Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Plan for blanket Aids screening, as one in four carriers don't know they have HIV

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 November 2008
SCOTLAND is planning to introduce universal screening for HIV, it was claimed last night.
A leading public health expert said government officials were discussing the proposal, which many medics believe would slow the spread of Aids.

Jim Sherval, of NHS Lothian, said the move was being considered ahead of the launch of a national HIV
strategy in the spring, according to reports. The idea, he said, was "under active discussion".

More than one in four HIV carriers across the UK are believed to be unaware they have the virus, which causes Aids. The figure was as high as one in three of HIV-positive gay men tested in a recent Edinburgh study.

Most experts believe HIV testing should be automatic in areas where the virus is most common.

David Johnston, director of Edinburgh HIV charity Waverley Care, said: "It may well be that GP practices in some areas should definitely be looking at proactively offering an HIV test to every new patient who registers, and I think that would be a helping way forward in terms of thinking about how to maximise people's chances of living well with HIV."

Glasgow has the highest level of undiagnosed HIV in Britain, according to the Medical Research Council. The UK Health Protection Agency has called for automatic screening in any area where official HIV levels run at two or more per 1,000. Such levels, however, have not been reached anywhere in Scotland. NHS Lothian has the highest official prevalence of the virus, at between 1.5 and 1.99 per 1,000.

The Lancet last week published a study showing that universal testing – if combined with immediate treatment for anyone found to be positive – would cut the number of new HIV cases by 95% in a decade.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 November 2008 1:02 AM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 30/11/2008 02:17:51

"Blanket Aids Screening"

I can see the reasoning, but I also see it as an invasion of privacy and one of stereotyping, certain communities, infact this has already been quoted,...

..."GP practices in some areas should definitely be looking at proactively offering an HIV test to every new patient who registers"

What "Areas"?, Why?

Soo are you saying as you must be, no-one, say in Ravelston Dykes in Edinburgh, would be tested?

Have these "Health Experts" never in their education learnt what "Stereotyping" means?

It is, quite simply, a 'Breach of Human Rights'!

Again I can see a little "Reasoning",..

But!,....'Bogg-Off', comes to mind!

2

Hairdrier,

Edinburgh 30/11/2008 12:03:22
It's not clear what blanked screening would achieve when the figures clearly show that HIV infections occur in specific subgroups, e.g. MSMs - with many unaware they are infected.

Also, there is a ticking time bomb in the heterosexual community - with a steep rise in numbers bringing in the virus from Africa.

Surely targeting these 2 groups is the way forward, difficult as this may seem.
3

wheels5894,

30/11/2008 12:25:46
I think we need to remove the moral and other questions from this and consider it in the same way as any other deadly disease. If there are carriers out there, we have to find them and treat them for the sake of reducing suffering and death of those they might meet.

Tackling the most likely groups and testing them is all very well but the virus can and does get into others too so I can't quite see why a blanket testing approach where all those with the virus are found and treated can be objected to. Surely people ought to know what diseases they have and get treatment.
4

Hairdrier,

Edinburgh 30/11/2008 15:02:31
Early HIV infection is frequently asymptomatic - in contrast to 'lesser' STIs - hence why people don't know they are infected.

A common sense approach is needed to tackle what is definitely a growing problem in Scotland: screening everyone is pointless when HIV prevalence is high in small, but identified, subgroups.

If, on the other hand, the virus spreads into the heterosexual community at large, as it looks it might, then blanket screening makes sense in addition to targeting groups with high prevalence. The cost of not doing anything at this stage could be a high one.




5

Mcsnagpile,

30/11/2008 17:15:30
If you have a high risk encounter it could take up to six months before it will show in a test. During that time you could have infected many people. so only continued repeated screening can be really effective in the long term.
6

truthsleuth,

01/12/2008 00:08:27
Go abroad the UK government are proposing to give £6billion in Aid for HIV
What an absolute waste of money money we cannot afford

We are no doubt giving some to India to help them divert their funds to get rockets into space and fund a nuclear war with Pakistan.

No doubt some will go to Africa to fund more extra sexual activity and increase the funds going into African rulers Swiss bank accounts and armaments to fight tribal wars.

Meanwhile pensioners cannot get proper care (South of the Border anyway) and cancer patients nor other sufferers get the expensive medication for their illnesses.

Its about time British governements realised WE CANNOT AFFORD IT NOW AND NEVER HAVE BEEN ABLE TO AFFORD IT.

Spend the money at home first we already fund thousands of NHS tourists.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.