Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Expenses row MP to quit seat

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 May 2009
THE expenses scandal engulfing British politics claimed its biggest Conservative scalp last night after a former aide to David Cameron announced he would be stepping down as an MP.
Andrew MacKay, the MP for Bracknell, declared he would not seek re-election at the next general election, claiming the furore over his expenses would act as a "distraction".

"I understand why people are angry," he said. "I hope my decision to step down goes some way to showing my constituents how sorry I am."

MacKay and his wife Julie Kirkbride, another Tory MP, claimed second homes allowance on their London flat, which Kirkbride declared as her main residence so that she could claim expenses on their Worcestershire residence.

The couple used their expenses to pay £1,000 a month in interest on the mortgage for their Westminster apartment, and a further £900 a month to pay off the mortgage on their family home.

This "double-dipping" arrangement meant they were charging the taxpayer for two "second" homes.

The couple also claimed a total of £1,800 for each other's "spousal" travel costs.

He said last night: "Following a conversation with David Cameron this morning, I have decided to step down as candidate for Bracknell."

In further revelations last night, the Sunday Telegraph reported that many of the more than 200 MPs who employ relatives were able to increase their expenses as a result.

They include the senior Scottish LibDem MP Malcolm Bruce, who charged the taxpayer for the cost of two homes because his wife, who works as his office manager, works from home.

MPs usually can only charge for a second home, but between 2006 and 2008, Bruce charged £60,000 on the cost of his London flat, while also charging £3,100 towards the cost of electricity, heating and cleaning at his main constituency home in Torphins, Aberdeenshire.

It also emerged last night that Derek Conway, the Tory MP who lost the Conservative Whip after he employed his son at Westminster, despite there being no evidence that he did any work, claimed taxpayers' money on a family house in Northumberland after telling Commons officials he did parliamentary work there. The home is 330 miles away from his Commons seat of Old Bexley and Sidcup in south-east London.

Kirkbride was also forced to defend herself after the News of the World disclosed that her brother, Ian Kirkbride, stayed at the taxpayer-funded Worcestershire home. She said the brother stayed there to help look after her son.

Meanwhile, Tory activist Daniel O'Docherty, 21, who appeared on social networking site Facebook wearing an Adolf Hitler moustache was yesterday expelled from the party.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 May 2009 11:19 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Politicians' expenses
 
1

Warden Resurrected,

24/05/2009 00:31:44
I hate this man with a passion for his politics. Strange then even I can see the system should have stopped his claim or his wife's claim or anyone's claims when the details of their mortgage were checked for payments to be paid.
2

Observer,,

Glasgow 24/05/2009 00:48:10
1 Yes it must have been a rubber stamping excercise that the Fees Office were running, with no real scrutiny of claims. You don't get that in my work ! Half the time I don't bother claiming because I can't be bothered with the interrogation - a neat way of saving money obviously unknown to Westminster.
3

Observer,,

Glasgow 24/05/2009 00:50:13
I'm not quite sure how he has to resign but the wife remains - they were both at it. Their conduct is staggering when you think about it.
4

Peter Curran,

Kirkliston 24/05/2009 01:06:16
Peter Sissons, of BBC News24, interviewed the Mayoress of Bracknell - Sandie Baily - on the telephone over the Andrew MacKay MP expenses scandal yesterday.

Sandie gets full marks for bewildered and misplaced loyalty and zero marks for political nous. Summoning all the experience of her 37 years as a payroll manager, she stoutly defends the indefensible, but then gets into ever deeper Tory party policy waters when asked whether she thought the Tory Party Leader was wrong to sack MacKay, and had she has lost confidence in David Cameron? The line suddenly went dead. I wonder why? A panic intervention from Tory Central Office, or even the Boy David himself, perhaps? Or maybe Chas Baily, of that ilk?

Poor Sandie! But what the hell happened to the Tory Party PR machine?

All of this would be amusing, if it were not for the fact that these people will soon govern the rickety political entity called the United Kingdon, and will have their fingers on the Trident launch button - Trident, a political, not a miliary weapon, and an ICBM irrelevant to current global politics, but much beloved by unionist politicians and supporters, since it support the jobs bribe for Scotland.

http://moridura.blogspot.com

www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPI_UfKa4vI&eurl=http%3A%2F%2Fmoridura.blogspot.com%2F&feature=player_embedded
5

Warden Resurrected,

24/05/2009 01:17:42
4- What good is a PR machine when first of all the public thinks all members of parliament are at it and then when someone is accused there's no excuses allowed anyway.
6

Anonym,

24/05/2009 03:50:35
It's almost as if they were being engulfed by an expenses row, isn't it?
7

W Smith,

Middle East 24/05/2009 03:51:48
I suppose The Scotsman wasn't going to go into detail on Eric Joyce's expenses.

Better keep the spot light on an Engllish Tory, eh editor?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1186953/This-conversation-cost-160-000-MP-claimed-1m-admits-failed-pay-capital-gains-tax.html

Our Eric 'forgot' to pay 40,000 quid tax on 130,000 pounds profit after selling his house in London.

That was after claiming 120,000 quid on the same house.

Comments from The Scotsman's resident 'expert' Professor John Curtice would be most welcome.
8

Gregor Addison,

Glasgow 24/05/2009 04:18:08
Since we're not allowed to comment on the BNP articles, I'd like to do so here. The BNP as I recall were for getting rid of the Scottish Parliament. What Scotland needs is not the BNP with its campaign leaflets with spitfires on them (or are they Hurricanes?), or UKIP with their campaign leaflets with Winston Churchill on them. What an odd idea of Britishness, almost in keeping with David Starkey's vision. Has Britain had no history since 1945?

I was born in 1966 and became politically aware during Thatcher's Britain - another era that loved to hark back to Churchill and spitfires (or are they Hurricanes?) - and I always wondered why no-one talked about Suez, or Korea. Should all our political decisions nowadays be based on some hackneyed view of the Second World War?

I support the SNP. My girlfriend is German. I support a Scotland that frees itself from the hackneyed stereotypes of the past, whether they be images of 1314 or 1945. I want a Scotland where people have power over decision-making processes, not one where we relinquish power just to affect some ideal of Britishness.

My understanding is that the BNP and UKIP want to get rid of the Scottish Parliament. Maybe some of their supporters can tell me I'm wrong. Maybe some of their supporters, if they have any in Scotland, can tell me what they stand for. I suspect it's not for Scotland, but for an English nationalist conception of Britishness.
9

BOTOB,

24/05/2009 07:05:34
Gregor, 9

Good, provocative post - thanks.

We have much in common.

What we're missing is a man with a plan.
10

dsm68,

glasgow 24/05/2009 07:23:44
the arrogance is shocking. no apology to the public for stealing our money just a typical well worded letter to his people who support him that he has let them down. all we want to hear is sorry. we can then addrerss the real issue later on. but sorry would be a start. arrogance is costing the tories.
11

Cadgers,

Perth 24/05/2009 07:37:13
#9 Well said Gregor, good post.

There are NO mp's who come out of this well. There may be mp's who haven't worked the expenses system but they must have known it was going on and the kept quiet. That in it's self implicates them.
12

,

24/05/2009 07:49:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
13

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 08:23:56
I see from the Independent on Sunday, things are getting even worse for Our Dear Leader, Comrade Broon.
It appears he's asking advice from His Holiness Comrade Blair!!!!

"Gordon Brown has called Tony Blair into Downing Street as he desperately tries to rescue his leadership from a series of crises. The meeting on Thursday lasted more than an hour, coming amid the continuing outcry over MPs' expenses and warnings from ministers that Labour faces its worst performance in decades at next month's local and European elections.

There was also continued speculation that Mr Brown could face a challenge to his leadership in the wake of the double poll on 4 June.

The timing of the meeting, with Mr Brown's future in doubt, triggered talk in Westminster that the premier was asking Mr Blair for help. Sources said that they did not discuss election timing or strategy, but the conversation did cover domestic politics. The day after the talks, it emerged that Mr Brown will launch a "national plan for Britain" as part of his fightback."
14

Linda,

Edinburgh 24/05/2009 08:34:29
Where is the supine Scottish press coverage of Lib Dem Malcolm Bruce employing wife and then claiming thousands on two houses at the one time or Eric Joyce failing to pay £40,000 capital gains tax as reported on front pages of English papers this morning?
15

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 08:40:53
Looks like Jim Devine, of The Connarty Devine Furniture Trading Company, is sinking firmly into the smelly stuff!

This particular smelly stuff will be getting examined by the Polis!!!

From The Herald,

"ONLY A couple of tube stations from Westminster, the apartment blocks on Southwark Bridge Road, central London, seem an ideal home for MPs.

The mile-long stretch between the Thames and South Bank University is also the location for numerous companies of varying sizes.

One such enterprise appears to be Eastern Electrical Ltd, a firm whose name is printed on an invoice submitted as part of Scottish Labour MP Jim Devine's second home claims.


The £2157 repairs bill was dated June 2007 and paid by the Westminster Fees Office a month later, according to Devine's end-of-year allowances statement.

However, a Sunday Herald investigation can reveal that there are serious doubts over whether Eastern Electrical Ltd has ever existed."


NEW LABOUR SLEAZE - WE DO WORKING CLASS FRAUD!!!
16

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 08:43:52
#16 Here's the link to The Herald story.

http://tinyurl.com/p3b4k5
17

A Crofter,

Western Isles 24/05/2009 09:43:39
I see from headlines that Hootsmon has issued grovelling apology to Andrew Brown re cleaning payments.

No comment permitted, presumably so as not to offend Carter-Fock.

One can only imagine the true cost (to the taxpayer) of cleaning up the mess that will result from all those nukes planned by EDF (Andrew) and democratically approved by HM Govt (Gordon).
18

Marian,

24/05/2009 09:51:11
Ref Comment No. 16 - New Labour MP Devine is also alleged to have claimed thousands of pounds of mileage claims and didn't pass most of the money on to his office manager, the actual driver of the car.
19

GM,

24/05/2009 10:08:00
TWENTY HIGHEST EXPENSES CLAIMANTS

Total claims 2005-08 (excluding travel)

Liam Byrne £ 478,536 LABOUR

Joan Ryan £ 469,893 LABOUR

Dan Norris £ 450,985 LABOUR

Shahid Malik £ 446,314 LABOUR

Charlotte Atkins £ 443,244 LABOUR

David Wilshire £ 438,377 TORY

Tom Levitt £ 436,686 LABOUR

Diana Johnson £ 436,632 LABOUR

Fabian Hamilton £ 435,999 LABOUR

Jacqui Smith £ 434,909 LABOUR

Margaret Moran £ 434,456 LABOUR

Ian Austin £ 434,409 LABOUR

A. Rosindell £ 434,149 TORY

Andrew George £ 434,062 LIBDEM

Dawn Butler £ 433,865 LABOUR

Roger Godsiff £ 433,298 LABOUR

Tim Farron £ 433,260 LABOUR

Peter Hain £ 431,905 LABOUR

Norman Lamb £ 431,683 LIBDEM

S. Hesford £ 431,527 LABOUR

Source: The Sunday Times 17.05/09
20

Libertarian!,

24/05/2009 10:25:18
Lying and corruption will never diaappear from our daily lives - UNLESS, ordinary people, who are the genuine backbone of society, make a lasting determined effort to wrest pol;itical power in one way or other, from the rotten Establishmen, who have controlled our lives for centuriest.
21

Tynietiger,

24/05/2009 10:46:59
And what about Labour's John Robertson who claimed £16,600 without a single receipt. See Sunday Times to-day.

However like Alastair Darling he is not engulfed in expenses row according to Scotland on Sunday.

That banner headline only applies to minor indescretiopns by SNP MSPs.
22

Number 6,

Germany 24/05/2009 11:10:25
When will the Scottish Media learn. All this Pravda like censorship is not working. It simply sends readers to other media outlets in search of the truth.

Daily Record News forum STILL down.

STILL no explaination given to it's readers.

It's pathetic.
23

Linda,

Edinburgh 24/05/2009 11:40:04
Re post # 16 and Jim Devine's bogus invoice for the rewiring of his London flat, Did he issue a cheque payable to a non existant company or did he pay cash and thus was a party to defrauding the taxman?

Either way it is a resignation issue and I wait to see if Scotsman publications take up the aspect of the story.
24

Linda,

Edinburgh 24/05/2009 11:42:35
I saw Lib Dem leader useless clegg get a hard time from BBC politics show on accepting £2.5 million from convicted fraudster (who had a record in USA before handing over the money).

TO be even handed , I wait to see if Politics Show tackles Alasdair Darling over flipping his second 4 times in four years in order to claim an extra £10,000.
25

Linda,

Edinburgh 24/05/2009 11:45:23
Will Glenn Campbell ask Lib Dem Alan Beith about Malcolm Bruce's expenses claims?
26

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 12:04:47
#24 Linda,

I fear you'll wait a long time to see the Hootsmon take up any story critical of New Labour Sleaze criminality!

NEW LABOUR SLEAZE - DO AS WE SAY, NOT AS WE DO.
27

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 12:11:29
#24 Linda,

If Devine paid for this 'work' by cheque then fraud has been committed as the company Eastern Electrical have never existed!

Was a bank account opened in a bogus name?
You can't do that without forming a company through Companies Hoose!

So if it was paid cash then the tax people have been defrauded and the work done (if it ever was) might have been done by an unqualified person, which is illegal under HSE rules.

Then there is VAT fraud!


NEW LABOUR SLEAZE - TAKING FRAUD TO A HIGHER LEVEL.
28

Warden Resurrected,

24/05/2009 12:43:17
A crook
http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/news/article-1186940/Mole-blew-whistle-MP-expenses-swashbuckler-7million-trail-debt.html
29

Curley Bill,

24/05/2009 12:43:24
From The Mail:

'The Labour MP who claims the highest expenses in the Commons has confessed that he may have charged £160,000 too much.'

Eric Joyce, come on down!
30

the reporter,

Godalming, Surrey. 24/05/2009 13:32:19
Re; Eastern Electrical Ltd, a search of the companies house website should turn them up if they exist.
Unless it is being confused with GET , Great eastern trading, which is an electrical materials supplier.Also if they have carried out the work since January 2005, they will under Part P, have had to issued certification and registered the work with their Part P administering body, who in turn would 1; have issued a certificate to the client who had the work done and 2; notified the building control dept of the local authority, can any of that be proved ?
Im an electrician by the way !
31

Nikostratos,,

24/05/2009 13:33:44
jimmy the pie

is alluding to the fact the

snp admits to low level fraud...but say they want to be in power a little bit longer before they....start the big fiddles..

Alex is holding a two day workshop later this year...

entitled....

The Scottish Nation and how the nationalist's can steal and thieve from the Scottish peoples......


32

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 14:02:00
#32

Excellent post.

That's sure to drive voters away from the SNP into the clutches of the cheating, lying, fraudulent, unionist parties!!!!


You might be deluded but at last the public are wakening up to the unionist lies.

SNP - The ONLY party for ALL the people of Scotland!!
33

Scotfree,

Erskine 24/05/2009 16:16:40
#23 The Pravda like censorship might not be entirely the work of the Scottish press but may be originating at the individual at the centre of this corruption, Gordon Brown. It would appear from the story “Andrew Brown an apology“ that Gordon Brown is using the resources of EDF energy, through his brother, to silence the press on the most disturbing story to come out of this corruption regarding the financial relationship between Gordon Brown and EDFs main parliamentary lobbyist Andrew Brown.
As I said when this story first came out.
“One might reasonably ask why a prime minister has a business relationship with the major lobbyist for EDF energy, paying for cleaning in a flat he does not use. Browns brothers lobbying for EDF energy has resulted in a 2.5 billion pound order for nuclear power stations. We have also witnessed, through the labour criminal network including Brian Wilson, Foulkes, Murphy and the Scotsman, their lobbying to force Scotland to accept the extension of the Nuclear build to Scotland. This is real corruption but as the Scottish press is party too, it will never be properly investigated.”
34

Warden Resurrected,

24/05/2009 16:23:00
33- I pie with my little eye something beginning with F – FEAR. Dictatorship comes easy as an idea to you in your only one party rhetoric. Control freaks all together.
35

,

24/05/2009 16:23:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
36

,

24/05/2009 16:24:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
37

,

24/05/2009 16:25:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
38

Warden Resurrected,

24/05/2009 16:25:35
Paranoia is howling at the moon
39

,

24/05/2009 16:27:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

Ewan Randall,

24/05/2009 16:38:51
Why is it when some people talk about the English media on here they seem to as an insult and yet are only too happy to use their findings for what would seem to be their benefit?
41

Jimmy Le Pie,

24/05/2009 17:00:59
#41 Ewan,

Who would that be then??
42

,

24/05/2009 20:25:18
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

im brian and so is my wife,

edinburgh 25/05/2009 08:26:07
am i right in thinking he will get a lump sum,to cushion the loss of income,or is that only for those ,who fail at the ballot box,to be returned as an MP?
also fat pension as well,and no doubt payment for story as well
should get hee haaww as hes had more than enough

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.