys".

McConnell vehemently defended his choice of slogan during the election campaign in April, claiming it had been responsible for boosting tourism levels and investment.

Few people yesterday appeared willing to insist that ministers reverse the decision.

A spokesman for Salmond said: "To be fair, the campaign was coming to a conclusion anyway.

"We never saw the need to have a qualifier. Why not just aspire to be the best country in the world?"

Labour MSP Charlie Gordon said: "I do not mourn its passing."

One Labour source added: "There were never many fans of this. Small in that context was not the kind of message we wanted to put out."



Page 1 of 1

 
1

Angus Lindsay,

Hong Kong 26/08/2007 00:15:39

Relief. Every time I saw that poster when entering a Scottish airport it made me feel queasy with embarrassment.

If it'd had any substance in the first place we'd all be beating our chests with pride, but it was a bad (if well-intentioned) party-political slogan which the general public has had to endure for three years.

2

Senga Jean,

Scotland 26/08/2007 00:16:00

We can aspire..only the best... tune in Tina Turner!

3

Boy Wonder,

26/08/2007 00:33:40

#2. Agreed. We're Simply The Best ... Better than all the rest .... :)

4

UriahHeep,

Edinburgh 26/08/2007 00:52:20

Scotland is the best country in the World.
Period.

5

Lindsey, Glasgow,

26/08/2007 00:52:27

Best wee Neds in the World...

6

,

26/08/2007 00:54:59
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 906649, Article id was mapped to record!
7

Angus Lindsay,

Hong Kong 26/08/2007 01:07:17

#6. Not A Unionist or Nationalist

That's ok then. Just as long as it's not Shiite replaced with Shiite - or Sunni.

8

I'm no really here,

26/08/2007 01:11:19

Well done Sir Ek.
People abroad sometime "complain" to me that the Scots "get everywhere". I explain to them that if the Scots didn't get everywhere, the world would be nowhere!!

With this Scottish Government, we know we are the best, but we will stop just putting on a kilt and blowing some bagpipes. We'll go out with a voice for people to listen to.

9

walter,

26/08/2007 01:11:43

The amount of times I have read that slogan from nationalism on these comments but now they will fully support scrapping it.
The groupthink carries on.

10

'Hezza,

26/08/2007 02:28:35

Phew!!! I just cringe when I see that when I return from my travels. I always wonder what the Danes, Irish, Luxembergers, New Zealanders, Icelanders, and goodness knows how many others must think when they walk through arrivals! Something along the lines of 'they really are deluded and arrogant...perhaps a bit of a joke'....much like the man who introduced the slogan to us, methinks.

11

thomas,

midlothian 26/08/2007 02:47:44

scotland produced some of the best inventors on the planet in the worlds history.
then after both wars the english government decided to tamper with the scottish education system. dumbing down is the hot-button word to describe it.
now we have the opportunity for scots to shine again
and the world will again be thankful for this.

12

Calgacus,

26/08/2007 04:14:10

About time too! I flew into Edinburgh for the first time recently. God, how embarassing. At least Aberdeen, my usual entry point, tones it down a bit.

#3 & 4 - spot on. No room for McConnell's insecurities here.

13

Pilrig.,

Livingston 26/08/2007 05:40:36

Good riddance to it.

14

SC,

Dundee 26/08/2007 06:15:36

The slogan perfectly sums up the difference between unionists and independentists.

What we need is a sign at the airports that says, "Scotland - a country." No boasts, no qualifiers - just a statement of normality.

15

Heidegger,

Fife 26/08/2007 06:44:29

It isn't even a country!!!!!!!!

16

mr chips,

26/08/2007 07:03:20

Good riddence to the worst wee slogan in the world and the thickest wee numpty in the world.

17

Spotter,

26/08/2007 08:36:11

scotland' s miles better now

18

Fat Freddys Cat,

26/08/2007 08:53:08

@9

please cite all the examples where you've read this slogan put forward by nationalists on this forum as a positive thing.

It was not a popluar slogan by any standards, let alone the fact that even labour MSP's did not like it!

19

Riley Hamish,

FREEING SCOTLAND 26/08/2007 09:08:12

Suggestions for a NEW slogan.

Howzabout.........

"Welcome To A McConnell-Free Scotland......(Sorry aboot WeeWindy)"

20

Cadgers,

Perth 26/08/2007 09:24:32

Gosh, I bet AM2's going to be disappointed.

21

donald,

weegieland 26/08/2007 09:31:22

Pure dead Brilliant rubbish.

How about renaming Galsgow Airport to The William Wallace Airport, Prestwick - Burns Airport and so on.

22

Richardinho,

26/08/2007 09:35:49

Instead of getting rid of I think we should retain it and add a mascot to it; a wee grey haired man with a huge brick shaped head and wearing a pin-striped kilt-called 'wee jack'. Jack McConnell himself could play the part of 'wee jack' as a roving ambassador and make personal appearances to promote Scotland at special occasions such as supermarket openings.

23

Pinelands,

Cape town 26/08/2007 10:01:30

If Scotslands the greatest place in the world why do so many of your country men live elsewhere, that always puzzles me.

Sir Sean Connery always amazes me the supposed true Scotsman live in Spain who was delighted to receive his knighthood, everthing that the Scots detest, but every so often pops back with his kilt in full flow .

Now you talk of your independance and being on the world stage.

Be realistic the only stage you wil be on is the Hippydrome.

Just be happy to be alive in the world

24

SEUMAS,

Tain 26/08/2007 10:18:43

Aye, you are a sad bitter man pinelands-chill out before you do yourself harm. I,
like Sean pay tax in this country, and comments like yours just reveal your character, if you can't say something sensible, better say nothing!

25

Seannair,

Oban 26/08/2007 11:45:12

I share most posters distaste for this slogan.I wrote to the Manager of BAA at Prestwick on one occasion after landing there but did not even get an acknowledgemnet far less an answer.
Certainly I would like my country to aspire to be better and I think that , at last, we are on the way to improve. Removing this stupid empty boast is part of that process.

26

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 26/08/2007 11:54:55

Sad. Flag-waving and nationalism are toxic. Remember the Nuremburg rallies in Nazi Germany?

But wait for it - somebody will dream up another catchy slogan that will not capture the essence of the uniqueness of Scotland and its citizens.

Any suggestions you opinionated, crabby, intellectually poised (sometimes) Scots?

27

Cool,

26/08/2007 12:05:40

It never was & never will be....just a daft slogan fae a daft wee mannie...

28

I'm no really here,

26/08/2007 12:07:10

I can't spell it in Gaelic, so I won't embarrass myself, but I think "A Hundred Thousand Welcomes" is sufficient.

29

WL,

Livingston 26/08/2007 12:35:15

I am sure that Malawi will now become the Best Small Country in the World.

30

Dougie - Edinburgh,

26/08/2007 13:10:40

Dumping this slogan makes a certain wee country even better!

31

cuthbert,

26/08/2007 13:37:07

"Relief. Every time I saw that poster when entering a Scottish airport it made me feel queasy with embarrassment."

Ditto. I hated seeing it every time i arrived in Glasgow or Edinburgh on the way home from London. It really was an embaressment.

32

Anonym,

Edinburgh 26/08/2007 13:41:08

Was that slogan plastered somewhere at Edinburgh Airport?

Never noticed it. Not that I used the airport all that much. Anyway.

Away with slogans! 'Welcome to Scotland' sounds good to me too, and is sufficient. Or perhaps they could have 'Please do not feed the neds' in smaller type...

33

SC,

Dundee 26/08/2007 13:55:03

Actually, that unionist-produced nonsense of a slogan has inspired a resolution in me.

I will never refer to Scotland as a country again until independence.

The unionists cannot have it both ways. Scotland cannot be a dependent region whilst remaining a country in its own right. Who are Scots to have two equal nationalities when the rest of the world only gets one?

34

livilion,

livingston 26/08/2007 14:08:45

""You are

WELCOME TO SCOTLAND

everyone else has helped themselves to some before you got here""

35

livilion,

livingston 26/08/2007 14:34:26

28. TimW1234, Ottawa, Canada

Yeh, know what you mean, particularly bad in Ottawa with black shirted Canucks goosestepping all over the place in their jackboots waving the Mapleleaf and getting up to mischief is it?

Who said:
"The flag is the symbol of the nation's unity, for it, beyond any doubt, represents all the citizens without distinction of race, language, belief or opinion."

For a motto how about:
ALBA A MARI USQUE AD MARE

Or in the light of the terrorist attack on Glasgow airport, why don't we post just a big poster of 'Smeato' with underneath:
NEMO ME IMPUNE LACESSIT - WHA DAUR MEDDLE WI' ME

36

,

26/08/2007 14:40:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 907935, Article id was mapped to record!
37

FLUB,

Cowdenbeath 26/08/2007 14:42:10

#7 - it's never Sunni in Scotland! Boom, boom!

38

Pinelands,

Cape town 26/08/2007 15:06:30

25SEUMAS

Its winter here so I'm quite cooled out.

O'h Its sean is it, he will be pleased dropping the Sir

I was not talking about tax, so he's paying his full whack in both counties is he !!!

I was commenting on the country he as chosen to live which is not Scotland

Aye and like you I pay my tax big deal.

Now please inform me of what common sense your comments made.

39

livilion,

livingston 26/08/2007 15:35:03

27. Seannair, Oban
Prestwick, did you notice how pure dead brilliant it was?

40

,

26/08/2007 16:48:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 908101, Article id was mapped to record!
41

Tommy Tank,

Edinburgh 26/08/2007 18:29:21

All around Scotland are small countries infinitely better - just take a look at the standard of living data for Norway, Iceland, Denmark and Ireland.

Scotland languishes at the bottom of most of these tables. Just look at the heath, mortality, income per capita and crime data. It's shocking.

The best small country slogan was a joke that would have been ridiculed by overseas visitors entering Scottish airports.

It gave the impression of a country with a massive chip on its shoulder. Why try to convince people of something that no-one with any sense could believe.

Good riddance to that slogan.

42

Miss Jean Brodie,

26/08/2007 18:56:08

How about ‘Scotland’ that’s the strongest statement in itsel’

43

Seannair,

Oban 26/08/2007 19:26:48

#42 livilion

I stand corrected. The "best small country" was at Glasgow as you trecked to baggage reclaim.

The signs at Prestwick are or were "pure, dead , brilliant" which must be utterly confusing to anybody who didn't learn their English from the Comedy(sic) Unit at BBC Scotland

44

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 26/08/2007 19:52:54

Welcome to Scotland (Sorry about the British Imigration and Customs con trolls)

45

Angus Lindsay,

Hong Kong 26/08/2007 19:55:02

#40. FLUB

"it's never Sunni in Scotland! Boom, boom!"

OK, Basil, but it's often the other on a dreich November-Feb day!

46

thomas,

midlothian 26/08/2007 20:25:09

timw1234 #28
you sad little person. flag waving is toxic is it ?
anything that happens O CANADA and there is a sea of red flags everywhere!
by the way, which third world country does canada model itself on?

47

RedSwanie,

26/08/2007 21:11:49

37. livilion: Thanks for that mate. You made me LOL. Brilliant post!

48

Seamus,

Top o the world ma... 26/08/2007 22:20:12

I wish I was young enogh to get to feck the hell out of here and do something abroad, this country is going to the dogs, knives, guns, gang culture.... slogans aint gonna change it. We have a huge problem of an underclass that think nothing of taking a life, thats going to take decades to change and will probably wom't. I despair for our children.

49

Eve,

Scotland 26/08/2007 22:41:05

Was it No con to begin with?

(Sorry have just read headline)

Odd that in the Sunday Hearlad today they had anartcle claiming that Scotland was the best wee country in the world when it came to science.

Science is braw & so is Scotland.

50

,

26/08/2007 23:39:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 908597, Article id was mapped to record!
51

Paul Mack,

Mandela Towers, Hades. 27/08/2007 05:07:42

Moreover, one of the many scandals that will be uncovered in thirty years time will be the amount of public money, Jack gave to his cronies belonging to advertising agencies and his erstwhile employers, passing themselves off as 'lobbyists'. During his tenure the slogan should have ran, 'Best Wee Corrupt Nation in the World'.
Bridget's diary must read like a Mafiosi ledger.

52

Bobo,

27/08/2007 08:14:08

Another bit of McConnell's legacy chipped away.

53

Wullie McGumph,

Paisley 27/08/2007 17:33:56

Jack McConnell should've been charged under the trades description act for that slogan.

54

Brian Hill,

27/08/2007 19:14:58

Well played Alex.

55

Lee 99,

Kyle 28/08/2007 00:14:58

"Any suggestions you opinionated, crabby, intellectually poised (sometimes) Scots?"

Aye: "Blame it on Canada"

56

Mr Pink,

28/08/2007 09:19:03

But Scotland is the best wee nation in the world!

Look at Social Mobility for example, where else could a drunken football ned become Justice Minister within 8 years!

Here's tae us! Wha's like us?

The fecking joke is on us!

57

Honest Jock,

Leith 30/08/2007 10:18:28

What is should have said was we are the best wee subserviant and self deluded nation in the world


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Is Bum the dog worthy of being commemorated with a statue in Edinburgh?
Yes, he triumphed over adversity and brightened children’s lives
No, there are more worthy – and human – candidates
No, this town’s not big enough for two famous dogs

Web Links:

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.