Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Aidan Smith: "They didn't have a Messi; only a Kirk Broadfoot"

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 May 2008
A COUPLE OF days have passed so by now it must have sunk in. You can't keep putting off your decision; you've got to face up to your responsibilities. Can you do it? Dare you do it? Are you big enough and ugly enough to cheer on Rangers in the UEFA Cup Final?
All over the country – everywhere that isn't Govan – Scots are asking themselves this question. We don't have many claims to football fame, but surely this is the game's most urgent inquiry right now. Those who don't understand football's subtleties
– and of course its perversities – will wonder why, as Scots, we're not automatically supporting the Scottish team. Oh that things were quite so simple.

Rangers exist to be the bogeyman of Scottish football. Actually, that's not the whole story. For their supporters, they're objects of devotion and I wouldn't dare suggest it's not absolute. Every second Saturday the faithful converge on Ibrox to pay homage to their heroes. They're there from kick-off right up until 15 minutes before the final whistle because, well, who wants to get stuck in traffic? But for the rest of us, Rangers are objects of derision. Just as a pantomime needs a villain – a giant slavering club-footed baby-eating monster – so the SPL needs Rangers.

We love to hate them. We moan about dodgy penalties, young talent being spirited away in the dead of night, the creepy unScottishness of Ibrox. We claim the SPL would be a better place if Rangers moved to the Premiership but the truth is we'd miss them. It would be like the political situation, post-devolution: who would we have to blame? (And I don't know why I made the analogy with England there, really I don't).

Back in October, when Barcelona's Lionel Messi accused Rangers of playing "anti-football", the rest of us chorused: "Tell us something we don't know!" Even some Rangers fans didn't like the style, or non-style, of play – especially when the solitary-striker routine was repeated at home against Inverness.

In Europe at least Walter Smith could argue that Rangers had to play to their strengths. They didn't have a Lionel Messi; they only had a Kirk Broadfoot. As they kept winning, it was rarely pretty. But the effect was weirdly hypnotic. Even the doubters began to wonder: "How far can they go without flair/ depending on defence/ sneaking an away goal/ holding on for the penalty shootout?" And even the dissenters were anxious to find out.

This is where the perversity comes in. We may have concurred with Messi, but when Rangers became the subject of a bizarre scientific experiment we were hooked. In the manner of beagles being forced to puff on Capstan Full Strength, David Weir and Carlos Cuellar were bombarded with crosses. How many could they head away before feeling woozy and turning green?

They're still standing, and the lab technicians are stunned. Smoking kills but it is possible for a Scottish team – six of last Thursday's line-up were home-grown – to reach a Euro final. And where's Messi? Barcelona never made their final. He may be a great player but he's not a great prophet. He's not the Messi, he's just a very naughty boy.

So, come on then, are you going to help make May 14 Honorary Bears' Day? I can see the issue – to support Rangers or not – dominating debate. It'll become another test of politicians' vision of a "modern, inclusive Scotland". Politcos will get involved and they'll only end up making fools of themselves, much like Tony Blair did when he harangued Scots for not supporting England at the last World Cup.

But guess what? The last people to be bothered about it will be the real Rangers fans. Celtic supporters in this situation would get paranoid. But those who follow, follow the boys in light blue won't lose any sleep. They'll just climb under their Union Jack duvets, turn off their Lee McCulloch nightlights and sing themselves off to Dreamland with a favourite lullaby: "We are Rangers, no one likes us, we don't care."





Page 1 of 1

 
1

,

04/05/2008 01:16:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Billy Mason,

London 04/05/2008 01:20:37
A bigoted article written by a complete bigot.
Ibrox un-Scottish?
Sorry, your forename might be un-Scottish, but Ibrox? No Ibrox is a symbol of Scotland to real Scots all over the world.
It resonates with the history of the Scots from the surnames of the followers who fill it each week, to the very blood that flows through their veins.
The blood that fought for our religious, intellectual and political freedoms, and forged the nation that allows you free will to spill your venom in ink.
I feel your pain.
3

Teary Ennui,

04/05/2008 01:21:17
You certainly need to dry your eyes, adsum. But not for that reason! If anything could add to the joy of reaching a European final at this stage, it would be watching folk like you and James stew in your jealousy. :0)
4

Manchester here we come,

Glasgow 04/05/2008 01:26:18
oh dear Aidan, I feel your pain. As a well known ITV4 commentator said in Lisbon "this isn't anti-football, this is intelligent football"

The funny thing about all this is - for a team who supposedly play "anti-football", we have reached the final having played by far superior opposition as to what Celtic did when they got to Seville.

The fact is, we are there and quite frankly the SPL and co better not have the cheek to congratulate us considering they have bowed to Celtics' demands and have forced us to play a hectic fixture schedule. Compare that to Russia's FA and the way they have postponed Zenit's games before the final. Dick Advocaat even said today in the Daily Rhecord what we all know about this country.

Also, as a journalist said today on the radio, Rangers have received nowhere near the same amount of praise Celtic did when they got to Seville yet Rangers have played far better sides.

I'm sure all the journalists who have criticised us the whole way through this campaign will not be wanting to go to Manchester and watch yet more "anti-football" . . .

Rant Over





5

Manchester here we come,

Glasgow 04/05/2008 01:37:02
Aidan, just another wee point in your article . .

"We love to hate them. We moan about dodgy penalties, young talent being spirited away in the dead of night, the creepy unScottishness of Ibrox."

I really hope you are not claiming Rangers receive dodgy penalties considering how referees have more than helped Celtic this season.

Falkirk away, Celtic win 1-0 - Falkirk had 3 stonewallers denied, McManus breaks a guys leg with a horror tackle, McDonald's goal offside

St Mirren, Celtic win 1-0 - dodgy free kick with a few minutes left given by Eddie Smith, the same man who travelled with Celtic to Barcelona just days later . .

Rangers at Parkhead 2-1 - Robson, Hesselink, Hartley should all have seen red no doubt about it, then we had the incident in the 94th minute where Hesselink decides to bear hug Cousin inside the box yet the ref and linesman who had clear view, both turned a blind eye.

Rangers at Parkhead 3-2 - McDonald goal offside, Caldwell handles ball inside box twice, Hesselink once again should have been off, 3rd goal was never a penalty as the incident took place outside the box and even at that McDonald wasn't even looking at the ball and instead jumped infront of Broadfoot who could have claims for obstruction.

Aberdeen 2 weeks ago 1-0 Celtic - Zander Diamond scores a perfectly good goal right at the end yet it is strangely disallowed for handball even though his hands were by his side when he first headered the ball . .

Motherwell today, Celtic 2-1 - Celtics winner came from a corner that should never have been


Now Aidan, could you point out to me any decisions that have went in Rangers' favour this season, other than the 6 good goals we've had disallowed throughout the course, one which cost us points at Tannadice in the 2-1 defeat with Cousin scoring . . .


Also - how can you say Ibrox is 'unscottishness'? Don't you ever see the Saltire being carried out onto the park before every game, or the one flying above the stad
6

Arthur Teak ,

Edinburgh 04/05/2008 01:50:45
Aiden Smith, oh yes! For the uninitiated, Aiden Smith is the former editor of the 'Celtc View'. He is also, Scottish but would claim to be Irish (of the Irish Catholic variety). His bigoted, sectarian, twisted bitterness is there for all to read. What amazes me is that I can still be annoyed by the fact that a so-called quality rag like 'The Scotsman' can allow excreta like this into print. By comparison The Sunday Herald fires a journalist for a mild and humourous criticism of a football club's fans...but then again, the complainant was Peter Lawwell, the 'bete noire' of the Scottish Sports media and the club Celtic FC, so, in truth no real surprise, there.

In Aidain Smith's philosophy, Celtic and by extension Roman Catholics (preferably of Irish descent) and the Roman Catholic church can do no wrong and The Rangers -for he lacks the courage to have a go at the Church of Scotland and other Scottish 'Protestant' institutions - can do no right.

To recap: Smith is nothing more than a twisted wee Roman Catholic bigot who would not be given the space to vent his diseased spleen anywhere else but Scotland

It's people like Smith who perpetuate the myth that Scotland is a country rivren with anti - Roman Catholic hatred, when, in fact, he himself is a merchant of hate.
7

Arthur Teak ,

04/05/2008 01:55:50
By 'unscottishness' does Smith mean that if one does not hate the English, one must per se be not properly a Scot? I would not be surprised if he did. This hatred of the Engish by the 'Tartan Army' Scottish types and the 'Plastic Paddies' is as equally foul as any anti-RC bigotry or does this irony elude him?
8

,

04/05/2008 02:02:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

Patrick 162,

04/05/2008 02:04:04
#1 & #2 So you guys will be supporting a Russian team who consciously don't sign black players because of their fans racism. Given Celtic fan's past, that's no surprise to any of us with memories.

#7 Strong stuff, but much, if not all of it, is right. There are those who exaggerate real prejudice for their own agenda, which ironically projects bigotry onto others rather than, more accurately, themselves. Thus, they are riven by their own persecution complexes, become bigots themselves and therefore stir up more bigotry in the minority they so representatively focus upon.

Fortunately, most of us can see this for what it is.
10

,

04/05/2008 02:13:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Patrick 162,

04/05/2008 02:21:28
Poor stuff adsum. You have proven yourself to be an illiterate racist bigot who produces the most poisonous of bile.

Your IP number should be banned, just as your previous IDs were of sectarianism, racism and other forms of bigotry.
12

alanbearno7,

glasgow 04/05/2008 02:29:27
well what can i say. A scottish team makes it to the uefa final and a journalist from a so called reputed newspaper comes out with a column full of negativity. I for one will never buy this rag again and i have been buying it for 15 years. I take it your not friends with the beadrattler journalist from the herald then. I always thought newspaper reporters were impartial but i think the AIDAN gives it away. Shame on you editor of the Scotsman for allowing this utter drivel to be published. Never again will i buy your newspaper
13

kenny mcg,

04/05/2008 03:03:57
#13 Alan, although i agree with your sentiments mate.
dont lower yourself by mentioning the rattling.
Enjoy what is a splendid time to be a Bluenose. Any negative comments at all from any source is merely sour grapes. Gers have done what they had to do. It has proved successful although not pretty.
As mentioned in my other post, we can only p1ss with the kok we've got. If we had the millions that Man U, Chelsea etc have, the football would be undoubtably be better.

Looking forward to Manchester

Follow Follow
14

WJR,

Leith 04/05/2008 03:06:45
#7 Was it not Andrew Smith who was the editor of the Celtic View? Is Aidan not a Hibee?
15

AntiGreenian,

04/05/2008 04:46:15
9# idee this must be a really difficult time in your life, n'est ce pas?
16

AntiGreenian,

150,000 Marching to Manchester 04/05/2008 04:48:07
Editor (if you exist): I guess the above was written by Pat Snivel. Isn't time to employ proper journos?

Even John Rafferty was objective.
17

Celtic Forever,

No-one likes them, they don't care 04/05/2008 04:52:45
What a great headline...kinda sums this lot up.

Celtic have shown how to beat them, twice in the last few week and when the wee greens do it again today this lot will fall apart.

rangers are rubbish, even their own fans know it
18

Bill Turnbull,

10 days from Bearchester 04/05/2008 07:14:25
Once and for all we dont care what the bitter bigots from the piggery say and that includes you Mr Aiden Smith

All of the bears can feel the pain and hurting keep it coming I love it
19

beeree,

04/05/2008 07:39:49
Adsum & co

Not only bluenoses are laughing at you. I'm loving the bile that mentions of Manchester are invoking.

However you should perhaps be facing a mirror when you mention racism and face reality
20

wayne bijlyeerheid,

04/05/2008 10:09:52
Just how deluded are the celtc minded?
You have to ask just how closed is the circle that this "journalist" lives in and exactly what nationality he is.
He thinks Rangers' supporters are only around Govan, and he thinks that "Scots" have some sort of problem supporting Rangers.
The only "Scots" who have problems with Rangers are those who think that the tricolour of the RoI is our national flag.
Thew only thing he said that rings true is >Celtic supporters in this situation would get paranoid.<
21

wayne bijlyeerheid,

04/05/2008 10:12:17
celtc don't even have a Broadfoot, only a Naylor
22

Magnet,

04/05/2008 10:26:13
Aiden Smith
When 18 agrees with you .... then you know that you must be talking garbage !
23

James fae blantyre,

04/05/2008 10:40:04
My goodness. Aren't the blue/orange noses a little sensitive this morning. A very interesting article which in no way can be described as bigoted.

It is also unsurprising that because the rangers fans don't like what they read, they immediately start to have a go at the writers religion.

The funny thing is, this article was not written by ex-celtic view editor Andrew Smith, but by Aiden Smith, a man who has no connection with celtic football club.

Real irony that the writer is being described as a bigot by people who ignorantly label him as a Roman Catholic. And in this wonderful country of ours, this is enough to condemn a man.

It is straight from the minds of the morons who burned down the home of a Paediatrician thinking that he was a child molester.

This land is our land and we are so proud
24

wayne bijlyeerheid,

04/05/2008 11:05:05
Aiden Smith is a Hibs supporter I believe.
#24
The writer of the article is coming from an Irish Catholic viewpoint, his hatred of Rangers and their supporters is because, unlike him and his circle, they are perceived as Protestants
Bit like yourself, otherwise you wouldn't have mentioned "blue/orange noses.
How does the "Scotsman" and "Scotland on Sunday" expect to keep bigots off the postings when their stories have nothing to do with football and everything to do with sectarian hate and envy?
25

James fae blantyre,

04/05/2008 11:12:50
"Aiden Smith is a Hibs supporter I believe."

Not even sure!!!!

And this is enough to make the assumption that he must be of Irish Catholic stock, and therefore he hates protestants.

Good God, can you not see how prejudiced and bigoted this viewpoint is.

Please Please Please, do not have children.
26

,

04/05/2008 11:24:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
27

wayne bijlyeerheid,

04/05/2008 11:42:30
#26
"Aiden Smith is a Hibs supporter I believe."
Is quite a common way, in the English language, to put a statement. I am pretty sure of it but not having the massive filing library in my head that the celtc-minded have, I am prepared to be corrected.
That doesn't alter the fact that the writer is coming from an Irish Catholic viewpoint.
He has chosen to write a story that has nothing to do with football and everything to do with how people like him view Rangers and their supporters, we are entitled to reply.
The fact that you have nothing to say but come out with "blue/orange noses" suggests someone whose hate is not just based on Rangers' defensive tactics.
Too late for me not to have children sonny.
Perhaps you can give that advice to your fellow supporter at #27
28

James fae blantyre,

04/05/2008 11:52:13
Come on. Let's not beat about the bush. You hate Roman Catholics, don't you?

Why?
29

Braesbear,

04/05/2008 12:07:13
I am utterly disgusted that a quality publication like scotland on sunday can print such a meaningless article.

The sheer nastinessness of the article has left me stunned and I cannot quite believe that the editor has permitted publication. It is outrageous that a platform should be provided for Aidan Smith (a legendary wit in his own mind) to spout these views. No doubt there are those who would suggest that this is humorous but I for one am not laughing. I hope Mr Murray or Mr Bain take action against this rag, they deservre it.

On the other hand I do take some comfort at Geetin Faced Aidan Smiths article as it highlights the pain felt by those who follow the mhanky mob.

Has NN/Idee Fixe/Adsum finally come out from under his stone in to the public domain?
30

The best-Rangers,

04/05/2008 12:09:29
Aids ridden your racist w4nk. What of the un Scottishness of celtc park? The pro terrorist celtc fans?

James, it's their church that has earnt animosity over the centuries. Stop sucking in their bullcrap for one moment and you'd have to agree.
31

BigRon,

04/05/2008 12:11:04
I`m no fan of either of the old firm but I wish all the best to Rangers in the final. They have put in courageous performances right the way through the competition and have done Scotland proud.
And Mr Smith for your information the Gers had the best ever Scottish player of all time, Jim Baxter, who was an artist with the ball, so Mr Smith don`t presume to talk for all non Rangers fans.
32

Jimmy Pop,

04/05/2008 12:20:37
Wow, ex-employee of the Celtic View in 'Not Liking Rangers' shocker.

Sadly, this piece would have been more appropriate in that publication.

Aidan, thanks very much. I feel your pain, and frankly, i'm enjoying it.
33

Still Believing,

04/05/2008 12:20:38
Aiden Smith - what a bitter sad individual you are.

Are you one of the guys who have been predicting that rangers would lose every round? Are you hurting this morning? It certainly seems like it.

Would you have dared to write a similar story about celtc when they were en route to seville? I doubt it.

In every civilised country the whole press would be behind their team. It seems like only in this sad parochial little country that a large number of the media will produce sniping belittling negative stories like this.

Scotsman, hang your head in shame.
34

The best-Rangers,

04/05/2008 12:30:08
More from aidsridden...

http://tinyurl.com/5hcbap

35

,

04/05/2008 12:38:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
36

Fred in sunny Sydney,

sydney 04/05/2008 12:54:00
similar to the old saying about england, but there are two teams most non old fimr fans support, their own, and whomever is playing against either of the ugly sisters that day.

c'mon the ruskies
37

Magnet,

04/05/2008 12:55:20
More proof that the Scotsman leans to the side of the Celtic minded ! Manchester here we come !
38

Keyboard supporter,

04/05/2008 13:20:57
Laptop loyal indeed!

You could have took the content of this article from numerous "celtic minded (sic)" websites without presumably having to pay for such palpably biased journalism. If it was intended to be humerous then a miserable failure beckons.

Unlike others i don't expect anything from opposing supporters as mutual dislike is the fundamental tenet of rivalry. However to use "anti scottishness" as the stick to which to beat Rangers with, when the obvious leanings of the author are self evident, is incredulous.
His beloved Celtic & their followers may be many things (soap dodging, giro scrounging, coin throwing, skydiving, shellsuit uniformed, monobrowed paranoid, terminally stupid trolls amongst others) but a bastion of "scottishness" they are not - oh thats right "Oirishness" is part of their history isn't it hence we are witness to a tricolour display before the Barca game

Fail Fail
39

Wee Fred,

04/05/2008 18:53:53
It really doesnt surprise me that the tims would want a team whose supporters have been called racist by their manager to beat Rangers.


After all it was the same tims who disgraced Scotland with their mass banana throwing antics when Mark Walters arrived in Scotland.


As for "the creepy unScottishness of Ibrox" - I presume the author has never been at Ibrox where Saltires are found in abundance as opposed to the rampant McGeady tipe unScottishness found at the other side of the city.


The side where Celtic have been ashamed to be Scottish since 1888.





Liars with typewriters.
40

Wee Fred,

Riding the Rangers rollercoaster 04/05/2008 19:09:34
#29

Try this

http://www.bishop-accountability.org/
41

,

04/05/2008 20:39:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
42

Fanling,

Switzerland 04/05/2008 22:18:09
#1 James,,
Russian for "Come on St. Petersburg" is "zhivyei Sankt Petersburg!"

Aidan Smith isn't too far out with "... the creepy unScottishness of Ibrox." That might fairly describe both sides of the OF, however. As a Scotsman, I support all our representatives in Europe, and I'll be shouting for RFC in the final. I'd still like to see more positive evidence of their supposed Scottishness in the stands though.
43

Fanling,

Switzerland 05/05/2008 01:00:32
#44 invictager,Kent
"Where the hell does the idea that Rangers fans are anti Scottish come from"

Check out the proliferation of Union flags (long ago [mis]appropriated by the BNP) on show at every Rangers game home and away. Check out also the Rule Britannia, Land of Hope and Glory, God Save Our Gracious Queen "songs" at these games and maybe, just maybe, you will have the answer to your question. What's Scottish about any of that cringe-making crap?

In your youth it might have been different, as it was in mine. Now it is not so. Rational explanation on the back of a postage stamp please.

44

,

05/05/2008 13:38:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
45

Muttley.1,

Edinburgh 11/05/2008 09:47:24
You know, this is poorly written Mr Smith because this is not evidence based. This is your personal opinion and you should have pointed that out in your article. You are assuming a vast number of Scottish people will agree with your opinion and/or think like you. Judging by some of the above comments there is already a body of evidence they don't and therefore it is dangerous to make such assumptions. Why don't editors read copy before the papers are sent out to print?
46

Bemused and above it all,

12/05/2008 16:44:13
Righto, so Rangers are Un-Scottish, Ibrox is Un-scottish?
Remind me what does IBROX translate as?
47

Bemused and above it all,

12/05/2008 16:49:19
oh come on now, where are all these non-rangers SCOTS?
Ibrox translation?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.