Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Cardinal slams politicians for creed of greed

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 31 May 2009
SCOTLAND'S most senior Catholic clergyman has attacked the greed of politicians as he stepped into the row over the lavish expenses claimed by Westminster MPs.
Cardinal Keith O'Brien is today expected to call on politicians to live up to the high standards that the public expects when he comments for the first time on the Westminster allowance system that has undermined trust in politicians.

In a homily
to be preached by the Cardinal at St Mary's Cathedral, Edinburgh, O'Brien will warn of the dangers of the "love of money".

He will say: "People have been shattered at what we might call the fall from grace of many called to serve in politics and public life, with money at the root of many difficulties.

"On behalf of very many suffering and bewildered people, I call on those in public service of whatever kind who have failed us to reclaim the high standards which we expect of them and to give the example required of them to all in our country, however difficult it might be to implement this."

O'Brien's intervention comes as the expenses row continues unabated with yet more revelations about the claims made by MPs.

Last night it emerged that Conservative leader David Cameron paid off a loan on his London home shortly after taking out a £350,000 taxpayer-funded mortgage on his constituency house.

The Tory leader took out the mortgage to buy a house in Oxfordshire in August 2001, two months after winning his Witney seat in the General Election. By nominating it as his second home, he was able to claim for the mortgage interest payments under the Commons' Additional Costs Allowance (ACA).

Just four months after securing the £350,000 mortgage, Cameron paid off the £75,000 loan on his London home. Cameron has not broken any rules, but financial experts claim that taxpayers could have been saved £22,000 between 2002 and 2007 had he kept the loan on his London home and borrowed £75,000 less on the Oxfordshire property.

Labour MP Frank Cook apologised for attempting to claim for a £5 donation he made during a church service to commemorate the Battle of Britain. Cook said: "I don't know how it happened, it is wrong that it happened, I can't explain it and I am sorry that is has happened. I can't give any better explanation because I don't have one." The Commons' authorities rejected his claim.

And Charles Kennedy, the former Liberal Democrat leader, claimed taxpayer-funded expenses for two teddy bears and mints from the House of Commons shop.

Kennedy said the claim had been submitted in error and the money repaid earlier this month.

Yesterday, shadow justice minister Eleanor Laing, who did not pay capital gains tax on the profit from selling her taxpayer-funded second home, insisted she had followed Inland Revenue rules.

Laing was reported to have avoided a £180,000 bill by designating her London flat as her "principal" residence for tax purposes. It was claimed that she made £1 million profit on the sale of the property, which was listed as her second home with the Commons authorities and therefore eligible for allowances.

Laing was reported to have claimed more than £80,000 from the public purse towards mortgage interest and service payments on two flats she bought in Westminster, even though her constituency home was less than an hour away.

She decided it would have been wrong under the HM Revenue and Customs' Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 to pay capital gains tax on her London flat, because it was considered her principal residence under HMRC rules.

The fresh revelations about MPs' expenses arrangements came as the former Labour minister Elliot Morley, the Scunthorpe MP, became the 13th MP to quit following the scandal. Morley – who claimed £16,800 of taxpayers' cash for a mortgage he had already paid off – announced he was stepping down at the next election.

David Cameron has said that the police ought to investigate MPs who used taxpayers' money to pay for "phantom mortgages".





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 31 May 2009 12:05 AM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Politicians' expenses
 
1

Paul Mack,

Paisley 31/05/2009 00:39:20
I note in the Subo Gazette that the Baroness of Craigielea has charged the taxpayer £245 a month for having the windows of an office cleaned which boasts only 'twa portholes'.
Why 245? Well if it was 250 she would have to provide a receipt. Five pounds just below the declaration code.
Does this ploy sound familiar? It should.
Wendy Alexander is the MSP for the same area.
The present occupant of the locus, a hard working hairdresser, who incidentally has been warned by the
Inland Revenue that tips have to be declared, gets the same service for a fiver.
Read the Paisley Distress and you're treated to a daily diet of Paisley Procurator Fiscals Office
pursuing with uncharacteristic alacrity Mrs. Macublican for taking the proceeds of the tombola from the Tallahatchie PTA.
A Mrs. Patel from Harrow is being prosecuted for fraud, having given the council the wrong address, in the hope that she could provide her son with a decent education. Can't we use the same legal process for our errant MPs.
Shouldn't Knacker of the Yard be paying the Baroness a visit? Or as many of us in Paisley have suspected for years Mrs. Irene Adams, former honourable member for Paisley North, is immune from prosecution.
My first exposure to Craigielea was in the poems of Robert Tannahill. Visit that part of Paisley today which pays homage to 'Thou Bonnie Wood of Craigielea' and you couldn't find a more startling contrast. The weans are eating putty aff the windies - not pocketing 240 bats every time they look out of them.
Tannahill would surely have had something to say about the personal wealth and crass indifference shown by the Baroness and the plight of those she ostensibly represents.
Awa! ye thoughtless murd'ring gang,
Wha tear the nestlings ere they flee;
To lift us from this endless misery, can we have the name of the window cleaner, not out of any sense of
retribution, quite the reverse. I want to shake this woman's hand. Oops! I shouldn't be sexist. It could be a man. Aye
2

Paul Mack,

Paisley 31/05/2009 00:42:41
Aye write.
Given the nations appetite for business types imparting their acumen and sharing with us their secret of success, we have to know who this girrl is.
Anyone who can get 240 quid for a service everyone one else pays a fiver for, has to be the greatest sales guru on the planet.
Move over Alan Sugar. You're Fired!
3

im brian and so is my wife,

edinburgh 31/05/2009 01:11:17
could be,the cleaner is bill gates,thats why its so dear
secondary school leavers ,have been asking,how they get a job as a MP,as the pay and pension,is the best
career officers ,are trying to muscle in as they too want the job
lord foulkes will teach school kids ,how to get free feeds and rake in up to 5 wage packets,and insult a bbc employee live on tv,just for having the gall to ask the truth
4

JaE_in_Oz,

31/05/2009 06:38:06
It is ironic that the Catholic Church chooses to attack politicians about failing to exhibit high standards. They should devote their energies to their sexual abuse by clergy and religious orders problems before pontificating. Once this is completely eliminated, the guilty brought to justice and the victims properly compensated they may regain enough standing to be credible in criticising politicians. Nobody has been physically injured as a result of politicians overclaiming expenses.
5

Pocket Dictionary,

31/05/2009 06:55:36
Gearge Orwell said: Political language... is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind.
6

donald,

glasgow 31/05/2009 07:28:13
All of the Churches in Scotland are to the left of Labour. Then, so are the Brownies.
7

S'me,

Edinburgh 31/05/2009 07:49:14
Well cardinal... enjoy YOUR priveliges while many of your parishioners struggle day to day..
8

Queen D,

31/05/2009 09:21:55
From Guido this morning,
Multi-millionaire Labour backbencher Mohammed Sarwar claimed £100,000 to cover mortgage interest that he paid from an account with a Swiss bank. Tax needn’t be taxing…
9

Iain Mac,

31/05/2009 09:52:13
Aye, Westminster's politicians are corrupt but the Catholic church is hardly a model of morality. It has great wealth and it is horrific to visit places like Italy which has cathedrals full of gold next to crowded slums.

And as to corruption, how many child abuse cases has the Catholic church swept under the carpet?
10

Jmhzx,

brighton 31/05/2009 10:05:46
what does Cardinal O'Brien think he can add to this?

a single man who lives in a palatial mansion in the Grange, paid for by his 'constituents' who aren't even allowed to vote for him or remove him....

meanwhile thousands of Scots live rough, sleep in hostels or live in appalling conditions.

Bl**dy old hypocrite!!!!
11

Vivas,

Edinburgh 31/05/2009 10:07:37
From the same church that offers up marital, sexual and emotional advice from celibate priests.

Thats right, they don't have a scooby !
12

mr broon,

Edinburgh 31/05/2009 10:26:30
Like others, the Cardinal has every right to comment about the current political scandal.

However, the Cardinal leaves himself, and his church, open to accusations of hypocrisy in view of the recent high-profile scandal involving the widespread sexual, physical, emotional, and economic abuse of vulnerable children and adults, in over 260 institutions run by Roman Catholic religious orders in Ireland.

AS the Cardinal well knows, if he made similar criticisms of governments in many other countries he would be slapped down!

France, a nominally Catholic State, does not allow the Catholic, or any other church, to interfere in any way in the governing of the country?

After the overt support provided by the Roman Catholic
Church to the wartime facist Vichy regime when hundreds of thousands of French Jews were transported and sent to Vichy and Nazi concentration camps with the full knowledge of the Church, the post-war Republic changed its constitution, and completely abolished the powers of the Catholic Church.

Since then any attempts by the Roman Catholic Church to interfere in French politics are met with further constitutional legislation, in agreement with the
French people. (Source: Irish Times)
13

Media at One,

31/05/2009 13:29:05
Oh my goodness, now we have the man in the pointy hat telling government what they should be doing.
Maybe he should get on with praying to his god and gathering funds from unsuspecting sinners - HYPOCRITE
14

Scotsman in Dublin,

31/05/2009 22:12:10
Well Cardinal O'Brien, people in glass houses?
15

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 31/05/2009 23:00:24
This geezer sounds a little bit in the same righteous department as Herr Braun, reportedly "shocked" at some of the revelations about his own party members' expenses. Err, of course that's not to speak of his own deviations in this area. However, as far as we know anyway Braun has not quite got into the same league as the Church in terms of kiddy-fiddling.
16

senza nome,

31/05/2009 23:20:32
11: "Palatial mansion?" I'ts a big hoose but in no way palatial.In fact, it's quite shabby.I've been in it.The house was donated by somebody, so his "constituents" are not paying for it.
17

Jim Baxter RIP,

Sai Kung, Hong Kong 01/06/2009 04:28:22
Dear Cardinal,

Are you having a laugh ?
18

Koffindodger,

Edinburgh 01/06/2009 11:32:51
17senza nome

Is that supposed to be a defence of the cardinal's/church's position?

"its a bit run doon so its no worth as much so its allright?

Sell the House, buy a flat suitable to his station and requirements (west end/ newtown etc) and donate the substantial remainder to the poor. Thats assuming the church doesn't already own loads of property already meeting that description.

Note someone donated the building to the church so the church instead of saying "thanks a lot, that's just perfect for us to stick a single elderly gentleman in" they should "pay it forward".
19

Eve,

Scotland 01/06/2009 12:57:00
Don't think it matters who says it!!!

Lets face facts no one is happy with the Westminster administration at present expect maybe a few MP's.

The MP's involved will only believe how unpopular their greed has been when they are voted out or force to stand down!!!

It's clear that some people care more about money and power than anything else. It's a sad world!!!
20

Eve,

Scotland 01/06/2009 13:05:15
#1 Labour lies: Shocking stuff!!!

£2,326.00 is a lot of money for putting up shelves in an office. May be they were made form a special material which is invisible to the eye and feels like thin air when you walk in to it.#

Mmm I wonder if Jim Devine is look for anymore employees cause the pay sounds fantastic. LOL
21

Ken Mac,

Glasgow 02/06/2009 08:30:58
'And Charles Kennedy, the former Liberal Democrat leader, claimed taxpayer-funded expenses for two teddy bears and mints from the House of Commons shop.
Kennedy said the claim had been submitted in error and the money repaid earlier this month.'

Ok, explain to me how you make a claim for two teddy bears in error.

'Labour MP Frank Cook apologised for attempting to claim for a £5 donation he made during a church service to commemorate the Battle of Britain. Cook said: "I don't know how it happened, it is wrong that it happened, I can't explain it and I am sorry that is has happened. I can't give any better explanation because I don't have one.'

Let me help you out, you are an immoral, cheap, lying, thieving b******. Does that clarify it for you Mr Cook.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.