Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 4th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Eddie Barnes: Eco-trendy message fails when they over-egg the pudding



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

I WOULD like to make a public apology. I deeply regret the circumstances that have forced me here. But I believe that all of us have to take responsibility for our conduct and open ourselves to public scrutiny.
Three years ago, I bought a Toyota Prius. I can confirm that I still own the Toyota Prius. The circumstances by which the purchase of the Prius came about were, I maintain, honourable; we wanted to buy a car that might not damage the air quite so bad
ly as all the rest of the cars out there. Of course I now realise I made a mistake. I did not realise that in buying a Toyota Prius I would be becoming a willing participant in the great global green witch-hunt against the rest of you blameless motorists out there, piling on your guilt about the terrible damage you are doing to the environment.

I have made my mistake. Now I would be grateful if you would all allow me to get on with the rest of my life.

I feel an apology for my greenie behaviour is necessary following the publication last week of possibly the most patronising, supercilious news release I have ever read – and that takes some beating. "Give your car, your environment and yourself a break this Easter," the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Sepa) declared. It's worth reprinting in full.

"Taking time out to enjoy your local environment might make you and the planet feel that little bit better this Easter," it chirrups. "Avoid the traffic jams, take a walk. No matter where you live, you are never far from something beautiful or interesting to experience in Scotland. It could be a city park, a local museum or peaceful countryside, but so much more relaxing if you don't have a stressful drive."

Sick yet? No? There's more. "Get gardening. Whether you've a window box or a woodland, this is the perfect time to get out and active. If you've a family, make it fun and get your kids involved with growing something themselves, maybe even some organic veg for munching later in the year."

And now the coup de grace. "Eggs. Don't buy an over-packaged, disappointingly hollow chocolate Easter egg, go for the real thing instead. Have a laugh with friends and family by hard boiling some free range eggs, have a decorating contest and rolling the results down a hill at the end of a local walk."

Forget for a moment what Sepa is actually suggesting. Imagine instead writing this message and e-mailing it to your friends. See how staggeringly patronising it is? It's difficult to think of anything more contrived to make me want to trade in my Prius for the biggest gas-guzzling 4x4 that money can buy. Environment Minister Richard Lochhead was at it as well on Friday. "This year I want Scots to go the eggs-tra mile and recycle as much of their Easter egg packaging as possible," he declared. Yes, he really did say "eggs-tra".

The smug claim to moral authority which the green movement all to often adopts is now in serious danger of overriding all the work it has done to raise environmental issues. They had a warning when it emerged that Jeremy Clarkson is backed by many Britons as Prime Minister. Unfortunately, it appears that ministers' desire to salve their own consciences by appearing eco-trendy is more important than getting the public on their side.

The wrong-headedness of this approach should be all the more troubling as the country enters more seriously troubling times and the Politics of Plenty comes to an end. It's one thing urging people to eat organic food when food is plentiful and cheap. But when living starts getting harder and food costs start rising – as they now are – it's a different matter altogether.

The credit crunch is about to eat our economy whole, our jobs are about to be gulped down by the great recession monster, the value of our homes against which we have borrowed thousands are now vulnerable to City sharks. The last thing you want is some public agency twittering away about getting the "kids" to "munch" some organic veg.

If we are heading for an economic crisis, politicians must understand that their concerns about the way we run our lives will soon start to come a distant second place to more immediate and pressing concerns. Expensive organic produce, lifestyle choices and their concern with our "health and wellbeing" will fall on deaf ears to a public far more worried about how they are going to make ends meet.

And sales of Toyota Prius, I suspect will plummet. Although if you're looking for a second-hand one…

eddie.barnes@scotlandonsunday.com



The full article contains 807 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 22 March 2008 8:15 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: SOS News columnists
 
1

Sierra Foothills Scot,

Diamond Springs 23/03/2008 04:14:50
Pseudo-greenery is even worse than Eddie says. What about the mass conversion of crops to production of corn for ethanol? This is already driving up food prices worldwide. It has also contributed to increasing atmospheric carbon by requiring more energy to produce ethanol fuel than petroleum fuels. Ethanol fuel is also less efficient than petroleum fuel, so more of it is needed to keep the rest of the economy running. To rational people, this is insanity.
2

Unimpressed one,

23/03/2008 09:14:43
Welcome to the new century's trendiest religion.
3

Forward not Back,

23/03/2008 09:22:17
The Easter event of this nonsense is this week - Earth Hour.

My response: Every light ON while going out for a drive and being as fuel inefficient as possible. Turn your lights off so we can feel better about China opening a new coal fired power station every day.
4

The Strategist,

23/03/2008 09:35:07
The Govt is about to auction carbon credits hoping to raise £3bn to £4bn per annum which of course will disappear into the general tax pot.

No company with any sense should get involved in this scam.
5

Neil,

Glasgow 23/03/2008 12:30:11
SEPA employees thouisands, conceivably 10s of thousands of people. They have to occasionally do something to prove how useful they all are. This is the real reason bureaucrats support this nonsense - to scare the rest of us into paying for their bureaucratic empire building.
6

donald,

glasgow 23/03/2008 16:05:05
Eddi Barnse should make a public apology for his past Labour Party spin releases.
7

Guga II,

Rockall 23/03/2008 17:41:14
#6 Donald. I'll second that motion.
8

PL,

23/03/2008 20:07:48
I just read the press release and saw nothing wrong with it - not reading the rest.
STATEMENT OF THE BLINDINGLY OBVIOUS: The Scottish Environmental Protection Agency is tasked with protecting the environment. Therefore, it MUST, by its very nature, offer people advice. The comparision with one citizen e-mailing another is facile. Unless you think that those EMPLOYED to protect the environment should not try to influence the behaviour of those who damage the environment.
Perhaps Barnes DOES think this lol...? After his risible article about Salmond resigning when he loses a tokenistic independence referendum bill...I hadn't really noticed Barnes before, he was just plodding along in the background, but now...
His citizen-to-citizen comparison is the kind of argument one blunders into as a student debator and cringes at ten years later. It shows that he wrote this article with ZERO thought.
9

Hugo of Garven,

23/03/2008 20:43:13
#8 PL

There is no need to praise Eddy.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.